What if BaTan had perfromed after HuTi MS

funforfunonly thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Yesterdays Episode, We all know HuTi were the best and out of this world, Manav was unreal and super. Shweta K matched his steps, Yash Gauri didnt deserve what they got, Ght should have got more then Shweta Raja and Yash Gauri.. but I want to say one thing here....

What if Bakhtyar Tanaaz had perfromed after HuTi and ManShweta... There is noway they would have got 30 today compared to there performances...

What say?

Edited by funforfunonly - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

897

Users

10

Frequent Posters

jimhawkins thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
that is a very valid point... tanaz bakhtyar were serving the old wine in a new bottle... the concept was new(not that it was good) but the dance was the same thing we see each time... i don think they wud have got 30 as Mallaika said this was by far the best performance of NB...

pritilovesnb thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
Oh so first juges are biased, then TB are arrogant, then it's come down to order of performance? Man, some ppl just cannot digest others doing well. I thought HuTi danced brilliantly yesterday but there have also been times when I felt they were a bit overscored. All this TB bashing I think is just overt hatred of this jodi or overt jealousy.

Personally I love TB and HuTi and sometimes ManavShweta but this is lame. This is getting to be like all that Shweta bashing that was happening sometime ago. I don't particularly like her although I think she's the best female dancer by far but ppl used to keep deriding her unnecessarily.I guess now it's TB's turn, huh?
funforfunonly thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: .:Aphrodite:.

^^ dude chill!

funforfunonly isn't one of those blinded and biased fan. I don't think he means any harm, he's just saying how he feels

Thanks dear and I dont even worry when I am saying what I feel I fight for all though HuTi are my favs...

and by the way you read it well , ManShweta and BaTan...;) (its a joke frnds dont pounce).;)

Girl thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
i think judges have got partial towards tanaaz bakhtiyaar.... agreed they dance well but if u compare their performances, barring just few of them... their steps, style, everything has been same in most of their dances.... they dont give much of variety... even if they danced before hussain tina or shweta manav... still they didnt deserve 30
funforfunonly thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: pritilovesnb

Oh so first juges are biased, then TB are arrogant, then it's come down to order of performance? Man, some ppl just cannot digest others doing well. I thought HuTi danced brilliantly yesterday but there have also been times when I felt they were a bit overscored. All this TB bashing I think is just overt hatred of this jodi or overt jealousy.

Personally I love TB and HuTi and sometimes ManavShweta but this is lame. This is getting to be like all that Shweta bashing that was happening sometime ago. I don't particularly like her although I think she's the best female dancer by far but ppl used to keep deriding her unnecessarily.I guess now it's TB's turn, huh?

Also my dear frnd, as a judge one must realise and not give away full scores to one of the 1st performers. if they find anyone better there is a scope of appreciation, and if they dotn find anyone better dont give scores more then the initial performers is what we are talking abt.

pritilovesnb thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
yaar that makes zero sense to me. That means the judges wud have to keep underscoring those in the beginning. Let me ask u this- HuTi were brillaint, if they were the first performers then also judges shd not give 30???? Of course they shd as it is deserved. And by the way, you know the concept 'first among equals'? It means even if say three four ppl are 'equal' unmein bhi hierarchy hoti hai. That;s y last season they used to do that 10a 10b stuff which is just a gesture.These r my scores:

I would personally give Manav Shweta 30AAA 👏 👏 they were the BEST by far!!!!
Then HuTi with 3o and TB with 30.

Although TB is my fave I think ManavShweta were out of this world, even better than TB and HuTi ( and no, I am not a fan of ManavShweta I am just talking abt their dance)
coolfire thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8


Truly speaking the ONLY couple who ABSOLUTELY DID NOT DESERVE (sorry for using capital letters, but I strongly feel this) a 30 was Tanaaz Baktiyar. I have nothing against this couple, I think that they are very cute and I was even impressed by them in the romance round, But I'm just bored with them playing safe yaar! I mean they are such good dancers! Why don't they ever try risking doing new things?

I mean compared to manav-shweta and hussain-tina, neither did these people take any risk like hussain tina, nor was their dance superlatively different and "CLASS APART" like manav-shewta's....

No offense to any tanaaz-bak fans but I'm sorry to say that I wonder how many times will they keep getting 30 on same ghisa pita uchal kudne wala steps again and again. The only change I saw was on the romance round and I thought that it was their best performance by far, and sadly, it still remains their best. Kyunki uske baad this couple has not given any variety AT ALL.

Besides that, all the other dances have the same feel... similar hype, only slightly different concept, thats it! Please feel free to disagree on this with me, but thats what I strongly feel. Like some rightly described, they are "selling old wine in a new bottle"

Agreed their performance has energy. But energy is not everything! ... kuch toh points concept, innovation, risk aur most importantly variety ko bhi milne chaiye naa.... Variety in the sense, variety of steps and dancing style not the concept or introduction. Tanaaz-bakhtiyar are doing the only thing that works for them wohi "engery bharaa uchal kuudna"

After all, audience WILL get bored after a point of time naa! Itne acche talent ko use nahi karenge toh. Also, I feel that this couple tends to choose famous "shah rukh khan" wala filmi songs which is bound to click with the audience. (not that I don't like the songs, actually I LOVE the songs, and thats my point!)

Audience toh audience, what I don't understand is that WHY AREN"T THE JUDGES SEEING THIS???? I mean, they said "hum bored ho gaye tum logo ko 10 deke" I was like unki ek hi repetitive dance style dekh ke bore nahi huwe kya? OPEN UP YOUR EYES JUDGES, first impression is not always last impression!

My views. Feel free to put in yours and critique mine!


funforfunonly thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: pritilovesnb

yaar that makes zero sense to me. That means the judges wud have to keep underscoring those in the beginning. Let me ask u this- HuTi were brillaint, if they were the first performers then also judges shd not give 30???? Of course they shd as it is deserved. And by the way, you know the concept 'first among equals'? It means even if say three four ppl are 'equal' unmein bhi hierarchy hoti hai. That;s y last season they used to do that 10a 10b stuff which is just a gesture.These r my scores:

I would personally give Manav Shweta 30AAA 👏 👏 they were the BEST by far!!!!
Then HuTi with 3o and TB with 30.

Although TB is my fave I think ManavShweta were out of this world, even better than TB and HuTi ( and no, I am not a fan of ManavShweta I am just talking abt their dance)

Exactly dear, lets go by your views, you would personally give Manav Shweta 30AAA 👏 👏and now here is what i am saying dont they desrve the best of the day as per you and they were at par with some one who were not as good as per you. Isnt it?

so I feel and its not underscoring, if no one is beetter then them, then no one will go above them so they will be the best of the day in anycase. Isnt it?

raunaq thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: coolfire



Truly speaking the ONLY couple who ABSOLUTELY DID NOT DESERVE (sorry for using capital letters, but I strongly feel this) a 30 was Tanaaz Baktiyar. I have nothing against this couple, I think that they are very cute and I was even impressed by them in the romance round, But I'm just bored with them playing safe yaar! I mean they are such good dancers! Why don't they ever try risking doing new things?

I mean compared to manav-shweta and hussain-tina, neither did these people take any risk like hussain tina, nor was their dance superlatively different and "CLASS APART" like manav-shewta's....

No offense to any tanaaz-bak fans but I'm sorry to say that I wonder how many times will they keep getting 30 on same ghisa pita uchal kudne wala steps again and again. The only change I saw was on the romance round and I thought that it was their best performance by far, and sadly, it still remains their best. Kyunki uske baad this couple has not given any variety AT ALL.

Besides that, all the other dances have the same feel... similar hype, only slightly different concept, thats it! Please feel free to disagree on this with me, but thats what I strongly feel. Like some rightly described, they are "selling old wine in a new bottle"

Agreed their performance has energy. But energy is not everything! ... kuch toh points concept, innovation, risk aur most importantly variety ko bhi milne chaiye naa.... Variety in the sense, variety of steps and dancing style not the concept or introduction. Tanaaz-bakhtiyar are doing the only thing that works for them wohi "engery bharaa uchal kuudna"

After all, audience WILL get bored after a point of time naa! Itne acche talent ko use nahi karenge toh. Also, I feel that this couple tends to choose famous "shah rukh khan" wala filmi songs which is bound to click with the audience. (not that I don't like the songs, actually I LOVE the songs, and thats my point!)

Audience toh audience, what I don't understand is that WHY AREN"T THE JUDGES SEEING THIS???? I mean, they said "hum bored ho gaye tum logo ko 10 deke" I was like unki ek hi repetitive dance style dekh ke bore nahi huwe kya? OPEN UP YOUR EYES JUDGES, first impression is not always last impression!

My views. Feel free to put in yours and critique mine!




that's what i felt and wrote in another message before reading this.....i didn't feel any kind of energy in their song, i mean one or two steps were similar to previous performances, i just dont know what to say, hussain tina and manav shweta were the best by far today 😛 did you see mini's face when hussain tina were being blindfolded 😕
Edited by raunaq - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".