Grand Finale Shaan Vs Shankar,Comments 4rm 2day!! - Page 25

Created

Last reply

Replies

277

Views

30k

Users

37

Likes

136

Frequent Posters

somone999 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
This match was the ultimate do or die one because both teams were equal. I knew that ultimately the medley will be the deciding factor, as we have seen in previous shows that individual performances get more or less the same marks from the audience, there is little variation rarely to be seen. Today's match was a good competition for both the teams. Both were winners yaar!, i loved all the performances from both the teams, i would have declared a tie myself. 😊

It is no use of arguing over spilt milk, what has been done has been done. Lets just hope that these people get a fair chance in bollywood someday. Especially Anwesha from Shaan's team and Rahul from Shankar's team. Best of luck to both of them!
navaneeta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: somone999

This match was the ultimate do or die one because both teams were equal. I knew that ultimately the medley will be the deciding factor, as we have seen in previous shows that individual performances get more or less the same marks from the audience, there is little variation rarely to be seen. Today's match was a good competition for both the teams. Both were winners yaar!, i loved all the performances from both the teams, i would have declared a tie myself. 😊

It is no use of arguing over spilt milk, what has been done has been done. Lets just hope that these people get a fair chance in bollywood someday. Especially Anwesha from Shaan's team and Rahul from Shankar's team. Best of luck to both of them!

Very true ... no-ones career would be at stake due to this MKMM ...
But as this particular thread is to discuss on finale, I have the same questions and trust me irrespective of the winner (as in both case it would have been pre-determined) the same basic public foolong concept remains ...
- Pre-recorded songs were asked to give marks
- A show telecasted as LIVE, but results were known before the medly round started confirming the winner to be pre-determined .... it does not matter even if Gajji would have decided to make Shaan's team winner and medly marks would have been other way round ... chori is chori ... be it 10 rs from Mr. X or 100 rs form Mr. Y
- Dil se round song were to be 1 soft, 2 emotional, 3 songs and Laundry was way far from all the three, so Gajji should have clear cut disqualified as it was not followed rules
And on Shankar M, as per my POV, he is great persona of the Industry and pride of country and as a result we all had much great hope from him on his fair play part but in this MKMM he has fully utilized all the show format loopholes in his favor, and his friend did open partiality and I wonder without any influence, why Gajji would have decided to make him the winner and not the more deserving team ... 😕 ... great public personalities carry some social and ethical responsibilities as public idolises them
an Example ... imagine our Sonia Gandhi or Mamata Banerjee in 'minis' smoking cigar and taking tequila shot in a discotheque .... now as an Indian citizen they can do that, they are entitled ... none of the above is a crime as per law ... but they have an image isn't it ????? But if a normal public do that .. no one would ever bother ....
Well I can conclude telling ... this was a full injustice with viewers votes and Gajji simply played with viewers emotion and this remains same even if Gajji determines other team to be the winner ... as Gajji should not determine, whole countries viewers need to determine ... who-ever be it ... but that's the dejected part of the show .. it's the same viewer based on whose vote and viewing Gajji gets his Rozi, Roti and Barkat in terms of show profit and TRP, so it was a foul act against your employer ....
Edited by navaneeta - 15 years ago
safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
We publics r not fools to accept shanakr and his rude rockstar,average singers as winner in compare to all teams specially strikers teams,..

we public can clearly read the injustice,politics played by gajji and how shankar manipulated the game in his side just sake of winning and played with innocent grt singers ansd hurted them,we 105 crores of public's heart has been hurted bec of shankar manipulation and gajji's politics,we never seen a man like javed,hate him giving too much biased marks just for sake of relation with shankar..javed dint even tried to go with truth and made winners wrong in prefinale whr shaan's strikers r d clear winner..

No one can accept on shaan's medely marks was 5,it may anyother music director,composer it may AR Rahman,or sonunigam,shreya,105 crores public will accept the truth how javed has played with shaan and his team by giving too biased marks,dirty politics to make someone winner who is closed to him,just sake of his lyricst career,or his son career..

and in grand finale thy gaved rahul average performance,which we cant think in dilse round it should be 3 to 4 wen shaans medely was 5..how dare thy can give 9 infront of anwesha's amazing,beautiful performances.thr dj round marks should be 9 infront of strikers amazing performance.in hit pe hit rockstars deserve 8 marks infront of strikers performances..

Medely round thy gave high marks to only repeatative songs played and w/o theme,just show off,just see shaan's medely again wat a concept,wat a perfomances,singing by all,while shankar itself goes on singing repeatative songs in his medely..

OFFFFFFFFF shankar shnakr shankar one man show..wat about the hardwork of strikers,honesty,fair play from shaan's strikers while rockstar never play fair,always we get to see thr captains performing infront of strikers..

This rockstars victory never consider as victory,this victory will consider as biggest crime on shaan's strikers,politics,manipulation done to loss strikers..too unfair all should has to ready to pay for the sins how thy manipulate,4 thr politics,and main javed u will pay 4 sins that how much u biased on strikers in prefinale and get thr winning marks in a last moment and gaved to shankar rockstars for relationship reason,its not look worth for a grt senior lyricst,who doesnt ve much knowlede in judgung music,i dono how thy invited,just to make shankar winner of this show..

All and all one man show😡...
324284 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
I have been calling this show as a crap show since long time back . People realized this only after Shaan lost the finale. Before that people just didnt want to believe this as a crap show despite knowing tht Gajjiman is the master of the manipulator.
safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
we just ve faith on public votes,strikers amazing performances and a grt captaincy of shaan,but this made lost bec of shankar manipulation,drity poitics by gajji..this crap show tried thr level best to go against shaan's strikers from the first episode 19th december wer shaan was clear winner,but this crap show made himmy winner by declaring 78+43=123.5,same on calculation..

But thy cant do those for all time bec shaan and his team was amazing to make them loss match its impossible,so in semifinals wen shankar star manipulating the game his side,every judges,gajji,all supported injustice and still grand finale thy tried to say victory was rockstars,noone can accept this..

Shaan 105 crores public has declared u as winner.U R D Real winner..
susm8 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: ashraynaik

Supporting one team need not make you blind to the good singers in other teams....
But of course you are not as open minded as me.



Neeti/Neetu Mohan is in wrong proffesion.. She is not a singer but she likes singing as some hobby and she is too hot and kinda eye candy.. Best profession for her is Bar Singer.. Arre Daaru peene ke bad kisi ko sur taal ka khayal nahi hota hai sab aisehi jhoomte hai!! Cheers Neeti/Neetu...🤣🤣🤣
Edited by susm8 - 15 years ago
rahul_02006 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: safeenafarheen

We publics r not fools to accept shanakr and his rude rockstar,average singers as winner in compare to all teams specially strikers teams,..

we public can clearly read the injustice,politics played by gajji and how shankar manipulated the game in his side just sake of winning and played with innocent grt singers ansd hurted them,we 105 crores of public's heart has been hurted bec of shankar manipulation and gajji's politics,we never seen a man like javed,hate him giving too much biased marks just for sake of relation with shankar..javed dint even tried to go with truth and made winners wrong in prefinale whr shaan's strikers r d clear winner..

No one can accept on shaan's medely marks was 5,it may anyother music director,composer it may AR Rahman,or sonunigam,shreya,105 crores public will accept the truth how javed has played with shaan and his team by giving too biased marks,dirty politics to make someone winner who is closed to him,just sake of his lyricst career,or his son career..

and in grand finale thy gaved rahul average performance,which we cant think in dilse round it should be 3 to 4 wen shaans medely was 5..how dare thy can give 9 infront of anwesha's amazing,beautiful performances.thr dj round marks should be 9 infront of strikers amazing performance.in hit pe hit rockstars deserve 8 marks infront of strikers performances..

Medely round thy gave high marks to only repeatative songs played and w/o theme,just show off,just see shaan's medely again wat a concept,wat a perfomances,singing by all,while shankar itself goes on singing repeatative songs in his medely..

OFFFFFFFFF shankar shnakr shankar one man show..wat about the hardwork of strikers,honesty,fair play from shaan's strikers while rockstar never play fair,always we get to see thr captains performing infront of strikers..

This rockstars victory never consider as victory,this victory will consider as biggest crime on shaan's strikers,politics,manipulation done to loss strikers..too unfair all should has to ready to pay for the sins how thy manipulate,4 thr politics,and main javed u will pay 4 sins that how much u biased on strikers in prefinale and get thr winning marks in a last moment and gaved to shankar rockstars for relationship reason,its not look worth for a grt senior lyricst,who doesnt ve much knowlede in judgung music,i dono how thy invited,just to make shankar winner of this show..

All and all one man show😡...

What 105 crores????? what r u talking?? If Shaan got more votes doesnt mean Shankar dint get any..I think he got 4 times more votes in mumbai....there are much much less people who vote then who dont. Just bcos u see more people in this forum and the internet who r shaan fans then Shankar doesnt mean much everyone is.
If you think its wrong rahul got 9 when Anwesha was singing...if u talk about fairness there is no way for a few songs that Shankar sang anyone on the show deserves more then 5 or 6.
If u think J.A was biased then I think people and audience are much more biased then J.A ever could be on the show.
Shankar's Rockstars totally deserved it.... :)
SayCheese thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
I don't think i am going to watch the finale first of all Shaan lost and secondly Shreya isnt going to be there
Edited by Shayal_Kumar - 15 years ago
doladi thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Shankar is a good singer, certainly very talented and one of the best. But not a good Leader. Perhaps didnt have much confidence in his own team or simply was possessed of winning.
On the other had Shaan is a good singer and a very good Leader. He demonstrated great leadership skills by utilizing all his team members. Its really sad that he didnt win.
Show producers are using us - the viewers and audience as scape goats..and playing us games.
susm8 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: rahul_02006

What 105 crores????? what r u talking?? If Shaan got more votes doesnt mean Shankar dint get any..I think he got 4 times more votes in mumbai....there are much much less people who vote then who dont. Just bcos u see more people in this forum and the internet who r shaan fans then Shankar doesnt mean much everyone is.
If you think its wrong rahul got 9 when Anwesha was singing...if u talk about fairness there is no way for a few songs that Shankar sang anyone on the show deserves more then 5 or 6.
If u think J.A was biased then I think people and audience are much more biased then J.A ever could be on the show.
Shankar's Rockstars totally deserved it.... :)


4 times more Vote in mumbai.. So do you think mumbai is the decider and the rest of the country is crap?? People and audience are biased??.. You mean PUBLIC and MAJOR MAJORITY of the people in the whole Country are Biased?? And you are the god or something who has to tell the PUBLIC whats right and whats wrong??? Bhai/Behan tu hai kaun be PUBLIC ko batane wala whats right and whats wrong??.. PUBLIC has given its decision and SHAAN STRIKERS are undisputed WINNER of MKMM 2010 both in Singing/Performances and PUBLIC Vote!! Congrats Shaan Strikers!! Now thats the TRUTH which I am not saying but the whole country is Saying.... Any Doubt?

SARKAR uska hi banta hai jo MAJOR MAJORITY of PUBLIC support and appreciation (Vote) gain karta hai.. Sad that this Show raped this Democracy!!



Edited by susm8 - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".