worst judging on any talent show

tell you honestly when we heard about this program we were so excited as vishal shekhar as judges and farah khan but after watching till date it has been according to us one of the most worst judging on any show. so many time what they say completely riddiculous there comments and marks doesnt tally and the peak was that in one episode vishal said that song from lagaan even AR rehman was out of sur sorry but i just cant digest that ,vishal may be good at his pentagram and creating music but he is not reached to the level where he can comments about sur of AR rehamn a legend. so many times judges gives full marks when singing was not up to level and song was flat and at same so many times even the contestant has sung it perfecly they cut marks and say low notes problem or some stupid reason which isnt true as many talneted musicians we know laugh at there comments and poor laymen dont know anything about this and they think exactly what judges are saying.

there is so much problem in some of singers diction but still they get full marks

especially when they singing s in song.

Agreed 100% How could he say that Ar's Sur was not perfect He is a legend Vishal Is Just a beginner As compared To AR

i'm not saying him saying that about AR's sur was right, but we don't know he's not up to that level. i don't know either, but for all we know he may have more musical knowledge than AR and only got into the music industry late in his musical life. may not be true, but...something to think about

Judges are biased - Yes... But worst judging on any talent show - No... I think VOI judges beat anyone and everyone at horrendous judging and I feel they are set to hold the record for a long time to come...

Originally posted by: smallwonder

Judges are biased - Yes... But worst judging on any talent show - No... I think VOI judges beat anyone and everyone at horrendous judging and I feel they are set to hold the record for a long time to come...

Ha ha..i agree. aadesh, abhijeet and alka were all for promoting their favourites- harshit, toshi and abhilasha and ignored poor arshpreet and irfan. it was pathetic

Originally posted by: smallwonder

Judges are biased - Yes... But worst judging on any talent show - No... I think VOI judges beat anyone and everyone at horrendous judging and I feel they are set to hold the record for a long time to come...

😆

Yeah I was reallyy exicted when i heard vishal and shekhar were going to judge...

but not so much shekhar..
i think Vishal over does it..

Actually, I could not stand Farah Khan on Indian Idol, but thought Vishal-Shekhar might be able to compensate for her absolutely terrible judging. But sadly, all three are such complete let-downs, that I completely agree that they are probably the worst of the singing reality show judges to date. In fact, after last weekend's Himani fiasco, I have even stopped watching the show. I'll check in every-so-often to see who gets eliminated and who wins, but I cannot bring myself to watch anymore since I cannot stand Farah Khan. If I had to hear her stupid "UM" once more, I'd probably break the TV.

actually I find them quite tolerable. I thought SRGMP and VOI judges were worse or that chick on Indian Idol - Alisha Chinoy. Maybe you all did not watch those shows 😉

Originally posted by: SGMPfan2

actually I find them quite tolerable. I thought SRGMP and VOI judges were worse or that chick on Indian Idol - Alisha Chinoy. Maybe you all did not watch those shows 😉

oo ya actually.... alisha ji was the worst... sorry to say but she actually was.. 😆