Does his one sin wipe away all the good things? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

2.4k

Users

23

Likes

87

Frequent Posters

cardio21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Mulan12

Are U like seriously seriously .

ONLY ONE SIN????😆
He broke her engagement.
He insults her mom and her foster father in public
Her foster father was badly beaten by his right hand - Ofcourse I understand he didn't know about this. But obviously he would wonder what must have happen to her father he ends up in hosital badly bruised and injured. But then again he took this too as his advantage and kind of blackmailed her to marry her to get back at her and take revenge.
He insults her infront of his servants and make her the 9 th servant.
He insults her on the set and insults her mother on the set too.
He insults her in a party and make her serve his guests drinks. Pulling pushing and insulted her and said she is not worth a kiss for the Superstar.
He make her foster father put finger print on the contract forcefully when he was barely living and fighting for his life on hospital bed
Next he uses his so called dark past and his father's suicide and her mother's remarriage to paveway for his revenge.
He played a game of love with her all those days. Making her think he has fallen in love with her.
I understand during this time he shows care, he save her from being killed by her biological father, he defends her infront of Dipali and his family, he made Padmini and Shamsher wed, he try to give a chance in films to her sister.
But then what is the use of all this when he himself admits it was done just to gain his trust, so that he could take revenge on her. Because all his attempts on taking reevnge on her was failing and he took this route to come behind her back like a coward.
So does all these count??? Infact all these feeings and good gestures are just to take the revenge and make her believe in him.
After the revenge, he insults her on set, chawl and whatever place he felt, publicly repeatedly. Still there is no redemption. He is angry only because she has moved on and still handling her life and standing up for herself instead of crying at home.
He has never once thought before dumping her at mandap what she has done for him. She made him get back his trust on God, his relationship with his mom, prayed for his life, gave him blood, save him from getting into an accident on the set, was ready to leave everything and her family, her mom, which she has been heartbroken to leave just for him.
If all those were not SIN, in your dictionary, then is it FAVOURS???




Agree with all you said!!

@underlined.. I agree he said that but then it's RK!! No matter how mean he is, he never tries to boast about his good deeds!! For instance when Madhu went missing, he was genuinely worried about her, infact his concern for her was written all over his face!! But when confronted by his Mom, he told her tat he did all that to preserve his macho image, which we all know was untrue!!
I believe that whatever he did for her family was genuine, but told her that it was a part of his revenge/prem game!! That was the only way to convince her and the audience that it was indeed revenge!!

He didnt have to stretch himself by getting her parents married or helping Trishna's career!! The Malik family was already indebted to him when he saved Malik from the Police!!
And the fear of losing Madhu on his face when she was hanging or when held by Balraj at gunpoint can not be fake!! Even Al Pacino can't fake such emotions under those circumstances.. 😉
752783 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22
If someone commits murder? would it matter that they have done a 100 acts of charity before??? Im not for Sultanbala but im def not a Rishabala fan anymore.
Edited by Gurtiluv - 12 years ago
berrysweet thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#23
One sin or many, many sins. How does it matter? He still must repent , he must realise and he must try his hardest to get back into her good books.
I am enjoying Sultans track only because at the moment, I feel very sure that she can never love him with the same deep passion she feels towards RK.
Barbiedoll_sona thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
Sultan forced himself in danger to save los of people's life from drugs which bhujang want to deal with him...and you are saying he is a murderer ..he kills bad guys just like god..at the same time he does'nt care about his life also to save innocent people life
saijahnavi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#25
i agree with u 👍🏼

his one sin wiped his all gud things...
how can they forget that rk saved madhu's life without caring about his life.if he really doen't luvs her if he thinks she is enemy.there is no need for him to save her from balraj.but he did it for her.

yes if rk is not gud then how can be sultan he hurted so many people by killing their family member...it is a big sin than what rk did...
then why all r bashing rk 😡?

nice post 😊
863659 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: mihikamahakal


</div><div>

<font color="#993300">yes he did break her heart.</font>
<font color="#993300">but it could have been worse!</font>
<font color="#993300">madhu cud have been pregnant with their child and RK cud have left her.</font>
<font color="#993300">did he do that?</font>
<font color="#993300">look at people's good side also!</font>


agree ...
aisa hota to Mb ek bache ka maa hoti ab...

Edited by UltimateVdian - 12 years ago
lovely_lady thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
One sin doesn't wipe all the good things away, but it definitely does make its mark shown.

RK and Sultan are similar in the way that they play God. Sultan, as you pointed out, takes peoples lives and whatnot. RK, on the other hand, played with Madhu's entire life. Neither of them are saints and personally I think both can be pretty despicable beings.

Personally, I don't want either of the guys to be with Madhu unless they change their ways. I want whoever Madhu ends up with to be worth her.

Related Topics

Madhubala - Ek Ishq Ek Junoon Thumbnail

Posted by: Heja

20 days ago

Here are some proofs that Madhubala is not actually a good character

Madhubala's character in the series was portrayed as a character who showed mercy even to her well-intentioned enemy. But when I watched the...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".