I'm shocked.... - Page 3

Originally posted by: tulipbaby53

yeah, i felt that hard kaur should have been in the finals...especially over karan, but i still felt bad for the way he was treated. i mean, he already knew from his scores the past few weeks that he didn't get there b/c of his dance, so the judges should not be saying things like that. i thought it was unprofessional. it's okay if we as audience members say things like that or even if contestants jokingly say things like that, but judges have to fair because it's not really karan's fault if the audience votes for him so much....it's just his luck. i do feel that he doesn't truly deserve to be in the finals though.

Originally posted by: AngelTeen

He might not deserve to be in the finals but the guy has to be appreciated for the fact that he keeps his emotions in check.

The judges and fellow contestants say so much about him but he has never opened his mouth and I respect him for this.

And thirdly the judges too should be more objective....vaibhavi and saroj khan have judeged so many reality shows and they know how things work there so why complain now?

I agree...d judges as well as we viewers know very well how this reality shows work....moreover I really admire Karan as a person he is so above all this negativity on d show...even when people make comments on him he sportingly takes all of it....

Originally posted by: munumoni

I agree...d judges as well as we viewers know very well how this reality shows work....moreover I really admire Karan as a person he is so above all this negativity on d show...even when people make comments on him he sportingly takes all of it....

Originally posted by: sunandshine

Well, they say that in each reality show. It happened during Indian Idol 3 as well, when all talented people got eliminated and prashant ultimately won due to regional votes. The judges unanimously felt that Amit paul deserved to win. Even in this years Idol, the little kid Remo was in competition due to regional votes. the judges each time said that 'vote for the talent'blah blah...When was the last time a talented person won any reality show?

Just coz its Karan doesn't mean that the others whom I cited above did not feel bad..although, I agree that its not Karan';s fault but he has to take it with a pinch of salt.

I don't get why people are being so unfair to karan...

Originally posted by: nureat01

I had no room in my heart to feel bad for a guy who didn't deserve to be in the show when such a talented performer....the person who TRULY deserved to win this show was being eliminated.<br>

if u were participating in a contest. and before participating, you knew that there is a chance that popularity will overpower talent. u know ur more talented but there r people who r more popular than u. still u decide to join, hoping people wil lrecognize ur talent. it doesnt happen.. ur disappointed.. but can u blame anybody? knowing that the facts were before u?

conversely, the popular contestant is still in, inspite of not being the best.. he has also joined knowing all the rules, and played by it. why should he be insulted just because of it? if the show is so keen on keeping only the best contestants, they shoul've rigged the results accordingly.. thrown him out in the last elimination.nobody is gonna know the difference. u dont do that, but u insult the said person?

i can completely understand the frustration of hard kaur being out.. but blaming that on karan, and being hard hearted enough to feel he deserves humiliation is something i really cant fathom.

Originally posted by: hope4u

conversely, the popular contestant is still in, inspite of not being the best.. he has also joined knowing all the rules, and played by it. why should he be insulted just because of it? if the show is so keen on keeping only the best contestants, they shoul've rigged the results accordingly.. thrown him out in the last elimination.nobody is gonna know the difference. u dont do that, but u insult the said person?

i can completely understand the frustration of hard kaur being out.. but blaming that on karan, and being hard hearted enough to feel he deserves humiliation is something i really cant fathom.

👏
I cannot fathom either!

yeah, i agree! you can't say that he deserves to be humilated, but i don't think nureat01 was trying to say that.