|| A Lie to Soothe vs. A Truth that Hurts||

Iridescence1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

.:: A Truth to Create a Distance. A Distance to Bring us Together ::.

***FR to Reunion***

As we all know, the character of Dutta is quite complex. He comes across as a tough, hardcore man from his apparent ways but what one may miss is the fragile heart he holds. The heart that he worked to keep safely hidden away and learned to protect in shell. A shell that eventually broke because of Nakusha's love and I would say it happened unknowingly from the very beginning. Started with tiny cracks and eventually it broke off and free, opening to her love.

Dutta had finally, after going through a whole lot of emotional turmoil , come to terms with the love he held for Naku and what it meant to be in love, what his life was and became.. *(as discussed by Ani & Rose...and there is still more to come, I believe two phases before this one). And just when everything seemed to be settling to his liking, desires, and wishes that's where twists play a role...another phase...testing time for our DSP dearest.

so it came down to a lie to soothe versus a truth that hurts...

When the truth behind Nakusha's color came out it was clear how much of a shocker it was for Dutta. He hadn't expected it, especially not on their wedding night. He poured his heart out to his wife...his love and in hopes of finally feeling like things made sense in his life, there was color, it was alive again almost as if in a dream. Well he sure got one hell of a wake-up call for feeling all that.

Right after he told her how he felt for her, how much he came to trust her, how much he was affected by her, and how much his life changed (in a good way) because of her the truth struck like a dagger to his heart. Falling right out of his precious dream and hitting the ground hard, reality sank in. The truth that the person he loves is a lie (well it's just her color that was a lie but in his perspective that's not how it would've appeared). Everything came crashing down once again for him. And to mask the truth that hurt him he chose to take a route of telling himself lies about how he feels about her and telling everyone those same lies..and showing his disinterest in her to soothe the pain.

The lie that Nakusha lived was a lie that was kept up to soothe the effects of the struggles in her life. A form of protection for her to avoid danger and a form of masking to protect other's from hurting (ie. her mother and later a Dutta who believed all pretty faces were betrayers). For Dutta, more than the truth of her color it was the betrayal of his trust and love that really stabbed him. He went from denial to grief and pain all in a matter of a few moments. The love that he promised to hang on to was a love that to him was all a lie. Although I think somewhere deep in him he could sense that the Naku he loved was inside this new appearance, he didn't want to accept it in fear of it bringing him back down again.

His shock over the truth being hidden not only from Naku but his family, the notion of his Naku not even being existent, and then the realization that the trust he had was completely shattered left him again back at his emotional turmoil stage.

One show of a fair maidens hand and his world went tumbling to the ground. Eventually he decided his Naku no longer existed and the name Nakusha was now associated with the word betrayal, he refused to get hurt again, after the first two woman in his life were disasters he had really truly believed Naku was different and then the idea of her being no different to the others wouldn't let him accept her again (right away that is :P), he wanted to lend a deaf ear and blind eye to what was the truth just to avoid hurt again...

He shunned her out with a lie that he hated her, he doesn't care for her, and that she can do whatever she wants it won't bother him no more but in reality every little thing she did affected him something his mind denied but heart knew very well.

He did care and that was most apparent when he wasn't in his senses, when his mind shut down and his heart alone took over. He did love her but he chose to say he didn't, he chose to create a distance that only ended up bringing them closer allowing him to see that no matter how indifferent he was to her new look, presence, and behaviors he knew it all still got to him and that she was no different at all from the inside, and she was indeed different from the 'others'.

Of course eventually he began slowly letting down his guard...I guess he started to follow his hearts call instead. He slowly began to show her he did care even if he preferred to mask the idea. Through his stubborn front he still had his moments that told everyone his hearts truth. His tough love attitude was still prevalent throughout the time he began mellowing down but he was beginning to step towards her again and not away. Scenes such as...Naku getting shot and his automatic responses to it, similarly the Suresh segment that lead him to eventually say Naku is his wife to make his point, then the Naku driving and the coat wala scene, and many more that showed his little gestures as being great forms of communication between the two, especially in conveying the truth. It was obvious what he felt no matter how much he denied it and eventually he gave into also...letting go of his stubbornness slowly. And just when we thought he'll finally let all of his anger go and understand the woman's reasons, even if he didn't agree with her approach, fate I guess had other plans. Uh actually no, Kala had other plans...she set him up for his death. An accident that separated the two before they even got confront where there relationship was now...

Then the whole blind segment only helped Dutta realize his love on a deeper level and the separation made their love stronger and their desperation for each other greater. The distance making him realize that he was being a fool to have distanced something that he always knew was there between them. Even amongst all the lies the one thing that was always true from the beginning was her unconditional love for him and his love for her (even if he realized that's what it was, later but that came as part of the description of being a gadha :P). I think he always felt something for her from the beginning...unknown feeling to a very known one eventually.

I must add, the moments they shared apart, talking over the phone and the amount of pain and desire they held and built up from the FR only made their reunion all the more better. It was a moment for everyone to yell out FINALLY!!

Her desperate run into his waiting arms and a longing for her that needed to be done with. And there you have it the hug that said it all, a moment of being completed where the world didn't matter and neither did any current problems. It was only about the two of them. His expressions alone (now this can be talked about and praised forever so I won't start lol) were good in conveying that sense of relief of having her with him. His strength, his love, his everything was there and he'd fight the world to keep it that way...which is exactly what he ended up doing just he was blind..Love makes one do unexplainable things doesn't it :P

I felt this phase of Dutta's character development was important in terms of letting go of his protective stance around his heart. Learning to open up to the true and unconditional love Nakusha was offering, learning to let go of the mistake she made in hiding the biggest truth from him, learning to work with his heart instead of against it, and learning to let go of his past experiences...

Alright that's it from me 😳

Do share your thoughts to😃

>>> M O R E B E L O W <<<<


Edited by -daya- - 13 years ago


DO NOT COPY THIS POST AS THIS IS EXCLUSIVE TO INDIA FORUMS


Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1.8k

Users

14

Likes

85

Frequent Posters

Iridescence1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#2

Now, I would add specific scenes for this phase, but there is a whole lot of them I wouldn't even know where to begin😆 so what I did instead is made a vm😛

I was actually sitting listening to madno song and every time I hear that song I think of Dutta and Nakusha...and after a long long time when I heard it after having written this piece and thought that the post FR scenes would fit for this song...

After writing this piece I really missed this couple😳 and its been a while since I made a VM so I decided to try to pick a few of my fav scenes and mesh em together 😆 So hope you like it...the first link is new VM...and the second is a very old one lol...but its short and on just the reunion hug if you'd like to see that also :)

Enjoy friends! Thanks for reading...

do share your thoughts on this phase of DSP..


Edited by -daya- - 12 years ago
tamanna1391 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
post dutta felt hurt on sr because he wants her to tell him truth before everyone but nakku and as come in kala idea and hide the truth if nakku told him on proposal day or after dp death then the matter was different but yes i love this show



stranger2rose thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
once again daya a very well written post and agree with all the points that you have covered..it was indeed a very big mistake on the part of nakku , babi and patil family to hide such a big thing from him ..for this i would blame nakku the most coz she was the one who loved him the most and he opened his heart out to her so how could she hold back herself from telling him this truth ..the scene where he expresses his feelings in detail after their second marriage my heart went out to him fearing the shock he'd have to face once the truth comes out to him and like everybody i too feel that the FR happened at the most inappropriate time. what followed next was well expected ...dutta crying dhokha ..smashing bottles ..going violent etc ..his whole outburst was totally justified and mishal did a fab job once again ..the pain the hurt was enacted out really well
the scenes which i liked the most during this phase were , their eating in the kitchen ..his throwing the plate to call her was just too sweet ...their holding of hands in the OT one could see the belief she had in him and he too couldnt hide the love he had for her ..it was indeed beautiful ..then their talking on the phone was heart touching and lastly their reunion hug which was out of this world
daya the vm is superb and me too love this song ..its made for them
tahera57 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
daya. love this piece of ur writing the dutta shriram patel the broken man the one who thought he was so much in control of his feelings, whose words would break ur heart when u hear him say " tu rahay ya jayay mujhay koi farak nahin padta" could not for the life of him bring himself to say it lest she should leave... .ahh the sweet agony it was to watch his gadhapan hurting himself and her with bitter words and attitude.
i loved his refusing food daily because it wasn'ther who served it, then the day when he couldn't loose the opprtunity of eating food served by her , without saying a word he pulls himself a chair and waits...
then the accident and seperation track ... personally i would've preferred it if their union was without the seperation as it would have stressed he accepted her without the absence makes the heart grow fonder.. phase. but the cv's did milk it to the last drop.
you wrote so well and the video made every thing even better.
i'm forever amazed at how much i enjoy all these overly repeated posts again and again by different writers it's alwasy so frsh again no matter what, dutta and LTL we never get tired of discussing reading and loving every time it makes me nostalgic i do have to keep a very firm control on myself to stop watching it all over again.
thanks daya.
Ani_La_Iam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Brilliant post Daya...love the VM. 👏👏

Will be back soon with my comments.
Nakusha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
hi daya
very well written post & sune pe suhaga (icing on the cake) is Vm . 😊
dutta was never seen character on small screen inspite of been don .he evoked so much of emphaty .he craved for luv through out & he got betryal all & one including his fly
naku was blessing in disguise😆actually in disguise .who brought luv unconditional luv in his like
its always pleasure to read any post by you .😊
mirage123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
hi daya
loved the thread😊
Ani_La_Iam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

First of all Daya love your vm 👏 love the song and just love the hug. 😃😍

Mind blowing post 👏 well written and love the way you analyzed Dutta and went through Dutta's journey in this phase. 😊

Love the part with Dutta' hearts in a shell, can only agree with you. 😊

For me there was no excuse good enough for Naku not telling Dutta the true. She knew how he felt about betrayal, he had opened his heart and his dark past in front of her...Dutta gave his all, even raised his voice against Kala, showed in many ways that he love her...what more did Naku need?

Dutta said some very beautiful and truthful thing in D - N The Eternal Story, that Naku love him unconditionally and would do anything for him...but she does not trust him.

It is not that Naku hide the true about her color or other things that hurt Dutta, it is the part that Naku did not feel she could tell him the true - that hurt Dutta.

How hurtful most it be that everyone you trust and care for, get together to hide a important true from you...that you are the only one who do not know.

Also to realize that the person you fell in love with, you though you knew...were based on a lie and you were wrong. You say you love the person and you could not even see, that the person was lying or hiding something big...again it made Dutta question himself.

One very interesting thing Dutta said in LTL...because of one girl everyone in his family and his childhood friend betrayed him. What I love about this part was the message, that no stranger (even if you love the person) is more important than your family.

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iL46t-BepLw&feature=colike[/YOUTUBE]

I just love this whole scene (just uploaded the last part) specially the way Dutta in the end say ...it is too late...was so painful.

Big👏👏👏 to Mishal.

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNNma5uCeLQ&feature=colike[/YOUTUBE]

If you put yourself in Dutta's situation you can really feel his pain, betrayed third time, by the women he love and gave his all to. As I said in my post, if your best and all is not good enough and you are left and betrayed then you start questioning yourself...what you keep doing wrong.

There are so many beautiful scenes and so many amazing dialogs delivery from Mishal, that if I start posting my favorite scene...I would fill up pages after pages.

Another very interesting and beautiful thing Dutta said was that Naku still had not admitted her mistake. I liked that because he is right. Naku think that what she did, was what she had to do, because she did not have a choice - that is not true...she used Babi and Baji as excuse for not being ready to tell Dutta the true.

Here is the scene and I just love Mishal in it. ⭐️

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfTTrf6ceHc&feature=colike[/YOUTUBE]

If you think about it, Dutta never got an explanation about what part Naku played in Supriya's betrayal. Still his trust in her was so deep that he did not need an explanation...he just trust her and loved her completely.

Where I think Naku always was wrong was (because Dutta opened up to her) that she thought, she had the right and that she knew...what Dutta need. Nakku start making decision ,that only Dutta hadthe right to make.

Like, hiding the true about Supriya.

Hiding the true about her true color.

Hiding and deciding what is best for Dutta in D - N TES, according knowing the true about Damodar.

Edited by Ani_98 - 13 years ago
Hamlet53 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
thank you for your brilliant post plus vm. Iam afraid, i have nothing more to add about DSP... as it would be repetitive.
x regards hammie.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".