avyarima thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
i know this is just a fictional show, but its interesting to see people opinion on a shows characters are only shaped by a tag ( lead actor/lead actress) suddenly they can "only make mistakes and their mistakes are surely forgivable" So THOUGHT I ASK THIS QUESTIONS

what if Rk was not the mean lead (and he is not sooo HOT!😉)? would you ever forgive him?????

what if Madhu is a real person and she is your sister/daughter? is there any time in life you think you would ever ask her to forgive RK?

What if Sultan was tagged as "Male lead" and he is just making his entry ...Rk is just like Madhu's old fiance ( just a phase) . how many of us would not want her to move forward???

what if Sultan is a real character in life...would anyone want his/her sister to get close to such a dangerous man???? (he may have a good heart but his life is too rough)

What if Mahu is your daughter, would you think its right for her to go to an unknown guy's house in the bush and come back home late like she did before sultan got shot?

THIS IS JUST A FUN POST. I AM NOT TRYING TO BASH ANYBODY FOR SUPPORTING ANYONE. I JUST WANT TO KNOW WHY PEOPLE ARE ACTUALLY MAKING THE DECISIONS ON WHO THEY LIKE AND WHO THEY DONT LIKE.

IS IT THE TAG?
IS IT THE LOOKS?
OR IS IT THE BEHAVIOR?

how do we decide if they doing the right thing and if what they are doing it wrong

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.3k

Users

8

Likes

32

Frequent Posters

752783 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
yeah i have always wondered what if RK was not hot would ppl support him as much as they do? good question? if Madhu was your daughter or sister would you advise her to go back? obviously never but ppl here are not going to admit it. great post!! 👏
cardio21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Gurtiluv

yeah i have always wondered what if RK was not hot would ppl support him as much as they do? good question? if Madhu was your daughter or sister would you advise her to go back? obviously never but ppl here are not going to admit it. great post!! 👏


@Gurtiluv
You know I am not a RK or a Madhu fan!! I don't care how hot he is!! But I have always maintained that no one can love Madhu the way RK can provided he s not acting as a jerk. And same with Rk, only Madhu can love him with this innate passion. Even if it was the other way round and madhu had wronged RK,I would expect Madhu to reform herself and RK to accept her back in his life.
I know RK went too overboard with this revenge crap!!

But The kind of love they share is eternal (at least whatever was portrayed), that's the kind of love which one cannot give up on. I know people can't change their personalities but they do mellow down.

If it was real life, the story wouldn't have started as normal girls don't shove their help down people's throat. RK was wrong to run over that dude, but his family was willing to accept the money! So it was not Madhu's business to start a crusade against him.
If Madhu was the guys sister, it would have been justified and even RK may not have gone so far.. But somebody meddling in my affairs would piss me off and I am not even a superstar!! Madhu started to play with fire, and nobody tried to control her. I am a strong, independent and a self made woman but my Mom would slap me right across my face if I start doing S*%& like this.

And then RK s a egomaniac!! Who is willing to hurt even himself to massage his ego! My take is that both are equally flawed. Because Madhu is the wronged one, she gets our sympathies.
And I have always quoted that Rk does not know how to respect women, but after his patch up with his mom, it is clear that he can be taught to adore the woman who means something to him.

We don't want it to be easy for RK, and I don't justify him. Both have been wrong at their places but
rK is far from redemption for now.

desait thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
great post if Madhu is my daughter no to RK and No to gangster also.
bugsbunny12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
In real life, it would be rather a sensible move to stay away from both.
As RK has decieved her for his revenge, and Sultan has done a lot of crime and is a gangster...so any woman in her right mind would say NO to both...
berrysweet thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
If Madhu was my daughter all the characters mentioned, would have their ears in the shade of burning red after they have heard me scream out the greatest lecture of my life!!.
Edited by basheerahmajeed - 12 years ago
cardio21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: avyarima

i know this is just a fictional show, but its interesting to see people opinion on a shows characters are only shaped by a tag ( lead actor/lead actress) suddenly they can "only make mistakes and their mistakes are surely forgivable" So THOUGHT I ASK THIS QUESTIONS

what if Rk was not the mean lead (and he is not sooo HOT!😉)? would you ever forgive him?????

what if Madhu is a real person and she is your sister/daughter? is there any time in life you think you would ever ask her to forgive RK?

What if Sultan was tagged as "Male lead" and he is just making his entry ...Rk is just like Madhu's old fiance ( just a phase) . how many of us would not want her to move forward???

what if Sultan is a real character in life...would anyone want his/her sister to get close to such a dangerous man???? (he may have a good heart but his life is too rough)

What if Mahu is your daughter, would you think its right for her to go to an unknown guy's house in the bush and come back home late like she did before sultan got shot?

THIS IS JUST A FUN POST. I AM NOT TRYING TO BASH ANYBODY FOR SUPPORTING ANYONE. I JUST WANT TO KNOW WHY PEOPLE ARE ACTUALLY MAKING THE DECISIONS ON WHO THEY LIKE AND WHO THEY DONT LIKE.

IS IT THE TAG?
IS IT THE LOOKS?
OR IS IT THE BEHAVIOR?

how do we decide if they doing the right thing and if what they are doing it wrong



It's not about that he is hot, but its about the love which he knows about but is not willing to accept. And I believe he is capable of redemption. If he wasnt the main lead, then he would not have been portrayed in this light...😊

If Madhu was my sister, I would definitely not ask her to forgive RK because at that point I am not watching a TV soap and will be clueless about his inner turmoil. But after seeing the concern he showed when she was missing (couldn't be fake as it would be pointless) I would have definitely tried to find more about what's going on especially if I know that my sister has badly invested herself in this man. Nt to mention, that the guy has to prove himself again.. And even after he proves himself, I will make him sign pre-nup 😉

But yes, I would like my sister to move on, if she can actually find happiness with someone. Not because she has to be with somebody. And for now Madhu can't be happy with anyone else. She needs to stand on her own 2 feet. 😃

I would not want anybody related to me to be involved with a gangster, he can be Robinhood himself.. I don't care about golden heart, if it belongs to a gangster who doesn't deal in drugs.. 😛


And kids or no kids, a sleepover at a random man's house are a no no for me. No normal girl would do that. That's why I say, only RK can control Madhu. He keeps her busy so that she can't go on her dangerous missions. Remember, the only time Madhu got in trouble in her good days of marriage was when RK was sleeping after taking the sedatives. It's for Madhu's own good that she needs to go back to RK..(this is a sarcastic comment, but so true..😆)


It is just my opinion. Your post is very interesting.. Nice!! 😊


armummy thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
First of all it is fiction , you see it as the cvs show it...
we already know rk /madhu is main lead...so the expectation is that story will be in thier favour..
If sultan was introduced as main lead, we would be seeing the story from his POV.
In reality nothing of this sort will happen as girls now a days are not so naive and have some common sense...and superstars have some image to maintain and have no time for common girls...and gangstars are not gold hearted...
Edited by armummy - 12 years ago
Ananya05 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Are yaar...its a fiction show...y put so much reality stuff in it? It always cracks me up..🤣

If Madhu were by daughter/sister, I would never have allowed her to take on such a powerful superstar in the first place. Whats with sending him bangles and then slapping him in front of his whole crew? 👎🏼
Edited by Ananya05 - 12 years ago
752783 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: cardio21


@Gurtiluv
You know I am not a RK or a Madhu fan!! I don't care how hot he is!! But I have always maintained that no one can love Madhu the way RK can provided he s not acting as a jerk. And same with Rk, only Madhu can love him with this innate passion. Even if it was the other way round and madhu had wronged RK,I would expect Madhu to reform herself and RK to accept her back in his life.
I know RK went too overboard with this revenge crap!!

But The kind of love they share is eternal (at least whatever was portrayed), that's the kind of love which one cannot give up on. I know people can't change their personalities but they do mellow down.

If it was real life, the story wouldn't have started as normal girls don't shove their help down people's throat. RK was wrong to run over that dude, but his family was willing to accept the money! So it was not Madhu's business to start a crusade against him.
If Madhu was the guys sister, it would have been justified and even RK may not have gone so far.. But somebody meddling in my affairs would piss me off and I am not even a superstar!! Madhu started to play with fire, and nobody tried to control her. I am a strong, independent and a self made woman but my Mom would slap me right across my face if I start doing S*%& like this.

And then RK s a egomaniac!! Who is willing to hurt even himself to massage his ego! My take is that both are equally flawed. Because Madhu is the wronged one, she gets our sympathies.
And I have always quoted that Rk does not know how to respect women, but after his patch up with his mom, it is clear that he can be taught to adore the woman who means something to him.

We don't want it to be easy for RK, and I don't justify him. Both have been wrong at their places but
rK is far from redemption for now.



@cardio

i understand where your coming from and all and most of the time we are in agreement in everything. but half of what Madhu did during the Mukand case was destiny. Madhu happened to be there to witness the accident. Anyone who witnesses an accident ends up reporting it right? I mean you cant take the person to the doctors and just say they got injured magically eventually it will work its way up to the police. Yes she shouldn't have gotten involved when RK tried to settle matters with Mukand's family personally and yes even my mother would slap the hell out of me. But Madhu's mom didnt in fact she enabled and encouraged her. Also any one in Madhu's place blood would have boiled if the witnessed someone run over so ruthlessly and not even have the decency to once come and apologize for it. I mean we the viewers didnt see a hint of guilt on RK's face at the time. He was just so confident that with the amount of money he had sent Mukand would have been ready to get run over again. He said that smugly to Bittuji. Yes most ppl wouldnt have taken such drastic measures. But it wasnt Madhu fault that RK got arrested on a day where the court wasnt open so he couldnt get his bail. That too was destiny. Madhu had guilty conscience with her dealings with Mukand before the case and she knew he was decent guy. At the end it was her humanity.

However what ever RK has done till now has only been out of egotism and bad intention. Whether it was humiliating her in front everyone. Spreading false rumors about him and her to the media. Using her sympathy to make her fall for him. Yes he ended up falling in love with her. But what is love when your not man enough to admit it. Love is only a beautiful thing when it completes you and helps you grow. This type of destructive love may attract audiences but is it fruitful or healthy? He thus far has only humiliated her in the name of love.
Edited by Gurtiluv - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".