molten_lava thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
This topic will only be restricted to Remo, his two chelas- Salman and Puneet and maybe, other choreographers associated with him. In no point of discussion will the celebrities be involved.

So, Is Remo a good judge?
I have been following him from DID times. Honestly, I never never ever found his choreography great or extraordinary. Infact, I didn't even know him before DID. How many movies has he choreographed? I hardly remember them. Infact, all the fame and stature he has now is all because of DID. So why is he considered as the best choreographer in India currently?
Rather, I love Bosco- Ceasar in the same genre of dance. And if I explore out of his genre, we have Saroj Khan, Vaibhavi Merchant, Terrence Lewis, Farah Khan, Ganesh Acharya, Prabhu deva, who are far more better than him.

Now, coming to the case of Salman and Punit.
Salman, the first winner of DID was in his team. According to me, Salman is an absolutely wonderful dancer. I 'had' never seen such a fabulous dancer in India like him, till he appeared in DID. So, was Remo the reason behind the success of Salman or was Salman a self made talent? I prefer the latter answer, because after Salman, Remo hasn't been able to bring out a wonderful dancer.

Next case- Punit.
Now, I might be a little biased in this verdict, but I simply do not like him. Never have I liked his dance. Infact, I was quite shocked when Punit landed up in the finals of DID that year. But actually, that year, Remo had some of the weakest dancers of DID. So nevermind.
However, I find Punit quite creepy, kind of like giving me creepy vibes.😆 And I find his dance equally creepy. At this point I have to admit, when I watched ABCD, Punit's first dance was super creepy. I could feel the hair standing up on my arms in a scary way.😆
But inspite of it, I feel that he may be a good choreographer. Why? Case in point, last season, when he danced along with Shibhani dandekar. I used to absolutely love her dancing and was quite sad when she got out.

So my ultimate question is- Is Remo a fair judge?
No, because I have felt numerous times that he favors Salman and Punit, his Chelas as I like to call them. And this is not just restricted to this season, it has been happening from the time Remo became a judge and goes as back as DID. Infact, I actually feel sorry for the other choreographers who work equally hard and yet, get half of what they deserve.

So do you agree? Is there anything else where you feel Remo is biased to choreographers related to him?



Created

Last reply

Replies

44

Views

4.6k

Users

25

Likes

97

Frequent Posters

molten_lava thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Calling all Drashti fans since you say I have nothing to talk other than Drashti. Now where did you all disappear for discussion when the topic is non Drashti?😆
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
I am a Remo fan. No, he isn't the best choreographer around because he is restricted to just a few dance forms but he is brilliant in those. I found him to be a great judge on DID but in JDJ, specially this season, I very sadly have to agree with him being biased towards his former students.

Off-topic, but I am just so frustrated with JDJ this season. I am not enjoying it at all. I think the only thing which keeps me sticking to it is the fact that I've followed all previous seasons. Oh and maybe KVB and Sid despite them not being the best contestants here, specially Sid.
DianaPrince thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
sometimes he is biased i feel,while giving marks.🤔

but considering that it is a dance show,he is the best judge among the 3. His remarks are always bang on

neha-rockss thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Oh to get comments on the forum

you gotto either PRAISE OR BASH DD 🤓

coming to the topic...
am glad more people are coming out pointing towards Remo's unfair judging . He has been behaving too sore ever since last season .
And all those romantic angle drama just add up to my irk

As a person he seems sweet, as a choreographer ORDINARY(I find Terrance Lewis heaps better) and as a Judge highly disappointing .
Edited by neha-rockss - 12 years ago
molten_lava thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: -BlackBeauty-

I am a Remo fan. No, he isn't the best choreographer around because he is restricted to just a few dance forms but he is brilliant in those. I found him to be a great judge on DID but in JDJ, specially this season, I very sadly have to agree with him being biased towards his former students.


Off-topic, but I am just so frustrated with JDJ this season. I am not enjoying it at all. I think the only thing which keeps me sticking to it is the fact that I've followed all previous seasons. Oh and maybe KVB and Sid despite them not being the best contestants here, specially Sid.


I guess most choreographers are also restricted to their own forms. For example, I cannot imagine Saroj Khan doing Hip hop any time.😆 But from whatever he danced, I didn't find him great. Maybe because he is aged and his movements are restricted now, whereas he might have been flexible in his prime.

And yes, I agree, JDJ simply keeps dropping low every new season. Infact, I only watch the performances and skip the in between parts. Other shows at the same time like DID mums and IDS are more interesting than this.
MsFoodyTwoShoes thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
i have never found remo biased with salman ... one should watch abcd ...were his biasedness went? ... He is also criticizing salman this season alot werevr salman is at fault ... he never did so earlier becoz there was nothing to criticize in previous seasons ...that doesnt makes him biased with him ... wen salman performed better he scored 30 now wen hez not able to give his best he is being scored accordingly ... is remo biased? i dnt think so ! 😊

Hope your topic stays clean ! No comment on punit !
molten_lava thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: LadyDabangg

sometimes he is biased i feel,while giving marks.🤔


but considering that it is a dance show,he is the best judge among the 3. His remarks are always bang on


@ bold: I have to agree completely. Among the lot of Maduri and K-Jo, he is far far better than them. The others simply don't know what to comment. All that they say is - Wow, this was hot performance, this was sensuous, the chemistry was sizzling, blah blah blah and then Madhuri tells- there was something off about this performance which I'm sure Remo will be better able to tell you.😆
PilloWtalk_13 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
i liked him in did..bt in jdj?not at all..he is over-hyped. his attitude shows"oh yeah iam the best"..and his gang also just like him.

i thought this yr they will bring raghav,prince nirav etc. wat a wonderful dancer and choreographer they r..bt no..same salman same puneet ..i prefer to watch DID super mom over this jdj
molten_lava thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: neha-rockss

Oh to get comments on the forum

you gotto either PRAISE OR BASH DD 🤓

coming to the topic...
am glad more people are coming out pointing towards Remo's unfair judging . He has been behaving too sore ever since last season .
And all those romantic angle drama just add up to my irk

As a person he seems sweet, as a choreographer ORDINARY(I find Terrance Leiws heaps better) and as a Judge highly disappointing .


@Bold: Amen to that! Atleast someone echos my thinking. Yes, he is sweet as a person. But I don't find him impressive as a choreographer or a judge.

And that romantic angle seriously irks me. Last season, we had Bharti and they just went OTT with that. Let's just hope this time's crush is restricted to one episode only.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".