Shameful behavior of some judges

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

madhyha

@madhy

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: smallwonder
Agree with all wat u said except for Vishal's judging... He was no different than the other two... I dont think Toshi sang better than Abhijeet or Harshit whereas he got a 7 as opposed to 6 for the other two... It was clear Vishal gave a 6 to Harshit only to bring down the score after Farha's 10... If he were to give his score first, I doubt if he would have given less than 7 or 8...

exactly nd did u notice in last 2 epi farah was only one who gave abhijeet 10 while others gave him 9..nd in previous week while all other judges gave him nd vineet 8 she gave dem 9...but no body commented on it neither opned a thread to make it as a big issue😕 dts for sure vishal's clear fav is Abhijeet nd rahul.. did they evr shocked wen harshit or debo was in bottom 3..😕If vishal can give 10 to rahul even b4 his performance y not farah should open her 10 ki dukkan for harshit once😳btw harshit didnt deserve 6 frm vishal...he was much better den Abhi😕

Quote

Abhijit Kulkarni

@kabhi_21

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

I was shocked to see some of the behaviors of the judges today. I think none of them are fit to be a judge except humara taklu bhai.

Let me start with Shekhar. We have seen from the very begining that when a Champion gets eliminated then the "Star" is taken away. We have seen that happening with the real champions like Ujjaini, Aishwariya, Rooprekha, and Ishmeet. We have seen the same with runners-up turned champion like Amit Sana. The same process was followed in case of other contestant turned champions like Prajakta, Himani, and Priyani.

So, why is Vinit treated differently? Kyun bhai why a step child behavior for these champions, and kingly treatment for Vinit. Do you mean to say that the remaining contestants were not capable enough to be the champions.

I agree that it was quite unfair to many contestants eliminated.... but i felt it was a request straight from his heart which vinit earned and others could not earn it yet.... Till now only good singer eliminated was aishwarya and we all know that reason for his elimination was to host SRGMP USA.... I would not call shekhar a bad judge just because he acted what his heart told him to do rather than star plus telling him 😃

Coming to Farah. Finally, we have our old Farah back. She is back to judging performances instead of singing. From next week she will start judging the clothes of the contestants.

Then her comment "Mera superstar to chala gaya." What the hell???? You are a judge, God Damn it!!! You are supposed to be neutral, and unbiased.

She was always judging performances 😕

Then her scores for Harshit. Kyun Madam, Bhaang ka rate kya hai aaj kaal??? I don't know what she was thinking today. All the scores she gave today was 🤢.

I was really impressed with Vishal's judging today. His marks were perfect today. 8 was his highest and everyone was judged accordingly.👏

Vishal was good for the most of the part today.... but i wont agree either with his comments or marking for debu.... debu completely ruined that song and still got away with 8 from vishal.... I would nt comment on score from other judges as they gave away minimum 8 to all yesterday... but debu deserved similar or lesser marks than abhijeet and harshit

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

irum

@musicaddict1

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

#13

i think vishal is a great judge... so impartial like all judges should be

Quote

Abhijit Kulkarni

@kabhi_21

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: apparaohoare
I totally understand that the judges might have a soft corner for Vinit. Afterall he was the youngest of the lot. But when it comes to judging these contestants, all of them should be judged on a level plane, and not based on age, or whether the contestnat can smile or not.

I think from a Music director's point of view, a singer's mood and expression does matter.... if they tell harshit to try to smile and sing if song is romantic, then its for his good as a singer...😊

Quote

Akanksha

@-Akanksha-

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

#15

shekhar guest judges ke tarah ban gaye, gave everyone 8s. farah is farah. seemed like she was missing her dus ka dukaan. her comment on harshit's smile... yes it can help him a lot, if he smiles more then it can bring more happiness into his singing when it is needed. but harshit's comment was really true, it can be hard for some people; not everyone opens up like that. then vishal...i dont know what he's playing at. he's inconsistent in his own criteria; sometimes he scores comparing two contestants and sometimes he doesnt. but harshit's scores really shocked me. his chaand mera dil was very nice, but the other two were not. i dont think he was better than abhijeet or debojit or even rahul, dunno why farah gave him 10. maybe she wasnt comparing...who knows? but what got to me was such difference in opinions. 6-8-10. 😕 i mean a difference in opinions is fair, what would life be like if everyone had the same opinion, but such disagreeing scores...

Quote

Seeya Ahmad

@karunya_forever

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: smallwonder
Agree with all wat u said except for Vishal's judging... He was no different than the other two... I dont think Toshi sang better than Abhijeet or Harshit whereas he got a 7 as opposed to 6 for the other two... It was clear Vishal gave a 6 to Harshit only to bring down the score after Farha's 10... If he were to give his score first, I doubt if he would have given less than 7 or 8...

i second u....