Riddikulus thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
Hey guys...!! 😃
Tonight, in my opinion, was one of the best episodes of Jhalak this season, complete with powerhouse performances, some serious hard work and soul, some stunning visuals, and a very complete, wholesome package of entertainment...so i just thought i'd share my thoughts about each of the five performances...do feel free to post in with your own too...😊
Gauhar and Himanshu : She looked every bit the "Kaanch Ki Gudiya" described in her song, and played every bit of the part to perfection with apt body language and expressions...the choreography was fabulous...although i personally felt the use of the ball was a little let's-fill-something-in-here type...and i was quite excited to watch them use the trampoline, but they used that only at the very end of the routine...and it sort of threw them off balance too, but it's a trampoline, and doing lifts on one ain't a piece of cake...so overall, very good use of props, good choreography and perfect expressions, although i was personally left asking for more...but that could be my expectations doing the talking...she can do better though...😊
Judges' Assessment : SK9 JC9 VM10
My Take : They were good, but have potential to do better...i'd give them a 9...😊
Parul and Deepak : The clown bit was perfect...the attitude, the body language, the expressions and all intact...what i personally felt should not have been so literally in-the-same-vein were the steps which i found a tad basic and simpler than usual...but i guess they did that on purpose, keeping the theme of a Circus in mind...so won't hold it against them...but still, again, left me asking for more coz Deepak's a fab choreo and Parul can also dance quite well...the treadmill felt a little out of place in a Circus act, but it was unusual and they used it pretty well...
Judges' Assessment : SK9 JC8 VM9
My Take : Agree with the overall score...would've done better if they used a wee bit more complicated steps or a lift here and there...I'd give them an 8.5...😛
Karan and Nicole : WHOA...dude, like Vaibhavi said, where the hell were you this long...?!! i mean, i always thought he had potential, but he crossed any level i could ever have considered for him, looking at his past record with dancing strictly, on either of his shows...well, he danced today...and HOW...i really thought theirs was a very complete and wholesome performance...loved the costumes, excellent choreography, good use of another very unusual prop, and this time, there was dancing too, good and proper...and they both pulled it off so effortlessly it was quite startling, really...tw...full points to Nicole for making him do this, and full points to him for doing it so darn well...!! i really can't think of anything to say except that he need not have missed a 30 for this one...and this is from a purely neutral point of view...
Judges' Assessment : SK10 JC9 VM10
My Take : Didn't get what Juhi cut a mark for...and she didn't explain either...but for me, this was one performance that was really worth a 30...so i'd give it a 10 without hesitating a tiny little jot...👍🏼
Hard Kaur and Savio : WooooHooo...!! it was a Circus incarnate, and what a circus it was...even theirs was a very complete performance, true to the theme, and yet not compromising on the dancing or lifts...and for the most part it was most thoroughly entertaining...be it the little pranks on the judges in the beginning, or HK being suspended from Savio's tie while he twirled her around...the expressions were perfect, the lifts were good, the use of props was amazing...again, not much to say, coz it was just so totally cool...!!
Judges' Assessment : SK10 JC10 VM10
My Take : Agree...totally deserved a perfect score...so 10 from my side too...⭐️
Baichung and Sonia : Hmm...well, it was a BIG risk...and it cost them a bit too...it was visually quite appealing...and graceful too...but personally, i felt that most of their performance was spent in holding postures rather than doing steps...but then the rings they used could probably have allowed them just about that much without risking falling off entirely if they got too ambitious with the choreography...i do still feel that some of the poses lasted too long, like the first two chants of "Soniyo..." had them simply sitting with thier legs stretched out...it sort of ate into most of their stage time...their performance was shorter than others as it is...it wasn't bad at all though...just felt a little incomplete, and not so well executed...😳
Judges' Assessment : SK9 JC8 VM8
My Take : Agree with the overall score...I'd give them a 7.5...😊
So there it is...do post in your thoughts...feel free to disagree...although i'd request everyone to keep it clean...try and keep it objective, and please don't get personal about any contestant/choreographer/judge/host/fellow member...let's try and keep this healthy guys...
cheers! 😃
Edited by nandinidev - 16 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

1.8k

Users

13

Likes

6

Frequent Posters

islandgirl007 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
Wow awesome analysis..

I just wish Juhi dint spoil it today..I seriously do...When judges make their judgement they need to realise they r making or breaking the result of the performer in addition to the voting from the audience..
she shud have been more responsible...

she gave everyone less marks than saroj..though i feel saroj is very biased ( personal opinion) i am sure juhi does not know more than the judges about dancing..i dont see why she gave less..and if she gave less based on how she felt and not how they performed then that is not good judgement..!!!!
352869 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
ur view is compltly lperrfect but my view r lik
Gauhar: pretty gud agreed wid her marks
Parul: she culd hav done better as she is jus osm but overall 4 me 2 she desrved 27
Karan: full on 30 no need 4 xplanation
Baichung: osm choreography de deserved 27!
HardKaur: ma comment wil lead 2 bashin so no comments
Edited by komal_4_u - 16 years ago
kash4life thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
awesomme anaylysis but ( juhi lost her mind chawla) had to go stop a truely amazxing day to become a great day
BUT KARAN
I MEAN WOW
enjoyed his performance by a mile the most
fantastic
ShelDev thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
Oh God Juhi again!...
I really don't understand her sense of judging. What did she cut 1mark from Karan's performance?? If the other two notable judges gave a 10, why did she give a 9?
From the analysis above, it sure looks like Karan & Nicole's performance was perfect....
Anyways, since JDJ has been on I have never really agreed to Juhi's judging. (that's my POV)....(PS I am not bashing her)..
Thanks for the analysis....
Riddikulus thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: hamsee_18

Wow awesome analysis..

I just wish Juhi dint spoil it today..I seriously do...When judges make their judgement they need to realise they r making or breaking the result of the performer in addition to the voting from the audience..
she shud have been more responsible...

she gave everyone less marks than saroj..though i feel saroj is very biased ( personal opinion) i am sure juhi does not know more than the judges about dancing..i dont see why she gave less..and if she gave less based on how she felt and not how they performed then that is not good judgement..!!!!

hey...thanks! 😳
and about Juhi...you know, i'd also have a lot less issues with her judging if she would just specify the reason behind cutting off the marks she does each time...she does clarify in some instances, but if you notice, there are many instances where she doesn't even mention what she found flawed enough to wipe off a mark...like in Karan's performance tonight...she cut off a mark, but never once mentioned what she cut it for...or even Parul's Aao Na routine...she gave wonderful comments, but never mentioned why she gave a 9 and not a 10 if it was so perfect...criticism is meant to be for the contestants' benefit too, so why not give it out clearly if you're the judge...?? 😕
that's just how i honestly feel...no offense meant to anyone...😊
cheers! 😃
Riddikulus thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: kash4life

awesomme anaylysis but ( juhi lost her mind chawla) lol...😆 had to go stop a truely amazxing day to become a great day

BUT KARAN
I MEAN WOW completely agree on that one...that was my first reaction when his routine ended...and i LOVED Rohit's reaction too..."aur kuch log kehte hain ki Karan ko Dance karna nahin aata...!!" 😎 and the hug he gave him after that...sort of redeemed him in my eyes after the May 2nd fiasco...just goes to show, also, that he probably said exactly what the creatives told him to say at the time, while tonight seemed pretty much impromptu...😊
enjoyed his performance by a mile the most
fantastic

-Veena- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
Nandu.... awesomeee post hun!!! jappies..!!
Haven't watched the show but defo will comment after i do!!!
Riddikulus thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
heyy Veenz...will wait for your two cents...!! 😎
oh, and by the way, LOVE your avi...!! 😍
cheers! 😃
-Blahdah thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
Awesome Analysis Nandi.
Ditto on Karan's one & Gauhar's one.
Well, i dont have tht much time to give a long analysis myself, so i would make it short.
Gauhar: Ditto you! 9 from me too and it was a brilliant performance. I loved the Cart-Wheel ones the most!
Parul: Her act was really cute! Enjoyed it alot. 8 from me.
Karan: The first word after his performance, i uttered, was WOW! And thn i had no words to praise it. 10 from me.
Baichung: Ermm, dint like it much...The risk taken was a HUGE one but whn i felt myself getting into it, it ended and it dint had much of Power, you say! 7 from me.
Hard Kaur: The circus and all was great but...I better not say anything. Am sorry! Since, tht JDJ is a dance show, i give her a 8.
Overall, a rocking episode!
Though i was majorly dissapointed after Karan got his mark. What did Juhi not give a 10 for? *controling* It deserved a full-on, without any doubt 30!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".