-#::: Taraka mitra Karna - Aham Sharma - AT 26 :::#- - Page 11

Poll

Who do you think cared the most for Karna despite of his any attitude?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

69.1k

Users

26

Likes

1.5k

Frequent Posters

Brahmaputra thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
My vote goes for Bheeshma, probably a person who gave him the love and true respect he deserved. It is true that Bheeshma had confronted him many times. But he also gave the reasons for that. Their last conversation is really a deep and mind disturbing one. It is also notable that despite being insulted many times, Karna had utmost respect for Bheeshma which means somewhere he had felt the care of a grand father like person from him. Else there was no reason for Karna to visit Bheeshma to speak out his heart. Also had he been truly dislikng Karna, there was no reason for him to have love and care filled words for Karna. Bheeshma had lived a life knowing who really Karna was, loving him, but showing disgust thinking that would make him choose not the wrong path for himself! Hence my vote is for Bheeshma.
Edited by Brahmaputra - 10 years ago
Sanskruthi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Brahmaputra

My vote goes for Bheeshma, probably the only person who gave him the love and true respect he deserved. It is true that Bheeshma had confronted him many times. But he also gave the reasons for that. Their last conversation is really a deep and mind disturbing one. It is also notable that despite insulting him many times, Karna had utmost respect for Bheeshma which means somewhere he had felt the care of a grand father like person from him. Else there was no reason for Karna to visit Bheeshma to speak out his heart. Bheeshma had lived a life knowing who really Karna was, loving him, but showing disgust thinking that would make him choose not the wrong path for himself! Hence my vote is for Bheeshma.

R: I don't question their love for each other that's true it was Bheeshma only who recognised Karna's skills at the Arena
B&P:Again the same question hits me Why didn't he declare that Karna, too, was his great-grandnephew like Arjuna and Duryodhana, why didn't he give him his due right as the oldest Kuru prince? Why, was he silent when the grossest injustice was done to him? Why didn't he recognize Karna as his great-grandnephew at the archery contest at Hastinapur "that he was a royal-born man. That he was the eldest Pandava, the eldest Kuru grandson, fit to be the scion of kuru royal family. If he had publicly declared that, he would not be facing the worst moments of his life. and Bhima too mocked him as a sutaputra, why was he and Kunti silent then?

My question still lies there WHY ONLY BEFORE THE WAR WHY NOT EARLIER? WHY ONLY THEN WHEN THERE AS NO SOLUTION NO AMENDMENT POSSIBLE?
Sphinx. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
^^^^ YES...I too have the same question😕
Sanskruthi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: dhivyakrish31

^^^^ YES...I too have the same question😕

You r still there😲😲
What about Diwali shopping😕
Or the fear that we r running is bringing u back🤣
kumki thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
I am short of posts.. So I m replying in one post guys 😳


Originally posted by: Brahmaputra

swathi- your reply made me ROFL.🤣

swathi & vani- I too have the heard the idea of Virata war being a later interpolation. But what makes you guys think so? Any sound fact supporting it?


Thanks Jamy.
I had so much wanted Karna-Kunti convo after VH in the show., to see her aghast at her jyesht beta's acts., we all know how often they interact here. but., CVs conveniently skipped it.. 🥺

I guess I will fulfill all my wishes with EpicKarna in this game! 😈

No., I don't have anything supporting it. I just read it somewhere & don't believe it either,. I just mentioned it to say how fans accept one as fact and conveniently ignore the other as it doesn't do them any favour.

Originally posted by: Sanskrutiii

Hmm you sound very convincing But I have mine questions too😛
If Krishna knew the truth then y didn't he reveal it Before??
Maybe bcoz it was Kunti's secret but the same question in her case too! Why only before the war? Why didn't she go to the pandavas after Karna refused?? It's not like she abandoned him only after his birth but every time she met him😭 only the thing that irritates me is Why not before why only before the war???


For Krishna..

I think I can give the same reasoning again., he nvr had a reason to reveal it before., and most importantly he was not obliged to reveal to Karna like Kunti & Surya Dev were...

unlike the serial or other novels portrayal., Krishna was nvr the preachy kinds and had nvr met or had conversation with Karna bfr in epic., remember Krishna was BFF of his arch rival., friend of a woman who was insulted by Karna., ..
Since., the peace treaty failed., he might have thought it was high time to reveal., and do some favour for Karna.. again I tell u he was not obliged even at this point of time., it was out of his own interest., he did it..

I m sorry to pull Karna's pitashree here., but even he didnt reveal the truth until Kunti came to Karna., maybe as many claim it was Kunti's secret so he could not reveal..
so., the same would apply to Krishna., but he took a better decision of it revealing for Karna's good.. rather than keeping mum...

And., Kunti - wala part.. u got me wrong dear... 😆
I was completely being sarcastic 😆., I understand why she abandoned him., but can nvr forgive her for revealing the truth at 11th hour... they pretty much built up her char in the serial to show us that she loved her Karna the MOST.
So., I made a joke of it ... 🤪

Originally posted by: Brahmaputra

I really liked your reasoning for Krishna, swathi.


Glad you liked it.
Was really conflicted with your question., I had to give a lot of thought.. and finally voted today
Edited by swathi.priya - 10 years ago
LadyMacbeth thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
Sanskruthi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: swathi.priya

I am short of posts.. So I m replying in one post guys 😳
Hmm I can understand😊 you r a groupbie yet😛


For Krishna..

I think I can give the same reasoning again., he nvr had a reason to reveal it before., and most importantly he was not obliged to reveal to Karna like Kunti & Surya Dev were...

unlike the serial or other novels portrayal., Krishna was nvr the preachy kinds and had nvr met or had conversation with Karna bfr in epic., remember Krishna was BFF of his arch rival., friend of a woman who was insulted by Karna., ..
Since., the peace treaty failed., he might have thought it was high time to reveal., and do some favour for Karna.. again I tell u he was not obliged even at this point of time., it was out of his own interest., he did it..

I m sorry to pull Karna's pitashree here., but even he didnt reveal the truth until Kunti came to Karna., maybe as many claim it was Kunti's secret so he could not reveal..
so., the same would apply to Krishna., but he took a better decision of it revealing for Karna's good.. rather than keeping mum...

R; EXACTLY That's what I too feel
About Krishna he is someone who easily get into your Heart but it's difficult to get into his head I admit
B; But again why didn't he tell his BFf the truth😕 I really wonder had the pandavas knew the truth Would they point out Sword to Karna😕
And., Kunti - wala part.. u got me wrong dear... 😆
I was completely being sarcastic 😆., I understand why she abandoned him., but can nvr forgive her for revealing the truth at 11th hour... they pretty much built up her char in the serial to show us that she loved her Karna the MOST.
So., I made a joke of it ... 🤪
I undrstood your Joke😆 but just wanted to blurt out the Anguish I have for Kunti😡
This is providing me the correct platform😈
...
Sorry for the late reply
Anyways I am leaving now Bye See u in the eve or 2morow only😊

MsChanadlerBong thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
Hey I m here sautan ji and this sure is awesome 👍🏼 can I join this too just askin if not it is okay
Sanskruthi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Texie

Hey I m here sautan ji and this sure is awesome 👍🏼 can I join this too just askin if not it is okay

You can surely join here
Karna admirers always Welcomed dear😃
Just hit like to the post on the first page😊
And Welcome🤗
MsChanadlerBong thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Sanskrutiii

You can surely join here
Karna admirers always Welcomed dear😃
Just hit like to the post on the first page😊
And Welcome🤗

okay sautan ji will do that 😉😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".