DOTW: The BIG decision

soni595 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

DISCUSSION TIME:

-What do you think, after finding out what happened to her, should kinjal abort the kid in her womb? Would this be RIGHT/WRONG of a choice?

-Do you think, Neena should have any right of this child if Kinjal gives birth to it?

-Do you think OUR decisions affect only ourselves and only our lives or other people connected to it? Should society have a SAY in your life and your choices?

DISCUSSION SIGN-UP SHEET

Jan 22 - Jan 29

Jan 29 - Feb 5

Feb 5 - Feb 12

Feb 12 - Feb 19

Feb 19 - Feb 26

So we all know that VALENTINES is coming up to be exact, it is a month away, so why don't we do something special for this special occasion. So if you have any ideas about what we should do, please PM me, soni595

Have Fun and Keep smiling..

Edited by soni595 - 17 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1k

Users

7

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

gujugurl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: soni595

DISCUSSION TIME:

-What do you think, after finding out what happened to her, should kinjal abort the kid in her womb? Would this be RIGHT/WRONG of a choice?

first of all if i was kinjal i would be freaked out cause i wouldn't know whose baby it is and will sue the hospital....as far as abortion goes it not really the baby's fault in all so abortion would be a bad idea then again to save the izat of your family and yourself would go through it......so i'm a bit in btw...

-Do you think, Neena should have any right of this child if Kinjal gives birth to it?

sure if neena acts like yashoda in all this....

-Do you think OUR decisions affect only ourselves and only our lives or other people connected to it? Should society have a SAY in your life and your choices?

it definately has other people connected to it...cause in your life u get so many people connected to u that even u yourself might not know..as far as the society go if your family has no problems with u then u shouldn;t listen to the society cause even their lives are very much screwed up and it gives them no right to go on bashing into someelses....

p.s. soni i love this discussion....

luv margi😳

::Prem$_Priya:: thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
Great discussion, got to run but I'll try to answer the questions as soon as possible. 😊
nandini27 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
well..acc to b it was wrong tht so much happened without kinjal knowing....but thinking of her character i think she will not abort the kid....but i think she'l hav full rights on the baby...bcos she hasnt signed the papers..yet..tht she has nuthing to da with the baby after birth....so...tht wud happen....like she wont b ready to giv away the baby.....

neena...for her its better she doesnt interfere with the baby...or else it'l create more problems in her life...and she'l hav to face more sorrows......

and for the society...i really hav no idea....

neways...gr8 discussion.....for the week...but every1 shud put in their views to make it activ.....

LUV NANDINI
soni595 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#5

Yea, I guess not many members on this forum enjoy discussions!!😆😆 Maybe this'll be the last DOTW then, since the DOTW's aren't that active.

Thanks Nandani and Margi for sharing your views, I enjoyed reading them!!👏👏 Sanya would love to read your views too!!

1) As an individual, I think Kinjal's decision to abort the child borders in between right and wrong. Meaning, since Kinjal never chose to be a mother and never did anything to be one, not wanting the baby could be right in her perspective. At the same time, since inside her womb is a living child, killing it would also be wrong. It's very complicated, since you usually have people knowingly get into situations with a possibility of knowing both outcomes, whereas Kinjal was suddenly struck, without any knowledge, commitment or consent.

Anyways, I do think Kinjal will decide to keep the child, and give birth to it. She seems to be the type of girl, who'd shiver/injure herself than harm anyone else, let alone a tiny fetus growing inside of her.

2) Technically, no Neena should have no right to claim that child from Kinjal. Since, it is Kanav's child and since Kinjal will give birth to it, hers too. At the same time, being Kanav's wife, and him being the father, she may claim the child on that basis.

Since Neena doesn't want the child, wanting it, just to hurt Kinjal would be wrong. A child needs a mother who can nourish, care and love the child, if Neena can develop such feelings for the child then that'll be okay but if she doesn't, it'll be wrong not only on Neena's part but Kinjal's part to give it to her.

3) Technically, no people should have not have a say in your life, especially not society. One should live to what it can offer its decisions and choices, if you run by societies laws, crushing under the burden of it, then you should not. A lot of people could tarnish your image, pushing you to do things, when they themselves in that situationw would not.

However, our lives are definitely connected to the people we love and care about, their best interests can mean a tremendous amount to you, to direct your decisions. You know if after the outcome of your decision they are hurt, you won't be able to repair it, and will suffer because their hurt is somehow connected to you.

So if Kinjal wants to abort the child to save her family's reputation, then maybe that wouldn't be so wrong, but then their reputation would be tarnished by society, so should society have that much influence, yet that protects her loved ones. I hope I didn't confuse you all with my thoughts.

Keep smiling..

Love

Soni

::Prem$_Priya:: thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
Sorry for not replying!! I think it was too late but in short I would say:

1. The type of girl Kinjal is, she would never abort the baby and I think it would be wrong to kill a life in you and that it's not even born yet. But she is young and not married but this was all somebody else's mistake so she will probably still have the baby and I think it would be rite to.

2.I actually never thought of this (good question 😃) but I think Neena mite try to have rights over the baby and since Kinjal is really sweet and loves her friend more than anything, then I guess she will give rights to Neena.


3. oH YEAH i think ppl all around you always get's affected and I think society has somewhat rights to have a say in your life, depending on the situation

Lots of Love(LOL) Priya
happygrl thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: soni595

DISCUSSION TIME:

-What do you think, after finding out what happened to her, should kinjal abort the kid in her womb? Would this be RIGHT/WRONG of a choice?

I think she should have an abortion. It's all so creepy. It's not her kid really - she didn't want it. How will she bring it up anyway?

-Do you think, Neena should have any right of this child if Kinjal gives birth to it?

Hell No, not even Kanav really. They both suck 🤢

-Do you think OUR decisions affect only ourselves and only our lives or other people connected to it? Should society have a SAY in your life and your choices?

I guess our decision affect people close to us - and you need to care for their sentiments. Society in general - who cares. My life, my terms 😳

DISCUSSION SIGN-UP SHEET

Jan 22 - Jan 29

Jan 29 - Feb 5

Feb 5 - Feb 12

Feb 12 - Feb 19

Feb 19 - Feb 26

So we all know that VALENTINES is coming up to be exact, it is a month away, so why don't we do something special for this special occasion. So if you have any ideas about what we should do, please PM me, soni595

Have Fun and Keep smiling..

k-ekta fan thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

-What do you think, after finding out what happened to her, should kinjal abort the kid in her womb? Would this be RIGHT/WRONG of a choice?

no she can't b'coz she is already so weak dat if she will try 2 obort d child if will b dangerous 4 her life only.... I don't knw if she will abort her child is rite or rong. but 1 think is sure wht happen wid her was completely rong. dis must hve nt happen. nthing rong was her but den also she hve 2 pay 4 it....

-Do you think, Neena should have any right of this child if Kinjal gives birth to it?

no way..... she must nt... she opt out 2 b mother 4 her career. so wht is gurantee afterward dat she will b gud mother.... n again she will nt go 4 her career....

-Do you think OUR decisions affect only ourselves and only our lives or other people connected to it? Should society have a SAY in your life and your choices?

yes it effect every1 in d soceity... i.e. v need 2 thnk twice b4 doinsumthing rong.. whch will raise ? on us or our family... but frankly whtever d perosn do wid his own life outsider ppl must nt interferce b'coz it is our n deir own life.. but if it effect 2 society den surely dere interfecrnce is justiable.....

soni luv ur discussion ?

luv Mona Lisa😉

Mages thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 17 years ago
#9

-What do you think, after finding out what happened to her, should kinjal abort the kid in her womb? Would this be RIGHT/WRONG of a choice?

well knowing kinjal atitute she will give birth to the child though i have seen little episodes of KNK but then by seeing the little episodes kinjal character is a angel she will harm herself but not someone else and this her own child even though its not her consent it happen by fault sure she will give birth as she also knows that killing a child is a sin and she can never do that being a women as being a mother is all women dreams and she knows this....its a 100% confirmation form me that kinjal will not abort the baby

-Do you think, Neena should have any right of this child if Kinjal gives birth to it?

No at all she chose her career than a baby so she must not have any rights on the baby what is the guarantee that she will take good care of the child in my view even kanav does not deserve the child because he is using his own blood for some revenge of his family and to get the haveli....but if kanav really changes than he deserve the child....and it will be known as Kanav-Kinjal love symbol but simply neena have no rights on the baby a career women who is so ambitious will never take good care fo the baby....

knowing kinjal she might give the baby but still she being the mother of the child she might not stand the seperation of the child

according to me kinjal is the best mother for the baby

-Do you think OUR decisions affect only ourselves and only our lives or other people connected to it? Should society have a SAY in your life and your choices?

No its our lives and it should go on our terms society has no rights on our lives whether they like it or not....and kinjal should do what she thinks is right for her

Edited by Mages - 17 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".