कसौटी ज़िन्दगी के ২ LIVE UPDATE/Episode Discussions 24 Jul 2019 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

126

Views

17.7k

Users

23

Likes

297

Frequent Posters

vdna thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#11

I'm not sure the slap here qualifies as "abuse". I volunteer at a women's DV prevention and help charity in the USA which mostly deals with south Asian women, and based on what we go by anurag's slap would not qualify as domestic violence or abuse just like how prerna's slap didn't qualify as abuse when she hit Anurag for marrying komolika.

A slap becomes an abuse when it is used to exercise control and kind of make life hell for the spouse - any slight deviation from expected behavior makes an abusive spouse (usually husbands) slap their wives and there is such a humungous fear in these women - it is incomparable to the fictitious situation that our story leads are in!

Prerna is clearly not a victim of abuse here based on real world laws :). Yes it is completely incorrect to get physically violent with anyone - and no one condones that but not all situations of physical violence qualifies as abuse.

When some person provokes you to such an extent - it is only human that the one on the receiving end might respond with their reflexes before their brain can control their action - in such situations we are told to strongly assess the situation and find out from the complainant as to how often they encounter such situations and under what circumstance the violence was perpetrated, how frequent it is and so on.

So let's not label anurag's slap as abusive. Prerna is NOT a victim of any sort of domestic abuse here (yet). Now if Anurag continues to stalk her/harm her and the likes after she very clearly tells him to stay away - then it would (in a real world situation) help if prerna files a restraining order against Anurag.

We are explicitly told to analyse situations fully before deeming something as abuse - so just thought i'd share since I have first hand experience dealing with a lot of women who immigrate to the USA and who suffer at the hands of controlling husbands!

priya185 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#12

thanks for this topic

I hope something positive happens today for us anupre fans

CutiepieHarshad thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#13

Here for bajaj☺️

Hoping for good episode today

Not interested in anu’s gundagiri😡

MERARAI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: vandana21

I'm not sure the slap here qualifies as "abuse". I volunteer at a women's DV prevention and help charity in the USA which mostly deals with south Asian women, and based on what we go by anurag's slap would not qualify as domestic violence or abuse just like how prerna's slap didn't qualify as abuse when she hit Anurag for marrying komolika.

A slap becomes an abuse when it is used to exercise control and kind of make life hell for the spouse - any slight deviation from expected behavior makes an abusive spouse (usually husbands) slap their wives and there is such a humungous fear in these women - it is incomparable to the fictitious situation that our story leads are in!

Prerna is clearly not a victim of abuse here based on real world laws :). Yes it is completely incorrect to get physically violent with anyone - and no one condones that but not all situations of physical violence qualifies as abuse.

When some person provokes you to such an extent - it is only human that the one on the receiving end might respond with their reflexes before their brain can control their action - in such situations we are told to strongly assess the situation and find out from the complainant as to how often they encounter such situations and under what circumstance the violence was perpetrated, how frequent it is and so on.

So let's not label anurag's slap as abusive. Prerna is NOT a victim of any sort of domestic abuse here (yet). Now if Anurag continues to stalk her/harm her and the likes after she very clearly tells him to stay away - then it would (in a real world situation) help if prerna files a restraining order against Anurag.

We are explicitly told to analyse situations fully before deeming something as abuse - so just thought i'd share since I have first hand experience dealing with a lot of women who immigrate to the USA and who suffer at the hands of controlling husbands!

I get your point and am aware of what abuse entails.

I made a generic statement about abuse in its simplest definition....mishandling.

It was not a comment about the characters on the show. I did not say Anu or Pre’s slaps were abusive. In social situations abuse is the word used for repeated long term misuse .....be it emotional, mental, verbal or physical ....as in domestic violence.

If the men were to beat each other up that’s unacceptable too.

We can always find justifications for either gender based on circumstances. It’s better to step back or leave the space, regroup then address the problem.

TV shows have to take some responsibility for the content they allow or promote on their fictional shows. Why flood the airwaves with negative imagery, young minds are easily influenced. Slapping each other wouldn’t resolve the situation, it’s just unwanted ott drama and ITV make it an integral part of their serials.

Edited by MERARAI - 6 years ago
arshi_asya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: opsora2090

yah .. but there is lil bit differences as well as in general

If Male is slapped by a female there will involve only the dignity part

but if a female is slapped by male there will involve both the dignity and also the physical tolerance .

In max time female could not give it back properly against the violence , but a man can do easily if he wants or able to .


There are women who are very exploitative & literally involve in physical violence & there are men who don't react back only to avoid a case because laws are skewed.

So, a woman slapping man isn't only about dignity, women can be abusive & physically violent as well for no reason at all. And I have seen psychological & legal cases of it in reality.

Physical violence & abuse can't be separated from context, intention & situation and that's how law works.

Slapping or physical violence in heated conversations between any party is wrong & shouldn't happen. Period.

Edited by arshi_asya - 6 years ago
arshi_asya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: vandana21

I'm not sure the slap here qualifies as "abuse". I volunteer at a women's DV prevention and help charity in the USA which mostly deals with south Asian women, and based on what we go by anurag's slap would not qualify as domestic violence or abuse just like how prerna's slap didn't qualify as abuse when she hit Anurag for marrying komolika.

A slap becomes an abuse when it is used to exercise control and kind of make life hell for the spouse - any slight deviation from expected behavior makes an abusive spouse (usually husbands) slap their wives and there is such a humungous fear in these women - it is incomparable to the fictitious situation that our story leads are in!

Prerna is clearly not a victim of abuse here based on real world laws :). Yes it is completely incorrect to get physically violent with anyone - and no one condones that but not all situations of physical violence qualifies as abuse.

When some person provokes you to such an extent - it is only human that the one on the receiving end might respond with their reflexes before their brain can control their action - in such situations we are told to strongly assess the situation and find out from the complainant as to how often they encounter such situations and under what circumstance the violence was perpetrated, how frequent it is and so on.

So let's not label anurag's slap as abusive. Prerna is NOT a victim of any sort of domestic abuse here (yet). Now if Anurag continues to stalk her/harm her and the likes after she very clearly tells him to stay away - then it would (in a real world situation) help if prerna files a restraining order against Anurag.

We are explicitly told to analyse situations fully before deeming something as abuse - so just thought i'd share since I have first hand experience dealing with a lot of women who immigrate to the USA and who suffer at the hands of controlling husbands!

+1

Anurag needs to be condemned for the slap & Prerna's reaction should be assessed. Her reaction was a smile. A truly abused person or who feels the abuse will never ever smile after abuse. Psychologically & legally, abusive behavior is a repetition of same kind of abuse (mental, physical, emotional, physical) to control or intimidate the other party into submission or thrash their resistance for the perpetrators act. The assessment of victim has a lot more weight while looking into abuse charges.

Edited by arshi_asya - 6 years ago
Peacefulmind thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#17

https://www.instagram.com/p/B0R6UGDBLfp/?igshid=1lgnuesgudrmx

Does bajaj understand what it means crossing line

Bhagya65 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#18

I am litreally trying my hard to connect and feel sorry for Pre but simply cant. She just irritate me right now.

anupre123 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Parijatrocks

https://www.instagram.com/p/B0R6UGDBLfp/?igshid=1lgnuesgudrmx

Does bajaj understand what it means crossing line

When he himself crossed the line by blackmailing Pre... 🤔

Also, I wont bring Women into Business, respect them etc and uses Pre against Onu proposal in the meeting

CutiepieHarshad thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#20

Waiting for angry bajaj now☺️

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".