It has happened many times in the past...

That's the way cookie crumbles ...the good comes with the bad....if one is willing to take the good...they should be willing to take on the bad just as enthusiastically ..

Originally posted by: denver_diva

i am glad thatatleast one person agrees...and u r so correct "hope4u" when u say that the judges themselves are responsible for Hard Kaur's ouster.

I like Baichung as a footballer and also as a person (what he comes across as on the show)...and i personally want him to win...but at the same time I feel that sometimes the judges mark Sonia alone for the performance...or Baichung wouldn't having been scoring higher than anybody on the show except the magician guy.

Like me...the judges have their favorites too...so why r they kicking up a fuss when the junta has their favorite too???

Originally posted by: denver_diva

On Reality Shows, it has often happened, that a contestant who is liked by a majority of audience gets harsh treatment from the judges.The judges are frustrated with the audience who doesn't agree with their judgment and saves their favorite week after week....and the frustration is vented out at the contestant.
Why don't our dear respectable judges understand that there is nothing in that contestant's hands...he/she is there because he/she cannot walk out on his own...going by the rules, he/she deserves to be there.

In Jhalak too Karan is facing a similar situation.The judges should learn to accect the junta's verdict...if they can't then they shudn't be be a part of the show.I feel it is extremely demoralizing for Karan.The judges are indirectly hitting on him week over week.

It is not Karan's fault that he is popular...and it isn't his fault if Gauhar or Hard Kaur or whoever else dance better than him.He is doing his job...he is dancing ...n that's it.The rest is upto the judges and junta...so he shudn't be rediculed for it.

Every judge has a differet style of judging...sometimes some have no idea about dance (like juhi) and make weird remarks and contradict themselves...(like juhi did in the circus round where she told parul that in at this stage in competition in terms of difficulty, other's did more diff stuff than her ...so her marks wud be less...and in the same show she told baichung that he shud not take the risk of doing something difficult at this stage in competition.Even Juhi should be rediculed for not being as competent as the other judges on the show...like Karan is being rediculed for not being as competent as the other contestants.

(I am not a Karan fan, I am rooting for Baichung)

Just my 2 cents

Originally posted by: hope4u

exactly.. the for and against people might say anything..but if ur neutral enough, u will recognize that the judging has been inconsistent.. these people, being choreographers tend to concentrate on the choreography.. hence, baichung has been scoring heavily, solely based on the fact that he has a brilliant choreographer..
i love baichung as a person too.. he is so real, and unassuming, u gotta love him..

but honestly, if u see the finale, none of the finalists really deserve to win in the true sense of the word..
as a dancer, i honestly feel karan is better in all departments than baichung..
however if u see as a team, nicole is seriously lacking behind sonia.. but the million dollar question is, how much importance is to be attached to how well the choreographer gets the dance. is it not necessary to see how the actual celebrity is as a dancer, leaving his choreographer's skills aside? this is not nach baliye, where both the partners are judged together.. this is dancing with the stars.. so marking a star, on the basis of his choreographer's skills is ridiculous.. strangely, the only person recognizing and accepting this glaring fact is baichung..and bless him for that![/QUOTE]

Yeah..I agree to that..He himself knows that he is over rated and he is accepting it without any reluctance..Thats where I like him. As a matter of fact,the remaining contestants are not really worthy to have that title, so I prefer Baichung out of it. Not neglecting the fact that everybody is working towards it very hard. Now I feel there is no point going behind best dancers. Just thinking how hurt HK would have been after getting eliminated. 😭

Originally posted by: cool_yv

That means to defend your favourites you'll bash judges???

Girl get you concepts straight before making such a strong post!:-(

Originally posted by: denver_diva

.

.

Every judge has a differet style of judging...sometimes some have no idea about dance (like juhi) and make weird remarks and contradict themselves...(like juhi did in the circus round where she told parul that in at this stage in competition in terms of difficulty, other's did more diff stuff than her ...so her marks wud be less...and in the same show she told baichung that he shud not take the risk of doing something difficult at this stage in competition.Even Juhi should be rediculed for not being as competent as the other judges on the show...like Karan is being rediculed for not being as competent as the other contestants.

(I am not a Karan fan, I am rooting for Baichung)

Just my 2 cents