|firefliesHaven|MaNan AT#108| Of Intentional Goofups n Moon Eyes... - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

91k

Users

70

Likes

3.7k

Frequent Posters

white_beauty thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: charminggenie


Same . No eating disorder, no suicidal tendencies , no random Momma drama , still normal character on the show. 😆

It will be annoying her breaking point because that will mean ugly crying, her dependence on Manik , her confusion while all other characters be at better place in life. Just handle it well .

the eating disorder irks me so bad
the nanadini breakdown..can it be possible in a way that yes initially crying outburst once but eventually it all turning into anger at how everything has gone wrong for her she going into a shell with all her confusion and trying to work things out and not wanting help from others including manik..i mean anger can actually do alot in rebooting her character at this point also wanting to be free of any dependency on anyone which brings me to the point that manik will obviously go all paranoid about this kidnapping thing and become more protective rather over protective about her...over bearing without realising it and nandini getting all suffocated due to this adding her own issues post kidnapping?
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#72
@Zahara - See this is the thing for 100 odd episodes you had mystery which is why a lot fo characters seemed promising - Mukti but the moment we realized her deal with Harshad that was gone, then we had recovering phase which started on a good note but CC could never sell her expressions, she played the intial Mukti all the time. Even with Abhi , I could understand the relationship but those bambi love sick eyes during NYE was such an overkill.Like I said they gave lot of things to this character but it never could connect because bad acting. Something that happened with Uttu too but also his dumping down was too much intially , which is why a character that had so much potential got wasted. Uttu played it bad and then his dis-connect with Nandu harmed him.
The only consistent thing has been MaNan track because PaNi execute it and sort of hold the show.

Alya is someone I adore a lot but I have absolute hate for this eating disorder it makes her growth so Mukti like now .
moonstonespirit thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: charminggenie


Same . No eating disorder, no suicidal tendencies , no random Momma drama , still normal character on the show. 😆

It will be annoying her breaking point because that will mean ugly crying, her dependence on Manik , her confusion while all other characters be at better place in life. Just handle it well .


I just want a track dedicated to Nandu, her past, how it affects her current decisions... Can they make Aryamann her childhood friend?? Someone who knows about her past, her shortcomings...
I would love to have a glimpse into her world. If not now, at least at a later point.
BoxedIn thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#74
Mukti needed the harsh truth of rehab sessions, not Abhi's cheesy lou. 🥱
.Kiran. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: BoxedIn


Sorry Kiran. I got carried away there. Your gifs are beautiful.
Even though I haven't watched the episode. 🤔

And yes, it took me right back to that drunk night where he had waited for her walls to come down, for her talk about 'feelings'. And this time, he is waiting because she asks him to, because even their hands don't touch, he knows it's a promise she's made him. And that is enough to keep him in that car- just the sight of her hand on his.

Now if only the CVs would stop getting the girl kidnapped and make her actually say those words the poor guy's been dying to hear. 😆


This doesn't count. You need to watch the episode first. Ill post them in your thread. Watch the episode whenever and then you can fangirl over this scene. I will wait. I always give in. f**k. Im so nice.
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#76
@Zahara - Dude there is never a normal external which pisses me this kidnapping better give me that break-point. I also wanted her break-point after Dhruv's accusation , i felt her reaction was so for Manik , that scene was all about Manik than her hurt as a woman by a friend ( credits - Boxter).
Also that Amms letter- that should play more . Such an opening.

MaNan are perfectly in sync , so to shake them they go to these OTT characters which are so unnecessary . My problem is they never transition well, see Nandu almost died after Soha bit but it was all about manik's fear not her fear for her own life . That is disservice and why people cannot react to her kidnapping/Pandit thing. No breathing space to Nandu there.


@White - Love to see a numb, angry Nandu but eventual crying is necessary , but keep it for a day and then let her detach and focus on missing spunk. But make it about her even if Manik has to be sensitive to her.



CooChi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#77
@Zahara..I never really had a problem with MukBhi ..it was just the execution and CC's acting.
Zain's part was very light..they never gave him very serious or angst filled scenes. They gave him scenes where even an expressionless face can get a lot of scope.
Their story from Abhi's side was never a problem for me. He was THE MR. RANDOM from the time they introduce him.He entered into Murthy's territory by telling them some twisted fake story.
The guy was always that clever. What I see in their thing is how Abhi liked her..how she was one of his SUBJECTS of counselling..but he started feeling more for her..He felt that she might start experiencing what is love all about and its beauty..
Let us assume they fell in love..But Abhi can never see his loved ones in pain(male Nandu)..he realised it very late and left her.
He went hiding and Mukti found him and declared her true lau.
The scene where he asks her not to poor baby him..the guy was pissed. He wanted love and all he got was pity.Still he gave her the chance..Valentines day and after that...
The guy again left her..what I concluded here is he was simply disappointed cause not a single person in his life was able to treat him like a normal person
Every1 sympathised with him and this left him with no choice than running away. Every person doesn't have the good luck of getting a Happy Ending.
See..its a nice story .
Just OTT acting and rushed scenes ruined it.
Edited by CooChi - 10 years ago
ZAHARA. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: charminggenie

@Zahara - See this is the thing for 100 odd episodes you had mystery which is why a lot fo characters seemed promising - Mukti but the moment we realized her deal with Harshad that was gone, then we had recovering phase which started on a good note but CC could never sell her expressions, she played the intial Mukti all the time. Even with Abhi , I could understand the relationship but those bambi love sick eyes during NYE was such an overkill.Like I said they gave lot of things to this character but it never could connect because bad acting. Something that happened with Uttu too but also his dumping down was too much intially , which is why a character that had so much potential got wasted. Uttu played it bad and then his dis-connect with Nandu harmed him.

The only consistent thing has been MaNan track because PaNi execute it and sort of hold the show.

Alya is someone I adore a lot but I have absolute hate for this eating disorder it makes her growth so Mukti like now .


Why couldn't Abhi stay as Nandini's friend? Or mainly as her friend? like... agh! So annoying. Bad acting just annoy me so much. Uttu! Dhruv had a lot of potential but it was just too... D: I don't even have the words to explain, and you know about CC.

PaNi are brilliant. I don't care about their offscreen crap, but on screen they do pull themselves together.

I love Alya. I think she's great. But she is also someone who has been in the background plotwise. And I honestly think this eating disorder could be an interesting plot, especially if it runs parallel to Nandini's breakdown. I don't agree that her growth is like Mukti's because we never saw Mukti getting depression and anxiety, that was there from the start... with Alya's we've seen what happened and now we're seeing how it's affects her. She was shown as being health aware and even Harshad mentioned episodes back about her chocolate habits. She's trying to drown her problems with chocolate. This girl, who saw what Mukti has gone through, is now falling into bulimia. This is her breakdown. (And maybe it might led to everything about Dhruv that was brushed under the carpet to be out in the open, which needs to be!).

I find Alya and Nandini to have similiarities (as I've said before); and IF these tracks play parallel, you have Nandini's breakdown from all these events and how it affects her, and you also have how the consequences of Dhruv's disappearance from Fab 5 and everything that happened affecting Alya.

Can these two girls just confide in themselves? Nandini has never had the 'girl talk' or a personal talk with Navya, even though she is her friend. (at least I don't think so)... and if Mukti and Navya can have that, why can't Alya and Nandini?


BoxedIn thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#79
@Kiran: Thank you for posting them in the thread. 🤗I'll call for you if I ever manage to watch and get feels.

@Genie: Stop quoting me and get off the AT. Someone told me to kick you out of your old habits. So.
-KP- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: charminggenie

@Zahara - Dude there is never a normal external which pisses me this kidnapping better give me that break-point. I also wanted her break-point after Dhruv's accusation , i felt her reaction was so for Manik , that scene was all about Manik than her hurt as a woman by a friend ( credits - Boxter).

Also that Amms letter- that should play more . Such an opening.

MaNan are perfectly in sync , so to shake them they go to these OTT characters which are so unnecessary . My problem is they never transition well, see Nandu almost died after Soha bit but it was all about manik's fear not her fear for her own life . That is disservice and why people cannot react to her kidnapping/Pandit thing. No breathing space to Nandu there.


@White - Love to see a numb, angry Nandu but eventual crying is necessary , but keep it for a day and then let her detach and focus on missing spunk. But make it about her even if Manik has to be sensitive to her.




Exactly! Soha almost killed her and even then, they focused more on Manik's fear about her life than Nandu's own. It's like she was fine the next day and that it didn't even matter to her even for a second.
With Dhruv's accusation, I will let it go be because Manik did explain to her that Dhruv is lashing out at her because of him; so I sort of understand why we didn't see a breaking point for her back then.
BUT NOW!! THEY CANNOT SHOW HER BEING BACK TO NORMAL AND ALL HAPPY. She was forcibly abducted and is being held against her will. This has to shake her up. IT'S ABOUT TIME SHE HAS BREAKDOWN, CVs.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".