Copycat Creatives - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

42

Views

4.3k

Users

25

Likes

93

Frequent Posters

-Nymphadora- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#31
in the mayur cases....it was done on purpose so dat mayu can impress a very filmy person....about the oethers i dunno wad to say!!
nehlove thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#32
Thanks to the DT (Mods and GMs) who took the matter into their own hands realizing that this topic was NOT instigating towards any particular member. We appreciate you re-opening the thread.
nehlove thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: DMGFan-2b-not2b

While the creatives may well be lifting ideas, isn't that what everyone wanted? That they take your suggestions? Then why is everyone upset? Maybe someone should tell PD to come and say that they have taken your suggestions but honestly does anyone expect them to put out a credit after each episode that states "inspired by IF?"

So decide you want them to take your suggestions or you dont?

They should take our suggestions NOT copy them. IMHO, if you are a creative you should use your own creativity to place those suggestions in the storyline.... And honestly I would rather they don't take our suggestions and use what they have learnt in the gazillion creative writing lessons. I mean that is what you are there for. Its not our job to give you suggestions. And when we do... the creatives should be smart enough to pick what fits and let go of what doesn't. The MJHT creatives have failed to do so in a "creative" manner.
Plus, this term that I am particularly talking about "chaddi buddy"..... It was used in the context of Mayank-Sammy. I don't understand why suddenly they felt the need to use it in the scene. It was sooo unneccesary and totally plagiarized.
And yes, if they ARE taking suggestions from IF they SHOULD credit out in the end saying "Special thanks to IF"..... It is NOT right for them to take credit for something that they have NOT brainstormed. People who make such comments have a talent of their own to come up with such witty stuff at the spur of the moment and it is only fair that they would be credited... if not by name atleast by the mention of IF. If you can't find a small space for a simple line like "Special thanks to IF"... Well then, DON'T use the comments/phrases/scenes.
Eloquent thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: akshiee

completely agreed that they have copied but to arrange the copied stuff is not a simple taskkk.....and btw dont u like the scenes??? and r u actually relating the scenes to the movies???if so what a waste of tym......nd honestly if u dont like the show please its a humble request that stop watching it.......im sure there r loads of ppl who actually like the show so pls stop criticizing it also.....thanx...



Well...since I just came by this topic!😆😆😆

Well..for the bolded part: Actually NO! I do not and never will like anything which is so blatantly copied!😆😉
And all of these movies and these scenes have been copied waaayyyyyyy too many times now....for me to even find any freshness 😕🥱 They have been copied in every star one soap of recent times!😆😆😆


As for the second part...about "arranging the copied stuff": arrey yaar....copying is copying....and arranging stuff isn't all that hard when you compare it to working to make up your own scenes and creative ideas!

They can atleast show the credits...!

🥱
petticoat thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#35
LOL

yea

thanks shruti for reopening the topic!


well my grievance is there have been so many better ideas suggested in the forum.. why not copy that..why copy our silly lingo and too many movies that the show becomes unrecognizable..

and yes when they copy utterly..a certain credit should be attributed!
-Rinky- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#36

Note:

India Forums does not permit posting of any content or material which is or can be construed as being

  • sexually explicit, po*nographic
  • offensive to any religion, race or community
  • abusive language or Derogatory Expressions.
  • violative of anothers Intellectual Property
I have just quoted whats there on the right of every "Quick Reply" section...

@blue-says it all......
prerna_agrawal thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#37
i don't think so coz "chaddi buddies" is very common term......and this isn't copying.....and the scenes that u've mentioned...many of them were already shown in the show that they are lifted.....
this is just my pov....i'm sorry if someone feels offended!!...i didn't mean to...
Madiha_20 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#38
I have a feeling that the creatives think that we are to dumb to notice stufff like that....:( LOL... And all the copying from movies just shows that the creatives need originality ;)

Madiha
myownarea thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#39
Its a little weird, when I started watching the show somewhere in the middle..I liked the bit I saw n went to utube to check out the earlier episodes n I was not too happy cos I went ..jab we met, qsqt, kkhh..so on n so forth. It was an endless medley of ideas taken from various sources..
Since I wasnt so clued in on the soaps in general, until I came into IF I had no idea that this is not necessarily the norm..
Oh well..i m happy when they show original scenes..I never visit the CJ cos the person responsible for the show shud do their job without my interference(thats just my thought)..to others..to each their own..I've no qualms if ideas are suggested by others n they get implemented..but I think its inappropriate if other's ideas r taken without proper credit.

Knowalot2 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 16 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: nehlove

Now they have openly started copying lines from the forum without crediting any of the members...



I think Someone else had mentioned that particular phrase in the Creatives Jannat.
Therefore that quote was used in the show. She probably didn't know that that person wasn't the inventor who had coined up that phrase.

Isn't that what the Creatives Jannat is for? For sharing our ideas with the creatives? ...isn't that the point of the Creatives Jannat...so that she can use our ideas?


And about using ideas...well aren't ur ideas coming from the Creative's show in the first place?


The phrase isn't copyrighted- so legally there's nothing wrong.
Also another MJHT forum member had coined up a different phrase...when she found out, she was over the moon..and was incredibly happy to know that the creatives used her phrase in the show!
- a completely different reaction!


^^Feel free to correct me if u think I'm wrong- I'm just stating my opinion😊


Edited by Knowalot2 - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".