Who is that drama for? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

51

Views

3.6k

Users

14

Likes

146

Frequent Posters

Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: radhika72


None of us like negativity. All the criticisms we see in the forum is to vent out our frustrations and anguish that the show you loved has detoriated to such a terrible condition. About Ashu the less said it is better. Everyone has the right to express his/her opinion as long as it does not hurt somebody. All we do is discuss about the happenings in the show which itself is an epitome of negativity right now.


i m saying the same thing... 😊
jayanti_dj thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: ithasme

Deepa, u give up??? On what??? Plsss bataao..:)


i dunno. Iam tired .thats all i can say.ab aur bardasht nahi hota.
shalini.malik72 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: deepa_jd


i dunno. Iam tired .thats all i can say.ab aur bardasht nahi hota.

come on Deepa you can't give up you are forums jaan...I know we are all feeling bad about the track par kabhi toh subh hogi...
Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: Armu4eva


i m saying the same thing... 😊



Tanu, there are probably shows that are far more steeped in negativity than this one...I wouldnt know cos I don't watch...even with this one, I follow your written updates and then catch up on yt if I feel like it...but yesterday, despite sufficient warning, I actually watched the epi...I really wanted to see what exactly was going on...and what I found was so very painful and lacking in any kind of rationale that I decided to share my frustrations with like-minded people...those who feel the show is going great guns are of course free to steer clear of my post...my topics are very clear about what I have to say...should be sufficient warning for those who don't want to be affected by my negativity to keep well away!

Like people have said in defence of Ashutosh, you are most critical of that which you care for...I don't care two hoots about any other show...I care about this one simply because I really like the concept, the actors and even the writer...I have admired some of KPjis films...so, when he churns out this kind of crap, it is but normal to react this way to it...I don't care about Ekta or anyone else and won't bother to criticize their shows...I don't watch them...this one I continue to watch or follow in the hope that things are actually going to make sense...like you said, my TV and my remote and also my time to waste if I choose to...and a democratic forum like this gives space for opinions both for and against the show. so long as no one individual is being targetted...I hope the democratic traditions will continue to be maintained...and like I say always. let us agree to disagree but let us do it with a degree of civility...!
shah1485 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: deepa_jd


i dunno. Iam tired .thats all i can say.ab aur bardasht nahi hota.

We are all frustrated by looking at the role of Ashu in the serial common we are in 2012 and being a neurosurgeon means the guy is not that stupid may be he is not well educated in love and romance but by giving him such a character to play is a like disrespectful to his profession he is looking like a noob as we said as we all know Ashu knows that sometimes Nidhi do react like a child but he understood it coz she is young but after a fight we r all very angry but aftera few minutes when we realised we do feel sry and try to repair our fault but Ashu didnt get this reaction and also how mean of him when BB wanted to go n look for Nidhi he prevents him and BB agreed wat kind of Grandfather,husband relation KPji is giving us meaning in households who are watching the show they will sure remember that even u r wrong dont go and compromise coz the wife will always come back as its a disgrace for both the wife and for her BB if she goes back to maikai Wow KPji what example are you giving to newly married couples
As we know in evry couple there are problems but for AshNi its would be little more coz of their age gap which will surely make them disapprove on many things but still they should compromise this is wat we want to see
Do u ppl agree
?
😃
jayanti_dj thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: shalini.malik72


come on Deepa you can't give up you are forums jaan...I know we are all feeling bad about the track par kabhi toh subh hogi...


shalini,i can take ny track that maintains trps. Hence never complained abt d track even once.
supu27111979 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#37
i didnot see that mafi scene may be she apologises next morning to mallu or is it same day?
subashni thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao



Tanu, there are probably shows that are far more steeped in negativity than this one...I wouldnt know cos I don't watch...even with this one, I follow your written updates and then catch up on yt if I feel like it...but yesterday, despite sufficient warning, I actually watched the epi...I really wanted to see what exactly was going on...and what I found was so very painful and lacking in any kind of rationale that I decided to share my frustrations with like-minded people...those who feel the show is going great guns are of course free to steer clear of my post...my topics are very clear about what I have to say...should be sufficient warning for those who don't want to be affected by my negativity to keep well away!

Like people have said in defence of Ashutosh, you are most critical of that which you care for...I don't care two hoots about any other show...I care about this one simply because I really like the concept, the actors and even the writer...I have admired some of KPjis films...so, when he churns out this kind of crap, it is but normal to react this way to it...I don't care about Ekta or anyone else and won't bother to criticize their shows...I don't watch them...this one I continue to watch or follow in the hope that things are actually going to make sense...like you said, my TV and my remote and also my time to waste if I choose to...and a democratic forum like this gives space for opinions both for and against the show. so long as no one individual is being targetted...I hope the democratic traditions will continue to be maintained...and like I say always. let us agree to disagree but let us do it with a degree of civility...!

Exactly my points. I am also not bothered about other shows. This serial had a promising beginning. Other serial makers do not claim their show as something for mature audience and different. If All you want to show is the run of the mill triangular love story or saas bahu type why do you claim it to be a love story involving a couple with age gap/? Why credit dhoop kinare/ why to show the lead characters as highly qualified professionals that too doctors. A doctor faking and other two qualified neurosurgeons not able to detect it/ How stupid can it get ? Does it not amount to cheating your viewers. If you want to give Mallu character this much of importance claim it as a triangular love story. Who prevented you? In the name of the lead pair" s charisma they are selling a crap. They know however hard they try viewers still believe and accept Ashu and Nidhi as the lead pair . If the pair is separated their show will be doomed . So keeping the pair together they try to give importance to Mallika as much as possible. the casualties are the story, ashu nidhi characterizations. Did the show seriously try to explore the bond between Ashu and Nidhi?. The lead pair appear pathetic . Ashu ' s all love declarations are farcical. His real care and trust is for Mallika .All his words are spoken to Nidhi but meant for Mallika. the makers have hidden agenda. They cannot sell the story with Mallu and Ashu as a pair .So they do it indirectly. This show does not need a couple with age gap. Age is not a factor when you dont trust your partner. All this MU s does not happen because of the age gap.
Edited by radhika72 - 13 years ago
mudraswathi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#39
This entire argument is reminding me of something...

When I was in the high school, our physics teacher taught us about the positive and negative poles...and she said these are arbitrarily named and what is not positive is negative and vice versa...

Later, in the pre university, our electronics teacher made this definition a bit more wider...When negative charges leave the atoms, we consider them having positively charged...

it went on... when I started reading and really understanding the philosophical literature( atleast I thought I could understand something)... Bhagwan Krishna himself suggested Arjun to kill Karan..when the later was not ready... isnt it wrong? isnt it suggesting negative nature?

No... It was told by Krishna himself, when it is an act which is useful in general, then you should classify it as positive...


Now in this current situation, in my view, pointing out the general negative track (or calling a spade as a spade) should not be taken as negative (or spreading negative)... why... it is helping us to identify the malignant tumour and helping us ( or by some remote chance, give the right message to the makers)... to cut it and enjoy the pleasure of removing it...this is a positive effect... probably all the this Ashutosh drama opens to some new direction in AshNi love... which we can enjoy to the extreme...


(Yes... I depend heavily and totally on the well balanced and well analysed WU of our forum members...for my POV... I proudly say, that all my research papers I had presented were based on the literature survey written by others as I cannot do everything on my own from the scratch)
Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: mudraswathi

This entire argument is reminding me of something...

When I was in the high school, our physics teacher taught us about the positive and negative poles...and she said these are arbitrarily named and what is not positive is negative and vice versa...

Later, in the pre university, our electronics teacher made this definition a bit more wider...When negative charges leave the atoms, we consider them having positively charged...

it went on... when I started reading and really understanding the philosophical literature( atleast I thought I could understand something)... Bhagwan Krishna himself suggested Arjun to kill Karan..when the later was not ready... isnt it wrong? isnt it suggesting negative nature?

No... It was told by Krishna himself, when it is an act which is useful in general, then you should classify it as positive...


Now in this current situation, in my view, pointing out the general negative track (or calling a spade as a spade) should not be taken as negative (or spreading negative)... why... it is helping us to identify the malignant tumour and helping us ( or by some remote chance, give the right message to the makers)... to cut it and enjoy the pleasure of removing it...this is a positive effect... probably all the this Ashutosh drama opens to some new direction in AshNi love... which we can enjoy to the extreme...


(Yes... I depend heavily and totally on the well balanced and well analysed WU of our forum members...for my POV... I proudly say, that all my research papers I had presented were based on the literature survey written by others as I cannot do everything on my own from the scratch)



Mudra, loved the atom analogy except that it went a bit over my head...have always been a miserable failure at science..but yes, I think all of us who are trying to analyse and understand the track and even criticize it are doing it only in the hope for a better future...we are hoping that the powers that be will possibly read our thoughts and understand the anguish of a discerning audience...if we thought this was a hopeless or a lost cause, I don't think any of us would actually bother...even as I type this, I am fantasizing KPji reading it 😆
Edited by Sujatha.rao - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".