Shamak is being unfair and biased

In the finals Shamak point to Prachi and Sandhya

Round 1   ; ; ; 2   ; ; ; 3

Sandya 8   ; ; ;   ; ; ; 10 10

Prachi 9   ; ; ;   ; ; ; 9   ; ; ; 9

Total he gave Sandhya 28 and Prachi 27

Ok so he gave Prachi only 1 point less than Sandhya and in one dance he rated prachi better. Judges scores are 50% of the marks and the rest is public. From his marks is does not look like he thinks prachi is all that bad, so why is he going on every article and saying Prachi will only win for popularity. If he thinks Prachi has no talent he should give her lower marks. From the marks he has given it seems either is fine as the differnce is so tiny between the 2.

Last year Mona got 23 and Shweta 30 from the judges and that is a big difference. That is not the case this year. The cumulative differnce taking all the judges score between Prachi and Sandhya is only 1 point. You all can say Jeetandra is biased, but what does Shamaks and Urmila's scores for Prachi say. They are not telling the junta with their marks that Sandhya is so much better or anything. They are telling that both dancers are at par.

I havent watch it yet but seems like everyone is against prachi

yah!
he was so unfair
and sandhya did not do a good job
praachi and jai were much bettter(100x)better

correction JDJ is unfair n biased,bending the rules for only one contestant n then giving the awrd to her

Originally posted by: vouge

yah!
he was so unfair
and sandhya did not do a good job
praachi and jai were much bettter(100x)better

I agree !!!!!!!

i don't agree with you. shiamak is the best judge and he was not biased. shiamak was right in saying that prachi would win by her popularity. she is a good dancer but as compared to sandhya, she is not the best.sandhya is a better dancer than prachi and as this show is about dancing skills i completely agree with shiamak.

Yes, he was unfair. i also noticed that prachi was soo good then Sandhiya.

Originally posted by: friskysam

correction JDJ is unfair n biased,bending the rules for only one contestant n then giving the awrd to her

u r absolutely right.

He was bit harsh with prachi

Originally posted by: friskysam

correction JDJ is unfair n biased,bending the rules for only one contestant n then giving the awrd to her

they gave the awards to her becuase the janta voted for her !!
so you cant call it unfair !!