If Tanya gives divorce.. - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

71

Views

5k

Users

14

Frequent Posters

desigrl05 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: coolkitty_23

I think in a way Karan feels guilty of not having loved Tanya at all..and thats why i think he is not brining Nandini back home, bcoz if he really had to bring her back, he would have brought her right after he met her...but since that didnt happen..I think its Karan's guilt or his thinking tht since he couldnt give anything to Tanya, he probably wouldnt leave her literally? I dont know..this whole track is confusing!

It all boils down to :

A man loves a woman, the woman loves the man, the woman gets married to someone else, the man is alone, the woman gets raped, the man swears vengeance, the man's mother finds out and shoots her own son which was the other man this woman had gotten married to,the man and woman get married. The woman gets pregnant, the woman goes into coma after child birth, the man married his best friend, the man and his wife,whome he now claims to love, dont tell the other woman, the coma woman comes out of coma, the woman finds out about the man and his wife, the woman is upset,the woman kills another man to protect her daughter, and the man goes on trial for the murder, the woman who killed confesses, the woman goes to jail for 14 years, the man lives with the woman he married the second time for the next 20 years, the man, never is able to love his wife, the man still loves his first wife dearly, 20 years later the man and the two women are still married to each other and NO ONE is happy!! Damn, that an awful story!! Ekta, get someone happy atleast! And, now, I am throughly confused!


Correct me if i missed something!

this serial seriously drives me nuts..but your story seems complete... and about Karan's guilt..I think he felt guilty before, but now after all Tanya's done and thru his actions, it seems like there is no guilt left...rather he's finally living for what he's wanted...remmeber the episode where he gets upset and asks nandini, "whom else is left to compromise with as we've compromised even with ourselves! and yet no one is happy"(episode wehre a piece of glass went in her foot)... I agree with Karan thou, despite all the sacrifices and compromises, the happiness they got out of that was momentarily and short-lived, and at the end it seems to go to waste cuz they're not happy themselves and by this they are not able to keep anyone happy...

adeela thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: AryanDipikaFan

just wait till the day when show wud show xyz and abc is now to play karan and nandinin's chacter, not hiten gauri, then all the support towards all the wrongs doen towards tanya wud cease.


they are suporting actors, ppl, so dotn waste ur time, its nothign to do with the injutice that tanya goes thru.

you all karan nandini haters have nothing to defend tanya thats why you said we love karan nandini because gauri hiten played by karan nandini. the matter of fact is.

if you people have a strong point towards tanya than how can we fight with you obviously we will except your support towards tanya.and same with nandini and karan if you peeple have a strong point against nandini and karan than how can we fight with you we will except.

and why i hate tanya.

tanya knew it very well on her first day's of marriage karan was agreed to maried with her just for bhoomi's sake and he only and only loves with nandini.then whynot tanya refused to married with him why she was agreed to married wth that man who madly in loves wirth his first wife. infact nobody forced to her infact all virani's forced to karan.

first three years he didn't gives her wifes rights when tulsi came back after completing her 3 years prision she said to him then he gave her wifes rights but when nandini was comeback from coma docter called him he left tanya in their wedding anniversary and happiliy went to met nandini.when nandini was faint when she read his diary karan told infront of tulsi and tanya maine woh sare rishte khatam kardoga jo mere aur nandini ke beech ayen ge.when nandini got 14 years prision karan told him clearly you will never takes place nandi's place in my heart .then why not tanya except it nandini is karan's life and i am nothing infront of nandini in karan's life.then whynot she left him.thata means she is the most chipko woman.zabadasti pyar karo she said to karan so many times when nmandini will retuen i will leave you but she never fulfil her promise ,she said to karan i always respect your and nandini's love oh thats why she kicked out nandini from sn that means she is a biggest lier.plus when she knew abt nandini's marriage she said so many bad things to nandini then why not she was happy in that time and if she was sincerely thinking abt karan thats why she said so many bad things to her then why not she is happy right now and reunite karan nandini.no she was showing jelousy that means she is a double standard woman.

. two more points i wana add here .when nandini came back tanya left karan first of all tanya left karan because nandini wana marry to her with other guy she didn't leave karan for nandini's sake.plus she came back after few days and said i cant live without bhoomi ,but if tanya fans still think its sacrifice then its nothing infront of nandini's sacrifices.

other point tanya was redy to sign divorce papers ont he other han she was crying infront of al virani's and showed she will sacrifice and she went to nandini's house and showed infront of divorce papers sacrifice karne wale sub ko bata aur jata ke sacrifice nahin karte like nandini she stopped her and lying i was married with other guy.plus if tanya truely wants karan nandini's reunion she never kickout nandini from sn .

when karan asked her tumhe mujhe chor ke jane main meri khushi hai then tanya said tumhari kushi ke liye main tumhe chordongi but i cant live without you .then karan said to her tum mujhe kabhi chor kar najana and hugged her.but when mandira called to tanya she told her abt karan nandini then why tanya went to nandini's house whnot he believed karan after all tanya sped 20 yers with him and she knew it very well karan never lie to her .plus when she saw karan nandini hugged with each other and thought now nandini wanna come back in karan's life then why not tanya left karan as she said so many times.

she herself kickout nandini from sn but still taunting.

tanya said to karan i said you were not here because you were deep in your thought and obviously you were thinking abt nandini.

shameless woman if you thinks karan still loves nandini and she is still living in his herat then why not you left him.that means you have no selfrespect.

plus she said to him i gave you and your family 20 yares of my life.

oh thats why karan ko zabardsssasti tanya se pyar karna parega.

she said to karan i always respest your and nandini's love.

oh thats why you kicked out nandini from sn.

and in which angle do you think tanya truely loves with karan and she deserves karan's wifes rights.plz tell me.

she loves with karan thats why she is always blackmailing him,pushing him i gave you 20 years of my .life thats why mujhe pyar karo,i loook after your children thats why mujhe pyar karo sacha pyar karne wale ehsan jata kar pyar nahin mangte.she loves karan thats why she kickout nandini from sn.if you truely loves with somone then your happiness is your lover happiness not like tanya zbardasti pyar karo.she loves karan thats why she said to him apni thakan guest room main jaa kar mitalo.she loves karan thats why she said for tulsi infront of him maar jati to acha hota wapis kyun ayen infact she knew it very well what is the meaning of tulsi in karan'slife.she loves karan thats why she canceled jewerlly order .she loves karan thats why first she herself kickout nandini from sn but still taunting over karan you were not here because you were deep in your thought and obviuosly you were thinking abt nandini .shameles woman if you know nandini is stll leaving in karan's heart then whynot you left him that means you have no selfrespect.she loves him thats why when karan deeply in hurt with his behaviour towards tulsi and mhir and saw bhoomi with abhir instead of supporting him she was planning how to take revange with tulsi.

one more point according to some tany's fans when nandini left karan then why she came back.

she didn't come back in karan and bhoomi's life she just come back in mumbai.have you not seen

nandini was disappered when nandini got accident with karan's car and karan get her in sn.nandini showed infot of bhoomi and karan her fake marriage just for tanya.nandini didn't attend bhoomi's engaement just for tanya,nandini hidden her face in bhoomi's marriage just for tanya.nandini gave karan 24 hours ultimatem just for tanya.nandini is listening so many bad thing from bhooomi just for tanya,nandini is listening you are not a oart iof sn just for tanya,nandini is listening you have no relationship with karan and she didn't say just for tanya.what tanya did for nandini.nandini left karan for tayna two times but what tanya did with her in whaich angle do you think tanya deserve more sacrifices from nandini's side.plz tell me.


Lovely-Maiden thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#23
tanya is being used as a toy, either u twe karan-nands decide to eb each other from very ebginning or sacrifice and go away, not give her karan and after one lifetiem coem and throw her, "ghungru ki tarah bajta hi raha hoon main hogaya tanya ke liye", so now she is reacting, she is a human after all. ( abt tulsi, tulsi sent her innocent son to jail, spoiled bhumi's life separated her from her love, sent innocent eklavya to jail, she played with every child's life, naturally any mother will be against her as the three bahus became, its called tit for tat, mother love their children very much)

and she sud, u caNt use her, keep her throw her on ur wish, anyway I AM SURE ITS GOT TO DO WITH HITEN GAURI MORE, I WILL BELIEVE OTHERIWSE THE DAY HITEN GAURI ARE REPLACED
AND KARAN NANDINI CHARACTER PLAYED BY SOME OTHER ACTORS AND NO HOPE OF GHT RETURNING, EVEN TANYA IS REPLACED PROBABLY PROBABLY BY GAURI ( IN THAT CASE HITEN REMAINS KARAN)...AND U STILL CONTINUE TO SUPPORT KARAN ANNDINI AND BASH TANYA.

.
Edited by AryanDipikaFan - 17 years ago
Lovely-Maiden thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#24
ah or consider a simple case...the three actors REMAIN, JUST THEY SWITCH CHARACTERS, HITEN REMAINS KARAN, BUT NOW TANYA WILL BE PLAYED BY GAURI AND RAKSHANDA IS TO PLAY NANDINI.

what then people

😉 ...i know the whole thing will change upside down, reactions , support, bashing.

p.s - don't ask me why and how this thing will happen, the three actors switching places, it might/ might not happen, its just to illustrate my point that here actors are being supported and bashed, so logically defending a character isn't working.
prerna15 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#25

Jhanvi, Sunaina & Kaura thanks so much for your support to KN, despite not being their fan.

coolkitty_23 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: AryanDipikaFan

ah or consider a simple case...the three actors REMAIN, JUST THEY SWITCH CHARACTERS, HITEN REMAINS KARAN, BUT NOW TANYA WILL BE PLAYED BY GAURI AND RAKSHANDA IS TO PLAY NANDINI.

what then people

😉 ...i know the whole thing will change upside down, reactions , support, bashing.

p.s - don't ask me why and how this thing will happen, the three actors switching places, it might/ might not happen, its just to illustrate my point that here actors are being supported and bashed, so logically defending a character isn't working.



It might and then again it might not...but ths not the issue out here..they will probably not change the actors since it will have the TRP's crashing down...
coolkitty_23 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: adeela

you all karan nandini haters have nothing to defend tanya thats why you said we love karan nandini because gauri hiten played by karan nandini. the matter of fact is.

if you people have a strong point towards tanya than how can we fight with you obviously we will except your support towards tanya.and same with nandini and karan if you peeple have a strong point against nandini and karan than how can we fight with you we will except.

and why i hate tanya.

tanya knew it very well on her first day's of marriage karan was agreed to maried with her just for bhoomi's sake and he only and only loves with nandini.then whynot tanya refused to married with him why she was agreed to married wth that man who madly in loves wirth his first wife. infact nobody forced to her infact all virani's forced to karan.

first three years he didn't gives her wifes rights when tulsi came back after completing her 3 years prision she said to him then he gave her wifes rights but when nandini was comeback from coma docter called him he left tanya in their wedding anniversary and happiliy went to met nandini.when nandini was faint when she read his diary karan told infront of tulsi and tanya maine woh sare rishte khatam kardoga jo mere aur nandini ke beech ayen ge.when nandini got 14 years prision karan told him clearly you will never takes place nandi's place in my heart .then why not tanya except it nandini is karan's life and i am nothing infront of nandini in karan's life.then whynot she left him.thata means she is the most chipko woman.zabadasti pyar karo she said to karan so many times when nmandini will retuen i will leave you but she never fulfil her promise ,she said to karan i always respect your and nandini's love oh thats why she kicked out nandini from sn that means she is a biggest lier.plus when she knew abt nandini's marriage she said so many bad things to nandini then why not she was happy in that time and if she was sincerely thinking abt karan thats why she said so many bad things to her then why not she is happy right now and reunite karan nandini.no she was showing jelousy that means she is a double standard woman.

. two more points i wana add here .when nandini came back tanya left karan first of all tanya left karan because nandini wana marry to her with other guy she didn't leave karan for nandini's sake.plus she came back after few days and said i cant live without bhoomi ,but if tanya fans still think its sacrifice then its nothing infront of nandini's sacrifices.

other point tanya was redy to sign divorce papers ont he other han she was crying infront of al virani's and showed she will sacrifice and she went to nandini's house and showed infront of divorce papers sacrifice karne wale sub ko bata aur jata ke sacrifice nahin karte like nandini she stopped her and lying i was married with other guy.plus if tanya truely wants karan nandini's reunion she never kickout nandini from sn .

when karan asked her tumhe mujhe chor ke jane main meri khushi hai then tanya said tumhari kushi ke liye main tumhe chordongi but i cant live without you .then karan said to her tum mujhe kabhi chor kar najana and hugged her.but when mandira called to tanya she told her abt karan nandini then why tanya went to nandini's house whnot he believed karan after all tanya sped 20 yers with him and she knew it very well karan never lie to her .plus when she saw karan nandini hugged with each other and thought now nandini wanna come back in karan's life then why not tanya left karan as she said so many times.

she herself kickout nandini from sn but still taunting.

tanya said to karan i said you were not here because you were deep in your thought and obviously you were thinking abt nandini.

shameless woman if you thinks karan still loves nandini and she is still living in his herat then why not you left him.that means you have no selfrespect.

plus she said to him i gave you and your family 20 yares of my life.

oh thats why karan ko zabardsssasti tanya se pyar karna parega.

she said to karan i always respest your and nandini's love.

oh thats why you kicked out nandini from sn.

and in which angle do you think tanya truely loves with karan and she deserves karan's wifes rights.plz tell me.

she loves with karan thats why she is always blackmailing him,pushing him i gave you 20 years of my .life thats why mujhe pyar karo,i loook after your children thats why mujhe pyar karo sacha pyar karne wale ehsan jata kar pyar nahin mangte.she loves karan thats why she kickout nandini from sn.if you truely loves with somone then your happiness is your lover happiness not like tanya zbardasti pyar karo.she loves karan thats why she said to him apni thakan guest room main jaa kar mitalo.she loves karan thats why she said for tulsi infront of him maar jati to acha hota wapis kyun ayen infact she knew it very well what is the meaning of tulsi in karan'slife.she loves karan thats why she canceled jewerlly order .she loves karan thats why first she herself kickout nandini from sn but still taunting over karan you were not here because you were deep in your thought and obviuosly you were thinking abt nandini .shameles woman if you know nandini is stll leaving in karan's heart then whynot you left him that means you have no selfrespect.she loves him thats why when karan deeply in hurt with his behaviour towards tulsi and mhir and saw bhoomi with abhir instead of supporting him she was planning how to take revange with tulsi.

one more point according to some tany's fans when nandini left karan then why she came back.

she didn't come back in karan and bhoomi's life she just come back in mumbai.have you not seen

nandini was disappered when nandini got accident with karan's car and karan get her in sn.nandini showed infot of bhoomi and karan her fake marriage just for tanya.nandini didn't attend bhoomi's engaement just for tanya,nandini hidden her face in bhoomi's marriage just for tanya.nandini gave karan 24 hours ultimatem just for tanya.nandini is listening so many bad thing from bhooomi just for tanya,nandini is listening you are not a oart iof sn just for tanya,nandini is listening you have no relationship with karan and she didn't say just for tanya.what tanya did for nandini.nandini left karan for tayna two times but what tanya did with her in whaich angle do you think tanya deserve more sacrifices from nandini's side.plz tell me.



Adeela, I am sorry if this disappoints you, but i have noticed the same reply in the other KNT arguments..and I think this topic did not need this clarification at all..since all this topic asked for was do you think karan was right or not to give all the money in tanya's name, i dont think your explanation, unfortunately has to do anything with tht question. I just dont want, another set of bashing and counter b ashing start. And as for Aryan dipika's comment, a one liner would have done the job.Sorry if I hurt you.😕
Lovely-Maiden thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#28
koolkiitty that exactly the point, trps wud coem crashign down may eb, but my point is the actor not characters supported thign and except oen or two all support actors not chaarcter.
coolkitty_23 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: AryanDipikaFan

koolkiitty that exactly the point, trps wud coem crashign down may eb, but my point is the actor not characters supported thign and except oen or two all support actors not chaarcter.


The thing is, they r pretty much playing with the aydience's emotion by doing this, bringing a negative character inbet'n two good pair, and then taunting the audience with some romantic scenes and some scenes of pain betn them...I bet in the serial as such..they probably have not written the script for Nandini's complete return in SN yet..and that this drama will continue more...
Lovely-Maiden thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#30
tanya is hardly engative, she is juts human.
anyone wud react so in her place.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".