RK Vs Sultan - Character Sketch Analysis..!!!

-Dil- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Okay...No two words about it...!!😃This post is in direct response to all the posts which called RK a psycho, a disturbed character etc..etc...😉All right..it's your POV..and I respect it..😳

But As Newton uncle said, Every action has equal and opposite reaction..!!!😉

So, now my two cents worth about the whole "Sultan track"...!!😳

First of all, I would really like to kick the CV's b**t for totally dividing this forum into parts..!!😡🤢Along with playing with the characters, they are playing with our sense and sensibilities too..!!!It's all their FAULT..!!!😃

Sultan...😊Let me begin by saying I have no problem with Avinesh Rekhi..I just find his track in the show MAHA BORING and CONFUSING..!!!😳

RK's character is behaving a little over the top now, no doubt about it...And I'm not defending RK for what he's doing now with MB here either..!!😳 BUT, fans have had entire 11 months to dissect, analyse and understand his character.No one can object to the fact that he's one of the most well developed and most unique characters on TV right now or EVER right...?!!!😳

But Sultan's character has been changing its colors on daily basis ever since it's inception..!!

Sample this..

One fine day- Sultan emerges from water like a fearless warrior, destroying the obstacles in his way..
Next week - We find him HIDING from one of his underlings in a CHAWL...!!!

One fine day- He's a BAD father, who made his OWN son a human bait..!!
Next week- He's a GREAT father, who's playing color color with his son..!!😊

A day ago- He's involved in a shoot-out in the chawl, in plain view of everyone..!!
A day later - He's seen strolling into the chawl with a picnic basket, as if he's the most respected member of community...!!😳

A day ago- He's reminiscing about his dead(??) wife fondly and with emotions...!!
A day later - He's all blushing and day-dreaming over someone else's wife..!!(before y'all erupt, RK did tell him Mb was his wife on holi day and NO-ONE contradicted, neither MB nor Sultan..!!)

A day ago- There was danger to his and his family's life, so he fled from his house..!!
A day later - He's back in his own house, like nothing of that sort EVER happened, and the enemy, hence the danger, isn't over yet...!!😲

A day ago - He said an emotional "Alvida"...!!
A day later - There..He's back AGAIN...!!!😆

and Finally,

3 weeks ago - An emotionless gangsta..!!
Now -A blushing lover boy(mature and sensible of course..Unlike RK..😉)..!!

And all this happened in a matter of "THREE WHOLE WEEKS"...!!!😉😆

How can one relate to a character which isn't stable from one day to next..??!!!😲Which changes it's colors like a chameleon every other minute..??!!😲RK, even in his full-on revenge mode knew that any change had to be GRADUAL to be BELIEVABLE and planned his game plan accordingly...!!!!😳😆Sounds like the CV's brain-child is far more intelligent than the CV's themselves...LOL..!!😆😆

Now, I'm not blaming AR/Sultan for this khichdi, but the CV's for not knowing their own MIND and giving him a completely hopscotched character...!!!😲😳

Now comparing the evolution of two characters..RK and Sultan..!!!

RK - Had a sad past (a well explained one), which he decided to overcome by killing the "Rishabh" in him and becoming "RK", he took up ACTING..!!😊

Sultan - Had a past (not well explained , but I have hopes), which he decided to overcome by killing people and becoming "Mumbai ka Sultan", he took up ARMS..!!😲

So I would like to say,

If RK is a man with some HUGE flaws, Sultan's whole being is a flaw(He's a mob boss as per the present track)..!!
If RK is a Social and egoistic animal, Sultan himself is anti-social(based on the present track)...!!!

So, There seems to be scope for redeeming RK's character, but Sultan's character...??Unless they change his character from gangster to something else, Not so sure..!!😳

If CV's make Sultan some kind of cop now, I'll have to add another to the above list...😉

One fine day - A dreaded don..!!
Next day - Was I watching the same show..???!!😛😆

We all have our favourites, our opinions..😊As the above post is my opinion, my right...Everyone has their own opinions and it's their right too..!!So I'm in no way forcing my opinions on to anyone..but just sharing my thoughts on the "present raitha of the show"..!!😳
I have not called anyone names, or my tone in the post hasn't been harsh either, I hope..!!😳

Sayonaara...😃😉
Edited by dilnasheen - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

69

Views

6.3k

Users

31

Likes

127

Frequent Posters

duaa92 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
awsome analysis Dil👏👏👏
i loved ur term chameleon🤣🤣🤣
really yar dis sultans character is such a confusing one he is keep on changing his colors
his last act of saying alvida and then walking in chawl as having walk in a park where only a day
later there was a terrible shoot out and his blushing stuff on madhus voice eww🤢
where he has himself said that his life is at stake each hour
and what all u said about RK is just awsome re
he is the one to be believed gradually😉

Edited by duaa92 - 12 years ago
Neutral_Mona thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Awesome post agree with you and for me biggest disappointment from this track is that Sultan character was supposed to be an Antagonist but why cvs portrayed him all positive why this mess?
DushtDanaf. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
I LOVE YOUR POST. I'm not a Sultan hater in the least, but I've come to dislike a lot of what he's beginning to represent; There's really no going back with his character this far down the slippery slope. You've already said it all for me perfectly, so I'll just paraphrase the words a wise member in the forum once wrote, for those claiming Sultan to be the more mature and stable option for Madhubala: RK teda rahega par life long Madhubala ka rahega, unlike Sultan who doesn't know kisse yaad kare uski biwi ko yaan madhu ko.
-Dil- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: mona1986

Awesome post agree with you and for me biggest disappointment from this track is that Sultan character was supposed to be an Antagonist but why cvs portrayed him all positive why this mess?


Agree!!An antagonist of Ballu's calibre would have taken the show to new heights..and not dragged down the drain..!!!😳And neither would it have divided the camps...!!
cardio21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Awesome post!! Sultan's character seems to undergo significant mutations with each passing day..

And all those who are comparing RK with this gold standard of humanity, RK still has to keep his Mom or Madhu as a bait for his enemies.

Sultan was also shown as an arrogant individual to an extent that in his over confidence, he actually risked his son's life..😕 But Madhu's divine intervention changed his character into a passive lover boy in 3 weeks! 😆



ennishet thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Awesome post, Dil! Agree with each and every word you said above. There is no consistency in Sultan's character and instead of instilling fear, CV's have made us laugh and mock him. I've seen better dons in movies ... they scare us in just one scene.

As to RK, he has been a bigda Nawab since day one. No change whatsoever. Madhu knew then and knows even now. Whatever she decides will be based on this fact.
...Seema... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
i second u dil.a super awesome take on sultans character.rk is rk he is still stick to his character who hates and loves with equal passion and obsession and v all love rk for his anokha style.as far as sultan is concerned i think da cvs r yet to decide to shw him in which skin as a antagonist or a lover boy hahahah.he is a rolling stone .
--Rose-- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Rocking post yaar:-):-)
Completely agree:-):-)...
No comments for sultan...
Rk is Rk<3<3<3<3...
-Dil- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: duaa92

awsome analysis Dil👏👏👏

i loved ur term chameleon🤣🤣🤣
really yar dis sultans character is such a confusing one he is keep on changing his colors
his last act of saying alvida and then walking in chawl as having walk in a park where only a day
later there was a terrible shoot out and his blushing stuff on madhus voice eww🤢
where he has himself said that his life is at stake each hour
and what all u said about RK is just awsome re
he is the one to be believed gradually😉


Thank you Duaa..!!I do think Sultan's character was treated atrociously by CV's..!!😲😳He could have been so much more..But now he remains a caricature of what could have been!!

Related Topics

Madhubala - Ek Ishq Ek Junoon Thumbnail

Posted by: Heja

16 days ago

Here are some proofs that Madhubala is not actually a good character

Madhubala's character in the series was portrayed as a character who showed mercy even to her well-intentioned enemy. But when I watched the...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".