Critics Review - Mod Note Pg. 67. - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

569

Views

47.2k

Users

100

Likes

1.9k

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#71
Exactly....they are making Mayank bipolar as usual....first they'll show him as the mega understanding, ready to be 'shaheed' in lowe type of loverboy for like centuries than magically he turns to tantrum throwing angry young man.....granted that ppl with a temper just have a snapping point and that's not something that can be explained logically but this entire premise in the show is too ridiculous for words.

The fights in the past still had some kind of basis....TP fight: Nupur DID purposely lie to him and he was justified in his anger....Drug track: Kinda ridiculous to begin with but still Nupur's POV was understandable and she was trying to help him in her own way and he was too harsh in his anger yelling at her...but this time.....this entire shaadi b.s. is just too ridiculous to be firstly shown as a 'track' and then construct these stupid 'fights' around it in order to give 'movement' to the storyline....I can see exactly what kind of 'movement' is happening in this 'story' *rolls eyes*

This is just an excuse to change the setting...since the 'creativity' of showing college issues already seems to have died out....LOLL....so off to Morena to give the 'dilwales' a chance to go running after their 'dulhaniyaas' to their hometowns.....I'm overjoyed *yawns*
Bazinga thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: nureat01

Exactly....they are making Mayank bipolar as usual....first they'll show him as the mega understanding, ready to be 'shaheed' in lowe type of loverboy for like centuries than magically he turns to tantrum throwing angry young man.....granted that ppl with a temper just have a snapping point and that's not something that can be explained logically but this entire premise in the show is too ridiculous for words.

The fights in the past still had some kind of basis....TP fight: Nupur DID purposely lie to him and he was justified in his anger....Drug track: Kinda ridiculous to begin with but still Nupur's POV was understandable and she was trying to help him in her own way and he was too harsh in his anger yelling at her...but this time.....this entire shaadi b.s. is just too ridiculous to be firstly shown as a 'track' and then construct these stupid 'fights' around it in order to give 'movement' to the storyline....I can see exactly what kind of 'movement' is happening in this 'story' *rolls eyes*

This is just an excuse to change the setting...since the 'creativity' of showing college issues already seems to have died out....LOLL....so off to Morena to give the 'dilwales' a chance to go running after their 'dulhaniyaas' to their hometowns.....I'm overjoyed *yawns*



Bingo Anu! When I am watching the show I can clearly see that the creatives have completely run out of ideas and have no clue what to do with MN, or for that matter even SG which is probably why they are DRAAAGGGGING n PROLOOOOOOONGING the confession, they are not sure what is to be done next with either of the couples so think of a vacation track in Morena, send the guys to Morena to woo their gals- show more naach-gaana in the shaadi, more mindless buffoonery in the name of "shaadi ki masti", kheton main romance instead of class room this time & give N's dumbness a boost in home turf in a WEDDING - kya "creativity" hai BY GOD 👏 👏. I can even guess the Sony songs that would be played this time - Maahi Ve from KHNH n guess what's more? We will have N imagining her mehndi ceremony this time on the lyrics "barse rangeeni kaliyaan hai mehki.......baje mann main halke halke shehnaai rey" and then Mayank standing between Moon n Star cut outs in some hideous white outfit on the lyrics "Jitne hai taare , aanchal main aa gaye saare *N will be hugging star cut outs here*.......". May be the small town locations are easier to acquire so no worries about getting shooting locations, which will give them ample of time to "think" about such 'brilliant' scenes n songs & also 'HOW' to shoot them 'beautifully' 😃

Its a different thing that we can SEE just how much scope there is to MN's story but then that doesn't fall in the range of their "kick-ass- ness" , does it?

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: Kavya_KraZQueen

on the lyrics "Jitne hai taare , aanchal main aa gaye saare *N will be hugging star cut outs here*.......". LMAOOOOOOO🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Kavya yaar, don't give them more cutout ideas than they already have🤣🤣🤣🤣

May be the small town locations are easier to acquire so no worries about getting shooting locations, which will give them ample of time to "think" about such 'brilliant' scenes n songs & also 'HOW' to shoot them 'beautifully' 😃 Sahi jawaab😳😳....but what makes you think they'll ACTUALLY go to a real small town to shoot this?😆😆 Kisi chindi set pe shoot kar lenge, pucca🤣

Its a different thing that we can SEE just how much scope there is to MN's story but then that doesn't fall in the range of their "kick-ass- ness" , does it?
We are childish, immature haters, Kavya....what do WE know about being able to see a story for MN??😆

Bazinga thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#74
Edited by Kavya_KraZQueen - 15 years ago
psycho_angel thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#75
i have an important question.if MN convo holds water,then they have an important exam coming up,right?on the other hand they are about to have a holiday.weird,eh?😲
incandescence thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#76
Adi....bache the way they have been studying and attending classes......it's better for them to just run away before their exams.....
psycho_angel thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#77

Originally posted by: mashaal

Adi....bache the way they have been studying and attending classes......it's better for them to just run away before their exams.....



so true😆
petticoat thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: mashaal

Adi....bache the way they have been studying and attending classes......it's better for them to just run away before their exams.....



im happy u said RUN and not ELOPE!😛
-Mystery- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: Kavya_KraZQueen

@Divya: I agree with you about the lameness of the fight, once again it was only Ar-Ti , especially Rati who stole the show. As much as I found the premise most pathetic n frivolous, Rati made me feel N's pain. N was genuinely not at fault this time, she tried her level best to conceal but the trio tricked her n got her to blurt out the truth, M did not think twice or give her a chance to explain herself, he jumped to conclusions about her quite quickly once again which makes this whole issue baseless n M's character quite inconsistent actually. M had shown us all this while that he REALLY knew N well n understood her, he put up with all her ridiculous demands to the level of stripping himself of his self respect PLUS this is not the first time that he did not give her a chance to explain n rushed to conclusions about her - he is REPEATING the same since TP. First TP, then drug track n now THIS & this is supposed to be our perfectionist Mayank who would not have repeated the same mistake again n again n again.

Plate throwing in anger is quite OTT which is SO not Mayank, I can understand Mayank's hot temper coz when I am seething with rage even I feel like breaking things to vent it out but I caution myself n think rationally even in that moment of fury simply because I am not foolish enough to waste my parents' money for my anger venting, its something that would go with M's character as well.



EXACTLY! You said it! Wasn't it Mayank who said something like "Revenge is best when served cold?" He's hot tempered but he is also the intelligent guy who's supposed to use his mind most of all. Seems like the only time he doesn't use it is when he's in a fight with Nupur.

If he understands her so well, why can't he give her a chance to explain her side? After he had asked not to tell anyone, she wouldn't have taken a mike and announced that they are in a relationship. Besides what if she told them? Benji and Dia are family.

-Mahi
Bazinga thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: -Mystery-


EXACTLY! You said it! Wasn't it Mayank who said something like "Revenge is best when served cold?" He's hot tempered but he is also the intelligent guy who's supposed to use his mind most of all. Seems like the only time he doesn't use it is when he's in a fight with Nupur.

If he understands her so well, why can't he give her a chance to explain her side? After he had asked not to tell anyone, she wouldn't have taken a mike and announced that they are in a relationship. Besides what if she told them? Benji and Dia are family.

-Mahi



I agree with you about everything else except for the bold part. Firstly Dodo & Dia are N's family, not his, secondly N would not think of it as a big deal but it IS a big deal for M; N saying "what difference does it make?" from her standpoint is easy but thinking what difference it ACTUALLY makes to M by looking at it from his perspective is what really puts the same thing in a totally different & quite serious light (I am not saying N is wrong here , I know she used that line in order to defend herself but from M's POV that is a careless comment) because he is someone who would not appreciate others knowing about his personal feelings, he is not the kind of person who would want his feelings (which he values a lot ) to provide fodder for others' idle gossip (N doesn't care what the world thinks about them, neither does M but while N would not bother whether she is giving people a chance to talk about them, M WOULD) which is why he put his foot down against making their relationship public in the first place . However, N's reasoning about the same (making relationship public) & her insecurities did seem valid to him so he asked her for sometime to think this out carefully before they can tell everyone in such a way so as to avoid being everyone's topic of discussion to some extent at least & at the same time allay N's fears. It was a plan which has been interrupted in between so M did not take too kindly to it, I can understand his anger about it but my main issue is his rationality going for a toss, I could have bought this kind of reaction to N had they NOT been a couple already but we were shown MN literally sticking to each other since confession so they should have formed a basic level of understanding at least (now I guess everyone gets why some of us have been stressing on the emotional bonding of MN for AAAAGESSS). One would particularly expect M to give N a fair chance this time because this is not the first time he didn't give her a chance to explain herself, how long will we be shown M repeating the same mistake again & again? Is that ALL there is to M's character or MN's relationship? Romance- fight-patch-up routine & comedy - that is ALL that defines MN? Where is the depth? When were we shown the strength of their bond by a proper build up of a bond between them for it to be 'tested' now?


Edited by Kavya_KraZQueen - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".