How fair are the judges in their markings

Page

Next Last

Bhaskar

@Bhaskar.T

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

How fair do you think they are with their ratings? I personally find Sudesh Bhosle to be the only one who is giving proper comments and marks according to that.

Amit Kumar is one I am finding too erratic. What exactly is he trying to find among the contestants??? Another Kishore clone???

Quote

Frequent Posters

OMkar

@omkar.dandekar

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

I agree with KCP 100% and agree with Bhaskar 0%
Amit Kumar is the soul of this show. Look at how exactly he points out exactly where the contestant went wrong. Rathar, I feel Sudesh and Bappi takes the idea to give their remarks from Amit only. When Amit mentions something, both of them just behave like NANDI BAIL... hehehehehe And most importantly this is a show of Kishore Kumar songs and Amit Kumar DOES NOT expect ANYONE on this planet to be like Kishore Kumar because he is very much aware that NO ONE can be like him. The show on Kishore Kumar itself is the strong proof to support my statement. So Amit Kumar expecting any clone is out of question!

Edited by omkar.dandekar - 17 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

HariOm

@HariOm

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

i like SB and AK's comments. Bappi gets on my nerves. No matter what he'll say "my bhanja ye, woh" and burst out into a song.Its like he's there to promote himslef and his singing.

SB and AK seem down to earth. Earlier though I felt AK came drunk on the sets, but last time, he was ok.

Quote

HariOm

@HariOm

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: kcp
HariOm...thats his normal style of speaking. His voice does become "drowsy" at places 😃 . But once you know him quite well, it is ok :-)

Thanks for clarifying it. We were feeling bad that AK cannot stop drinking or what

Quote

myprincess

@myprincess

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Judges are not fair w/marking at all i think!

Quote

Rockfort

@Rockfort

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

If Bappi and SSudhesh do not comment on Amit's remarks they do so out of politeness. They do not want to insult him before everyone.

Amit seems to be drunk all the time. I hope he gets removed.

Quote

grao

@ani_gr

Stunner

Posted: 17 years ago

the best judge i like here are sudhesh & amit later. i just cannot stand with bappida's comments. it is the same for everyone.

Quote

Bhaskar

@Bhaskar.T

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: kcp
nopes. He is putting across "his" views, which nobody else can point out better ( which is the sole purpose of this show - IMHO )

Sorry can't agree to this point. Do you mean to say our Music industry lacks proper judges as far as music goes? We have much more successful and better musicians and singer than him. Sorry it may hurt Amit Kumar fans but thats the truth.

Amit Kumars judgement is too inconsistent. You never know what rates he'll be giving for similar performances. If one he gives 5 for lacking emotions then next moment he gives 7 for same error to another contestant.

Infact my own POV is maybe all the three judges themselves have no clear idea what to do here and what rates to give.

Quote

advil

@advil

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: omkar.dandekar
I agree with KCP 100% and agree with Bhaskar 0%
Amit Kumar is the soul of this show. Look at how exactly he points out exactly where the contestant went wrong. Rathar, So Amit Kumar expecting any clone is out of question!

Actually I am still trying to figure out what mistakes he is pointing out.. I enjoy his tidbits on Kishoreda, but his marking, judging are not upto the mark.

I also feel only Sudesh Bhosle is bang on...the other two - I am not too sure they know what they are really looking for.!

Quote

Bhaskar

@Bhaskar.T

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

#10

Other two are not looking for anything. Bappida is more interested in promoting his own singing 😆 While Amit Kumar more interested in showing he is the best when it comes to judging Kishore clones. 😉 😆

Quote

1 2

How fair are the judges in their markings

Related Topics

Explore Topics