Posted:
I personally do not believe any one person is right or wrong here. It is a matter of individual perspective.
there is such a thing as letting sleeping dogs lie. Of course, in the show, Aradhna would be conveniently unmarried or maybe widowed. However, what happens if she indeed lived with her husband, and what if she had never told her husband about this past relationship, in the belief that past is past. In the process of fulfilling one men's death wish, another woman's family life may well be destroyed, her husband may well feel that she has betrayed him by not sharing her past with him. Now, Baba will in die in peace. But what will happen to Aradhna? I think this is worth considering too!
Ashutosh is at the moment concentrating on extending Baba's time with them by adopting a course of treatment that is the lesser of the two evils. He is not concentrating on Baba's death bed wish because he is not thinking of Baba dying, if this is denial, then so be it. I think most of us in his situation would try to focus on treatment to start with. Obviously, if Baba expressly told Ashutosh that he wanted to meet Aradhna, Ashutosh would not ask him to shut up or ignore his wishes. Nidhi is acting on the basis of information that she has secured by snooping around. I am not saying that her approach is wrong but, it is not necessarily true that her approach is the only right one, Adhutosh wants to respect Baba's privacy. I am unable to see that as a crime!
I don't know if anybody here has seen Astitva, Mahesh Manjrekar's film with Mohnish Bahl and Tabu. in a way, it illustrates the exact point I made above!
I don't know if anybody here has seen Astitva, Mahesh Manjrekar's film with Mohnish Bahl and Tabu. in a way, it illustrates the exact point I made above!
