SO WHAT if Naku tells the truth now...

gp00 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
I wanted to test the waters on this....

FR is reaching a fever pitch on the forum! Some of us want Kala to do the honors (like me), others want Naku to do so, and others want Babi.....

But let me ask you...let's say Naku and Babi emerge from their MENTAL FOG and realize the real risk of Kala's questions and actions regarding the kajal. And then, out of fear of being exposed and her true reasons being manipulated by Kala, Naku decides to blurt it all out to Dutta, her mea culpa.

So I ask you: SO WHAT?

Would such a scenario redeem her in your eyes?

For me, you ladies well know the answer.😆 I would have respected Naku infinitely more if she had been honest before because it hurt her to keep this from him, to lie to him...the guilt or the sense that it is the right thing to do. But for her to tell the truth because of fear of being exposed, that doesn't redeem her at all, in my eyes. I'd probably dislike her even more for it, because she would look manipulative to me.

What is your thought?

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.2k

Users

6

Likes

16

Frequent Posters

Rose_Petal thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
We've been shown in a promo (don't know if it's just leading us on or not) that Naku was saying to Babi to fulfill her promise and do the FR....so I want to think that Naku isn't doing the FR out of fear of being exposed. And I agree with you that fear shouldn't be the reason why she tells Dutta her secret. If it turns out she lets out the truth only because Kala or someone threatened to tell....then she will have to do something...whatever it is....to redeem herself for me to forgive her...but I think I could forgive her eventually...for the character she was before.
lizdarcy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Babi's scared alright. But somehow i have this gut feeling ki when Naku says the truth, it's not gonna be out of fear. The last few episodes, she seems quite at peace. And confident. Quite like the jhoola wala scene where she was gonna tell him the truth.

I am frustrated at her taking forever, but she came close to redeeming herself in the scene where she told D, ab naye rang,naye roop me milenge. She didn't sound like a cheat. I hope D remembers that line after the FR.
mussy.jamshed thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Parul lovely post..............IF It happened that she herself spoke the truth to dutta then it would not be out of fear I am sure but babi has not told her about kala 's action yet........I wish she could do it before kala goes to dutta and that too without any fear ........I am sure she will b victorious but if CVs want to drag the FR then they might completely twist the tale.........😳
bfunofbb123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

Hey Gp this doesn't sound right to me. GPi want u to put ur self in naku's shoes and think like naku. but, hey at the end of the day it is my p.o.v i could b wrong. we have beeen following ltl 4 some time and the reason we fell in love with tasha in the first place is their honest they have that in their relationship. she always never backs down from telling him the truth and dutta has been honest throught out with her except FRthat stands in their way. that is the only big thing she hide from him but we all know there hasn't been good time for her until or no need as they were going seperate ways but after dutta's propose she was tensed and ready to tell him but one thing came after another and now the wedding. i 4 one whether the FR is done by her or babi or s/one else i wouldn't call her a betrayer or liar or anything bcoz she is marrying the man she loves and therefore she doesn't intend to marry him with out telling him the truth as liz mentioned she even hinted to dutta when she was leaving his room she will come back with new rang, roop and all will b soonder those r the words she use so u can understand her intention .naku wouldn't bat her eyes to die for dutta so what is FR comparing to that it is not like she has done it purposely she never thought he will fall in love with her let alone marry her so for me she has beeen the victim not dutta she has been there for him through thick and thin , she has put dutta's happiness before her's and she know that she has to tell him the truth and she intends to tell him she also gave her mom a chance to do it since it was babi who put her in this i feel it should b babi to tell dutta with the full story why she did it then he will b able to understand her. But for her to tell the truth because of fear of being exposed, that doesn't redeem her at all, in my eyes. I'd probably dislike her even more for it, because she would look manipulative to me. i hope all that i said above doesnot put her as manupalative or anything like that naku is a true person she has been throught out she has been a victim many times by her mom, dad , anna morrey u name it the evil trio and even dutta and she deserves a break and i am hoping the CV's will handle the FR v.well dutta understanding and even feeling more for her what she has to go through and all that and instead of felling all DHOKA Dhoka he should really put his thinking cap and realise she never once used her pretty face to manuplate him and the pain she has to go through till date bcoz of that, she is a true sherni she deserve to b with her sher and have a lovely shadi minus MU.😉ps sorry gp 4 the long post.

Edited by bfunofbb123 - 14 years ago
mussy.jamshed thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
I simply loved your reply Jorda......I don't know whether its yr name but you gave an excellent reply here.......I wish what you said happens in LTL..............😳really hope so
Crystal29 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
The delay was ok during the DP track, till they announced the marriage. But delaying it further and not feeling tensed is very confusing and does not sound right to me.

Anyway, once the FR happens, either by herself or by accident, I can forgive her after she faces the music from everyone(Dutta) for it.

When I can forgive Dutta for getting mad and marrying her in the most worst possible way, hating her so much after that, sending her away and thinking/taking a shower when she was kidnapped by Anna... then I can forgive Naku for this delay too.. I love them both....😃

bfunofbb123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: mussy.jamshed

I simply loved your reply Jorda......I don't know whether its yr name but you gave an excellent reply here.......I wish what you said happens in LTL..............😳really hope so

tanx mussy i don't know if t ur name as well yes jorda is my name tank u again 4 likiing it srsly i just said what i felt dil se from heart that is all.😉
gp00 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: bfunofbb123

Hey Gp this doesn't sound right to me. GPi want u to put ur self in naku's shoes and think like naku. but, hey at the end of the day it is my p.o.v i could b wrong. we have beeen following ltl 4 some time and the reason we fell in love with tasha in the first place is their honest they have that in their relationship. she always never backs down from telling him the truth and dutta has been honest throught out with her except FRthat stands in their way. that is the only big thing she hide from him but we all know there hasn't been good time for her until or no need as they were going seperate ways but after dutta's propose she was tensed and ready to tell him but one thing came after another and now the wedding. i 4 one whether the FR is done by her or babi or s/one else i wouldn't call her a betrayer or liar or anything bcoz she is marrying the man she loves and therefore she doesn't intend to marry him with out telling him the truth as liz mentioned she even hinted to dutta when she was leaving his room she will come back with new rang, roop and all will b soonder those r the words she use so u can understand her intention .naku wouldn't bat her eyes to die for dutta so what is FR comparing to that it is not like she has done it purposely she never thought he will fall in love with her let alone marry her so for me she has beeen the victim not dutta she has been there for him through thick and thin , she has put dutta's happiness before her's and she know that she has to tell him the truth and she intends to tell him she also gave her mom a chance to do it since it was babi who put her in this i feel it should b babi to tell dutta with the full story why she did it then he will b able to understand her. But for her to tell the truth because of fear of being exposed, that doesn't redeem her at all, in my eyes. I'd probably dislike her even more for it, because she would look manipulative to me. i hope all that i said above doesnot put her as manupalative or anything like that naku is a true person she has been throught out she has been a victim many times by her mom, dad , anna morrey u name it the evil trio and even dutta and she deserves a break and i am hoping the CV's will handle the FR v.well dutta understanding and even feeling more for her what she has to go through and all that and instead of felling all DHOKA Dhoka he should really put his thinking cap and realise she never once used her pretty face to manuplate him and the pain she has to go through till date bcoz of that, she is a true sherni she deserve to b with her sher and have a lovely shadi minus MU.😉ps sorry gp 4 the long post.


Hi!

The reason I am so adamant about Naku is because I have put myself into Naku's shoes, from a perspective. Yes, I could see myself keeping the secret when the relationship status wasn't clear, or even when I was afraid to lose him. But I could not do this for LONG, not as long as her. The minute he was honest and said what was in his heart, I could not have taken being dishonest to a good person like that. That's just me...I can't do it for too long. It would eat away at me. And at some point, I would have said, what will happen will happen...but if he loves me, he should know everything about me. And then he can decide. There's no other way.

At this point, truth be told, given the amount of time that has passed, it's all about being dishonest. In the beginning, her fear and silence was understandable to some degree. SO WHAT EXCUSES CAN SHE GIVE TO DUTTA ABOUT WHY SHE DRAGGED HER FEET WHEN IT CAME TO TRUTH to a man like him, who lives honestly about himself?
My mommy said so?
I had a tough life.
People kept getting in the way every time I tried to tell you, even though I shared a home / room with you?
I thought you'd hate me?
I had a psychological break and began to believe I was the dark Naku?
I don't want to be fair. Its my curse in life.
I was being blackmailed by Ganpat.
STOP WITH THE EXCUSES, NAKU. She comes across, not as an honest and true person, but as a person who can't accept the responsibility for her own silence....and that responsibility sits at her feet.

Here's another thing that gets to me. When people say: her love is true. She's done so much for him. She would die for him. GOOD FOR HER. I actually do believe all of these things about Naku's feelings for Dutta.

BUT IT GOES BEYOND THIS and I'm not sure why some do not understand that. To Dutta or even if you were in Dutta's place, your jaw would open wide at the shock that the person whom you've always taken for 100% honest and looked up to (which Dutta does by the way) and loved and given faith to, LIES ABOUT SOMETHING LIKE THIS while living in your house, while being with you alone in the jungle, while professing her love to you.....THAT IS WHERE DUTTA WILL BE HURT AND RIGHTLY SO. Her "goodness" or "good deeds" should be and will be considered BUT THESE DO NOT EXCUSE LYING! Come on already....I just can't believe that people are saying to this day that her reasons are okay, that she has a good reason for keeping the truth hidden😆 Trust is a fragile thing...and Naku's stupidity and immaturity is going to shake Dutta's trust in her and IT SHOULD. But he will think about her goodness, and then make that leap of faith and marry her. Of that I have no doubt.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".