Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

2.7k

Users

15

Frequent Posters

honeebee222 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#21
i agree with u, jay, prachi and sandhya are really trying really hard to win, nobody shud go against anybody cuz other ppl mite feel the same way especially prachi, she is very popular
ReemAnshu thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#22
This is to the author fo this topic : Well you feel annoyed that you are reading topics on Prachi's re-entry being unfair and why she should not win. I agree to a certain extent with you.
But do you realise that it is also very annoying for many like me to see her episode after episode knowing that her entry is unfair and if she wins it will be due to bending of the rules.

You expect us to act accordingly so that you are not ANNOYED any further, yes but what about our ANNOYANCE ?? We are also annoyed seeing her prace arround on stage and people talking of her winning when we feel that they have cheated. And believe me that when the contest started I wanted her to Win as she is a sweet girl, bubbly, full of life and genuine and ya, she is from my college too. But I will not want her to win now since in my heart it does not feel right.

So I will request you not to be selfish and think only about yourself, there are many of us who are equally (if not more) annoyed.
InduD thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#23
Angel just ignore the post that bash Prachi. Well, yes, It has not been very fair wildcard but is it Prachi's problem? No, but she would be attacked again and again by others. Attacking someone when that person was not the one who decided on wildcard is fair to them. Then so be it and let them be Fairness lords.

Any topic on Sandhya will turn into Prachi bashing zone. You just have to live with it because others are "expressing their opinion" and not bashing a contestant. So let them just express themselves. 😊

According to me, though the way she came back to the show in a unfair Wildcard round, she is sustaining mainly because of her hardwork and I appreciate that hardwork by her. I dont want to take out my "annoyance" on Sony for not extending wildcard to all participants to others on Prachi. 😉

Just leave it dear. Let them "express" themselves if that makes them happy. 😛

Cheers,
Meena
ReemAnshu thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Je_aime

Angel just ignore the post that bash Prachi. Well, yes, It has not been very fair wildcard but is it Prachi's problem? No, but she would be attacked again and again by others. Attacking someone when that person was not the one who decided on wildcard is fair to them. Then so be it and let them be Fairness lords.

Any topic on Sandhya will turn into Prachi bashing zone. You just have to live with it because others are "expressing their opinion" and not bashing a contestant. So let them just express themselves. 😊

According to me, though the way she came back to the show in a unfair Wildcard round, she is sustaining mainly because of her hardwork and I appreciate that hardwork by her. I dont want to take out my "annoyance" on Sony for not extending wildcard to all participants to others on Prachi. 😉

Just leave it dear. Let them "express" themselves if that makes them happy. 😛

Cheers,
Meena

Meena, well I do not agree when you say that Prachi had no role to play in the WC entry. I agree that it was maybe due to other pressure that she hd to be brought back but ultimately the decision is hers, like it was for Sudha Chandran who openly said that she does not want to comeback. Prachi could have taken that option, no one can force her.

My problem is also that when she was out and to the period when she re-entered, she made the 'right kind of noices' about her elimination and justifying her re-entry. I have read her articles on Midday & Mirror in which she was mentioning that Diwali caused less votes (it was diwali for all) and how hard she has worked etc etc. Which she could have avoided. Coz this made the re-entry look even more unfair. Coz she was hell bent on returning while Sudha was not willing to and the contest was just between these 2.

As I said that she is such a sweet kid and would have just added to her charm if she had refrained. I from being her supporter (still am) do not want her to win.

In football once Maradonna scored a goal in World Cup semi's in which he had used his hands which the crowd saw but not the ref. Argentina won the match and the cup, but people till today only talk about that goal which was cheating (called hand of god). This is one blemish which a legend like Maradonna will have to live with till his end. Similarly Prachi will have to deal with people who question her re-entry till the end of this show.

InduD thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: ReemAnshu

Meena, well I do not agree when you say that Prachi had no role to play in the WC entry. I agree that it was maybe due to other pressure that she hd to be brought back but ultimately the decision is hers, like it was for Sudha Chandran who openly said that she does not want to comeback. Prachi could have taken that option, no one can force her.

My problem is also that when she was out and to the period when she re-entered, she made the 'right kind of noices' about her elimination and justifying her re-entry. I have read her articles on Midday & Mirror in which she was mentioning that Diwali caused less votes (it was diwali for all) and how hard she has worked etc etc. Which she could have avoided. Coz this made the re-entry look even more unfair. Coz she was hell bent on returning while Sudha was not willing to and the contest was just between these 2.

As I said that she is such a sweet kid and would have just added to her charm if she had refrained. I from being her supporter (still am) do not want her to win.

In football once Maradonna scored a goal in World Cup semi's in which he had used his hands which the crowd saw but not the ref. Argentina won the match and the cup, but people till today only talk about that goal which was cheating (called hand of god). This is one blemish which a legend like Maradonna will have to live with till his end. Similarly Prachi will have to deal with people who question her re-entry till the end of this show. True, alot cant seem to look one single black point in the paper.

Sorry but correct me if I am wrong. Didn't Sony asked to vote for Sudhaji in wildcard round as well. If Sudhaji really rejected the offer how come she did not come up to the media and tell the viewers to not vote for her as she is not contesting. What Sudhaji said in the interview was her opinion BUT she was still NOMIATED for wildcard, there were ppl who voted for her that includes some of my friends in India. So, ppl I think ppl should stop assuming that Sudhaji said no the wildcard.

Well, just a small qtn. If judges favour Sandhya and show partiality to her, will you blame the judges or Sandhya?

I dont know dear. I dont want to impose my opinion on others. I just said my opinion. I do not want to blame her as she was not the one who decided on wildcard. As simple as that.

Further more, her hardwork is clearly showing. If ppl want to keep on still talking about wildcard and ignore a person's talent and hardwork, its their call. I cant do anything about it.

Edited by Je_aime - 17 years ago
ReemAnshu thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#26
Meena, I agree that Sony did nominate Sudha, but in all her TV and orint interviews, she always said that she does not want to come back. I am sure she would be bound by contract and so technically can be nominated. But if the person himself says that they do not wanna come back, then are people mad to vote for her ?? Thats why Prachi re-entry is even more fishy coz they had a poll between only 2 people and the other person was not all interested in coming back and was openly saying so. So it was a one horse race all along.
I agree that she dances well, is a nice girl but she will have to live with this till the show ends and it will always be the talking point.
And as far as your hypothetical remark that if judges were partial towards Sandhya, would I blame her. Well certainly not but if she danced badly and then claimed that she dances better than others, I would have surely hated her. And judges favouring someone is not technically against the rule as they are not the deciding factor and they can favour someone if they like him/her, right now the judges are partial towards NEGI, who cant dance but gets high marks. I will not blame that on him. But if he was bribing, threatening or using external pressure on the judges to get good scores then yes, he would be cheating.
MAybe Prachi was not instrumental in bending the rules but she surely seemed to be justifying the bending of the rules in her favour by giving some other stupid reasons for her elimination like it being Diwali Night !
brown3y3db3auti thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#27
yes it is geting really annoyng and please stop making posts of prachi being childesh or irritating. 😳
InduD thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: ReemAnshu

Meena, I agree that Sony did nominate Sudha, but in all her TV and orint interviews, she always said that she does not want to come back. I am sure she would be bound by contract and so technically can be nominated. But if the person himself says that they do not wanna come back, then are people mad to vote for her ?? Thats why Prachi re-entry is even more fishy coz they had a poll between only 2 people and the other person was not all interested in coming back and was openly saying so. So it was a one horse race all along.
I agree that she dances well, is a nice girl but she will have to live with this till the show ends and it will always be the talking point.
And as far as your hypothetical remark that if judges were partial towards Sandhya, would I blame her. Well certainly not but if she danced badly and then claimed that she dances better than others, I would have surely hated her. And judges favouring someone is not technically against the rule as they are not the deciding factor and they can favour someone if they like him/her, right now the judges are partial towards NEGI, who cant dance but gets high marks. I will not blame that on him. But if he was bribing, threatening or using external pressure on the judges to get good scores then yes, he would be cheating.
MAybe Prachi was not instrumental in bending the rules but she surely seemed to be justifying the bending of the rules in her favour by giving some other stupid reasons for her elimination like it being Diwali Night !

Sony had already reasoned why they chose only Prachi and Sudha for wildcard. I assume that Sony would have given the same reasons to Prachi as well, then i dont see any reasons for her to reject the offer. Sony already said that they chose wildcard contestants depending on the ranking of judges and previous voting and did not want to extend to all as it might be difficult to get everyone to rearrange their schedule.

Anyways, the excuse of Diwali night was given by Mona on the episode and then articles carried out the same. If I remember correctly, Prachi said that Power voting was one of the reasons for her elimination. She did not talk about Diwali night at all. And truely, power voting was the reason. Sony even took measures to tackle that issue and made that only 10 votes can be sent from one SIM card.

I dont think Prachi used Ekta. Ekta likes her and even on the elimination day itself, if you see the video, Jeetu was already angry and threw the card on the table. I dont think she specifically went and asked ekta or public to support her. It was public and ekta supporting her willingly. Anyways, i believe that BBC and sony changed the format only because it had lost two deserving ppl and a lot of general public sending them emails that includes me. Also check out the JDJ official website's message to see how many ppl demanded for a wildcard reentry of Prachi. If ppl by themselves support her, then I dont see it as her fault. It is just like if judges liked Negi and gave him full points, Negi cant do anything about it. But nobody blames Negi, everyone blames Judges but in Prachi's case, it is exactly opposite.

About Sudhaji, she said that she does not want to be involved in the voting game because the official announcement of wildcard came. AFTER the offical announcement came, she said nothing about it. so again i would not want to assume.

I dont really see how it is a big issue, if one wants to accept a second chance given, lets not forget that Sony did reason why they chose only two contestants.

Well, that is my view.

Edited by Je_aime - 17 years ago
angelrockz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: ReemAnshu

This is to the author fo this topic : Well you feel annoyed that you are reading topics on Prachi's re-entry being unfair and why she should not win. I agree to a certain extent with you.
But do you realise that it is also very annoying for many like me to see her episode after episode knowing that her entry is unfair and if she wins it will be due to bending of the rules.

You expect us to act accordingly so that you are not ANNOYED any further, yes but what about our ANNOYANCE ?? We are also annoyed seeing her prace arround on stage and people talking of her winning when we feel that they have cheated. And believe me that when the contest started I wanted her to Win as she is a sweet girl, bubbly, full of life and genuine and ya, she is from my college too. But I will not want her to win now since in my heart it does not feel right.

So I will request you not to be selfish and think only about yourself, there are many of us who are equally (if not more) annoyed.

Can i ask you when i was being selfish i was not saying anything her for just myself i am sure there are loads of other Prachi fans who feel the same !!
I was making a request !!!!

Sorry if i said anything wrong 😳

Angelrockz

Mistyy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: ReemAnshu

Meena, I agree that Sony did nominate Sudha, but in all her TV and orint interviews, she always said that she does not want to come back. I am sure she would be bound by contract and so technically can be nominated. But if the person himself says that they do not wanna come back, then are people mad to vote for her ?? Thats why Prachi re-entry is even more fishy coz they had a poll between only 2 people and the other person was not all interested in coming back and was openly saying so. So it was a one horse race all along.
I agree that she dances well, is a nice girl but she will have to live with this till the show ends and it will always be the talking point.
And as far as your hypothetical remark that if judges were partial towards Sandhya, would I blame her. Well certainly not but if she danced badly and then claimed that she dances better than others, I would have surely hated her. And judges favouring someone is not technically against the rule as they are not the deciding factor and they can favour someone if they like him/her, right now the judges are partial towards NEGI, who cant dance but gets high marks. I will not blame that on him. But if he was bribing, threatening or using external pressure on the judges to get good scores then yes, he would be cheating.
MAybe Prachi was not instrumental in bending the rules but she surely seemed to be justifying the bending of the rules in her favour by giving some other stupid reasons for her elimination like it being Diwali Night !

only one thing 👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".