They both were hiding so they both are at fault

-Nafisa-

@-Nafisa-

Stunner

38

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#1

Trish and RK both.

Trish recognised Balraj but weighed her options and opted to do the film and hide from her family that her father was the producer, thinking if I reveal they won't allow me to do the film and this is my one shot at being a heroine, let me grab it. She didn't think for a moment that Balraj knew her, however there were some indicators, he was persuading her to do the film why? So many wannabe actress why her a new person what was so special about her for him to make three posters advertising the film with her image, to give her an advance of 20 lakhs as a signing amount. New actresses I'm sure don't get an advance only established actresses get advance, newbies get paid very little for their first movie as a heroine, in fact I think they have to chase to get paid. She getting the producer (the money man) trying to persuade her with 20 lakhs plus posters should have rang alarm bells in her head, particularly if the producer is the father they all ran away from who has psycho tendencies.

RK should also take some blame, though a lesser amount then Trish, because he didn't know Balraj was the father of Madhu who wanted to kill her when she was born, he didn't know the name of the father she mentioned to him only the day of the wedding, however he should still take the blame for doing any action or work for a family member of hers without first discussing with his wife if he should go ahead and also to notify everyone at the chawl that he is doing this work. I know why he hid it he was feeling bad for blackening Trish's name before and thought to give her this gift, so she thinks she got it out of her own merit, after being turned down so much when she could have got the opportunity before because of RK's doing, putting a block in her getting a foot in the door into the film industry.

If he had revealed to Madhu he would have had to tell her the whole truth and didn't want to get her angry perhaps at him for what he did previously to stop Trishna coming into the industry.

So the way I'm seeing it, both of them are to blame, Trish more then RK, because Trish knew who it was and still jumped in willingly, RK for trying to hide his previous wrong doing with a nicety ended up bringing evil into their lives.

34

Reply

Quote

Anya

@Three.Broomstic

Voyager

18

Posted: 12 years ago

#2

According to me both are equally at fault.

While Rk did not know Balraj is Madhu and Trishna father but I've always thought that RK should have done an backround check on Balraj. I also know it is not too much of an expectation because RK in general is shown to be very sensible and especially sinceBalraj was always shown a crackpot.

As for Trishna, I think that she always thinks that she is making the right decision i.e. using her mind but she forgets that her mind is always busy daydreaming and never thinks rationally

SO I think that since both have their share of faults and reasonings( excuses) for doing they are both equally responsilble for what has happened.😊

6

Reply

Quote

shravanikrishna

@vaani21

Voyager

17

Posted: 12 years ago

#3

Nice Post! Nafs.

Rk 's fault is being careless.He just gives in to Balraj cos he comes to the studio and does those antics.

However knowing Balraj that he is a high level Pagal. he should have made a proper background check of Balraj , before he makes trishna getting introduced to Balraj.

I donno whatever made him hide this from Madhu. Maybe he did not want to exhibit his good deeds to his wife..

Edited by vaani21 - 12 years ago

4

Reply

Quote

SunshineGirl6

@SunshineGirl6

Inactive

37

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#4

But RK's intentions were pure !!

6

Reply

Quote

gudia1990

@gudia1990

Beginner

4

Posted: 12 years ago

#5

Trishna...Trishna...Trishna ...see the guts of that girl... even after all that she put the blame on Rk...😡 she couldnt see his good side and keep shut!

4

Reply

Quote

-Nafisa-

@-Nafisa-

Stunner

38

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#6

Originally posted by: vaani21
Nice Post! Nafs.
Rk 's fault is being careless.He just gives in to Balraj cos he comes to the studio and does those antics.
However knowing Balraj that he is a high level Pagal. he should have made a proper background check of Balraj , before he makes trishna getting introduced to Balraj.
I donno whatever made him hide this from Madhu. Maybe he did not want to exhibit his good deeds to his wife..

Yes that's why I said also RK was careless, before he decided to do this for Trishna he should have discussed it with his wife, but it was a unique situation, because normally when you escape from someone you at least know what he looks like and here Madhu even met him but still didn't recognise him for who he was. Because he saw her when she was a baby only. So unique situation where Padmini didn't even show the her what the evil person looked like in a picture because she escaped with nothing.

It's kind of hard for RK now to face his wife's questions when she comes back from her confrontation with Trishna they will have a short lived fight and they will reconcile soon enough, as is their style, we saw already they were holding hands on the steps in that segment video soon, so argument during the day the night afterwards reconciliation.

Edited by Nafs_Sweetheart - 12 years ago

2

Reply

Quote

-Ratzz-

@-Ratzz-

Inactive

23

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#7

but trish is more faulty but still she blaming hate her

3

Reply

Quote

Tanmaya1

@Tanmaya1

Dazzler

24

Posted: 12 years ago

#8

Nice Post Nafs.

Trishna is more to be blamed. Trishna brought death to the doorstep of Padmini, Madhubala and RK.

As and when Trishna recognised Balraj she has to tell it to Padmini and Malik that she has seen Balraj.

RK didn't know that Balraj with whom he was dealing was Madhu's father.

Trishna's behaviour has gone out of control. Trishna needs to be disciplined and reprimanded by Padmini. How dare Trishna talks in out of control manner with R.K.

R.K. is Madhu's husband and son-in-law of the family. Trishna needs to learn that she has to respect her sister's husband.

Madhu's inlaws have been invited to a marriage. They were taken by Balraj and everyone were frightened what Balraj's men would do to them.

RK had to undergo so much suffering and pain to save his wife.

If Trishna spelt out to Padmini, Malik or Roma that she has seen Balraj such a catastrophe would have been averted.

(For a while let us forget that the situation was created for the hero to emerge victorious. )

RK who was always very smart in dealing things overlooked to check who Balraj was. RK was very much eager to complete Madhu's responsibilities and take his wife Madhu and go away to far off place.

Again is this possible? Madhu did not discuss atleast once with RK that she would leave everything and come away with him. Can he leave his mother with Bhatias and move away far? Will his mother be safe with Sr. Bhatia and Dipali Bhatia?

This is a serial and such things need not be cross checked because the more misunderstandings the more episodes in a serial.

Any how I strongly feel Trishna is responsible for such an epic episode to happen

4

Reply

Quote

-Nafisa-

@-Nafisa-

Stunner

38

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#9

Originally posted by: SAnonymous

Nice Post Nafs.

Trishna is more to be blamed. Trishna brought death to the doorstep of Padmini, Madhubala and RK.

As and when Trishna recognised Balraj she has to tell it to Padmini and Malik that she has seen Balraj.

RK didn't know that Balraj with whom he was dealing was Madhu's father.

Trishna's behaviour has gone out of control. Trishna needs to be disciplined and reprimanded by Padmini. How dare Trishna talks in out of control manner with R.K.

R.K. is Madhu's husband and son-in-law of the family. Trishna needs to learn that she has to respect her sister's husband.

Madhu's inlaws have been invited to a marriage. They were taken by Balraj and everyone were frightened what Balraj's men would do to them.

RK had to undergo so much suffering and pain to save his wife.

If Trishna spelt out to Padmini, Malik or Roma that she has seen Balraj such a catastrophe would have been averted.

(For a while let us forget that the situation was created for the hero to emerge victorious. )

RK who was always very smart in dealing things overlooked to check who Balraj was. RK was very much eager to complete Madhu's responsibilities and take his wife Madhu and go away to far off place.

Again is this possible? Madhu did not discuss atleast once with RK that she would leave everything and come away with him. Can he leave his mother with Bhatias and move away far? Will his mother be safe with Sr. Bhatia and Dipali Bhatia?

This is a serial and such things need not be cross checked because the more misunderstandings the more episodes in a serial.

Any how I strongly feel Trishna is responsible for such an epic episode to happen

Yes Trish is responsible but RK also his good deed for any family member of Madhu's he needs to discuss first with his wife, even if Madhu didn't know Balraj at all, at least that would have cleared him completely here. Because he hid his good deed from Madhu that's why they will have an argument tomorrow, even if he was trying to right a wrong he did to Trishna when he blocked her career that does not mean he hides the facts from Madhu.

Trish is very immature Sarada she really believed a new person to be taken in a heroine role would get so much money and would be coerced with the posters, straight away she should have known that Balraj knows who she is.

Also I agree with you that the excuse she is using now that RK wanted to destroy Madhu and her family is completely with no foundation as we all saw, he was blown up plus went through a lot of agony getting beaten up to save her sister's life, in front of her, so she has no right to throw mud at his character having the evidence before as she did. His family were also tied up like Madhu's family in that hot sun Radhaji's arms hanging on the pillars that way, why would RK want his mother to suffer, completely no foundation her excuse. Also this is the first time Trishna has admitted that RK knew of her movie, before remember she was warning him to stay away and cursing him, all of a sudden she knows he was behind it, either a blooper by the CV's or she is grasping at straws to shirk the blame from her shoulders and put it all on RK.

However Sarada, RK is feeling guilty we saw today, he couldn't touch Madhu and wife away her tears in the hospital he dropped his hands not out of pain but because he feels he is to blame for bringing that shaitan to wreck havoc in their lives, so yes he should have done more of a background check on BSC. But he was pressed for time as he was planning to relocate them he wanted everything done quickly, resolved the arguments at the chawl, get Trishna's career started, get the elders married, get him and Madhu married, so he acted without thinking that BSC had exhibited some psycho behaviour already, at the jail in particular how he got himself released, driving an ambulance, calling himself Bhagwan Shaitan Chaudhry many other indicators that RK ignored out of haste to put his plans in motion.

2

Reply

Quote

Tanmaya1

@Tanmaya1

Dazzler

24

Posted: 12 years ago

#10

Yes Trish is responsible but RK also his good deed for any family member of Madhu's he needs to discuss first with his wife, even if Madhu didn't know Balraj at all, at least that would have cleared him completely here. Because he hid his good deed from Madhu that's why they will have an argument tomorrow, even if he was trying to right a wrong he did to Trishna when he blocked her career that does not mean he hides the facts from Madhu.

Trish is very immature Sarada she really believed a new person to be taken in a heroine role would get so much money and would be coerced with the posters, straight away she should have known that Balraj knows who she is.

Also I agree with you that the excuse she is using now that RK wanted to destroy Madhu and her family is completely with no foundation as we all saw, he was blown up plus went through a lot of agony getting beaten up to save her sister's life, in front of her, so she has no right to throw mud at his character having the evidence before as she did. His family were also tied up like Madhu's family in that hot sun Radhaji's arms hanging on the pillars that way, why would RK want his mother to suffer, completely no foundation her excuse. Also this is the first time Trishna has admitted that RK knew of her movie, before remember she was warning him to stay away and cursing him, all of a sudden she knows he was behind it, either a blooper by the CV's or she is grasping at straws to shirk the blame from her shoulders and put it all on RK.

However Sarada, RK is feeling guilty we saw today, he couldn't touch Madhu and wife away her tears in the hospital he dropped his hands not out of pain but because he feels he is to blame for bringing that shaitan to wreck havoc in their lives, so yes he should have done more of a background check on BSC. But he was pressed for time as he was planning to relocate them he wanted everything done quickly, resolved the arguments at the chawl, get Trishna's career started, get the elders married, get him and Madhu married, so he acted without thinking that BSC had exhibited some psycho behaviour already, at the jail in particular how he got himself released, driving an ambulance, calling himself Bhagwan Shaitan Chaudhry many other indicators that RK ignored out of haste to put his plans in motion.

Nice Explanation Nafs.

RK is feeling very sorry that he has brought Balraj into their lives.

Sometimes in the urgency to do things very intelligent people (like RK) forget to cross check certain details. That will bring disaster and rewrite their lives.

I hope once Padmini learns about the situation she will surely give life's tough lessons to Trishna.

I hope Padmini will tell Trishna that inspite of bringing her from her evil father Balraj and trying her and Malik's best to be good parents to her the gift Trishna chose to give Padmini and Malik for their wedding is Madhu's death. (From the begining Trishna knows that Balraj will kill Madhubala if he knows their whereabouts.)

RK didn't know that Balraj with whom he was dealing was Madhu's father. Trishna recognised Balraj and didn't tell Padmini and Malik.

This girl Trishna needs to be dealt very sternly by her mother Padmini.

2

Reply

Quote