Was Shiamak Unfair With Jay ?? - Page 2

Originally posted by: atria

Well he gave less marks to everyone, the highest he gave was a 7 I think, so I don't think he was specifically unfair to Jay. Jay messed up the footwork, which is the main thing in salsa. So in comparison with the others, his marks were okay. 😊

I m not saying Jay deserved 7 or 8...but I m just confused that how can Shiamak give same marks to both Mika and Jay when Jay was much better than Mika at least😕😕

Originally posted by: Sharmii

But I agree.....You need to watch it technically... 😉

So maybe shamak ji has a scoreboard in his hand!!
😆

1 point for footspes..
1 point for flexibility..
1 point for timing...
and so so.. 😆

Sharmi but does Shiamak believe that technically Jay ,Mika and Aadesh were of the same level😕😕..because all got 5...And I strongly believe that even technically Jay was better than Mika and Aadesh at least😕...and u r right Dunno how can a contestent get 10 marks from Shiamak😕😕..Mayb to get 10marks from Shiamak ,one needs to hire Michael Jackson's aatma for one day😉😆😆

Originally posted by: luv_eijaz_anita

I agree with you...
Shaimak was a little harsh on Jay..
Becuase he gave Mika and Jay the same marks....And i actually think that Jay did a better then him..😳
But..maybe on the upcoming performances he'll give better marks to Jay cuase he'll start improving..😳

Mayb Shiamak expected more from Jay sinse he has got a young blood😛

Originally posted by: ploye

Really, that guy is a real kanjoooos! I'm sure no one will get more than 9 from him! He is quite harsh though, on giving points! 😆

😳 Komal

Komal 9 toh bahut door ki baat hai😆..he is not ready to go beyond 7 also😕..but the fact that Shiamak gave same marks to both Mika and Jay is hurting me a bit...I think Jay was much better than Mika😕...Mika kept jumping like a monkey throughout the stage and still he got 5 points😕 whereas Jai at least tried to do some good salsa steps and still he got 5 for his efforts

Is Jay that Chocolate Liqueur boy?? I did not like his performance all that much. By himself, it was good, by herself (choreographer) it was good, but together, they dont seem to have clicked. Just my pov. there was something lacking in their performance...

I am waiting for the videos to be up, so haven't yet seen the performances for men. I do, however, like that Shiamak and Urmila are not overly generous with scores. I hate it in NB that judges are quick to give a 10. A 10 should be given only if the judges are blown away by the performances. And the first few episodes are for people to develop themselves, so a low score is justified. If Shiamak does give a or a 10, we will know for sure that the person does deserve to win because of the outstanding dance.

Originally posted by: greatmaratha

Is Jay that Chocolate Liqueur boy?? I did not like his performance all that much. By himself, it was good, by herself (choreographer) it was good, but together, they dont seem to have clicked. Just my pov. there was something lacking in their performance...

Yes Priyadi ,I know that Jay's choreographer was better than Jay and that was the main problem and therefore together it didn't clicked...but what is hurting me is how can Jay get the same points as Mika and Aadesh got from Shiamak😕...when Jay's performance was at least better than Mika and Aadesh😕

Originally posted by: Nach_Baliye

I am waiting for the videos to be up, so haven't yet seen the performances for men. I do, however, like that Shiamak and Urmila are not overly generous with scores. I hate it in NB that judges are quick to give a 10. A 10 should be given only if the judges are blown away by the performances. And the first few episodes are for people to develop themselves, so a low score is justified. If Shiamak does give a or a 10, we will know for sure that the person does deserve to win because of the outstanding dance.

Yes u r right its good to start strictly from the beginning itself,so that the contestents don't take things for granted and become over-confident😛..now we will hv to wait and watch who gets the first 10 from Shiamak😛

I too think he was a bit unfair to jay..Actually all the judges were really unfair.. they praised the participants but while giving points they were super kanjoos..
Shamak was stuck with 5/6 most of the time 😕

but it was just the beginning... the participants are yet to improve..

On low scores, while initially I also thought they were being super kanjoos with the scores, I read a post by another member, making a very valid point - that one should keep a 10 for a super duper performance and this was after all the first episode.. this is certainly not their best, so a higher score than 7 or 8 may not be justified.

But yeah this guy definitely deserved more than Mika. For that matter, even Cyrus deserved more. With all his antics, he still danced... unlike Mika who merely tried to dance.