Fraud on Jhalak?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Aishwarya

@pakhara

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: -Chandramukhi-
I think I would give them a benefit of doubt, I mean even with that kinda space in the wall, it would be difficult for them to see each other. Yes they might see through the periphery only in that portion, but they were moving constantly from one end to other. So there was very limited time for them to cheat. And end of the day, for any performance be it with the wall or without, one needs to know the steps, if they forget even a step, it would be very obvious. So I think they did a very good job. Not the best, but still very satisfactory 😃

P.S: It is very refreshing to see a fan criticizing her own favorite.

Well yes, but it was such a blatant deception (wow, that's an oxymoron, but yeah). And the judges pretended that they didn't see it either. I mean, they're not blind! It doesn't really bother me how well they performed, but the fact that they did this sort of gimmick.

And of course. Thank you! I'm not a blind follower or anything, but I do admire them.

Quote

3283

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: RadhaHiBawari

Well yes, but it was such a blatant deception (wow, that's an oxymoron, but yeah). And the judges pretended that they didn't see it either. I mean, they're not blind! It doesn't really bother me how well they performed, but the fact that they did this sort of gimmick.

And of course. Thank you! I'm not a blind follower or anything, but I do admire them.

I agree, nobody spoke of that space. But then we don't know what their intention was. While they were performing, I did realize that there was some sorta gap since they were exchanging their sections. So overall, I don't know if the judges let it go cuz it was part of the act, or Punit created such choreography to have that kinda space 😕

And I agree with the choreography, it wasn't mind blowing to get a 30. And theatrical hip hop, that just cracked me up 😆

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Rapier

@Rapier

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#13

Sorry, but I couldn't understand what you were referring to. Are you referring to the doorway? Or are you suggesting that the actual wall was transparent?

I don't think the wall was transparent. But yes, there was a doorway. That doorway was used to exchange the characters from one section to the other. But I don't think there is room for much cheating here cuz I felt that they had come up front whenever they were dancing and they danced with the actual wall part in the middle, not the doorway. But of course, I couldn't be sure. I just felt that that was their positioning. Unless the actual wall was transparent or it allowed one to see the shadow of the other through the wall, I think it wasn't fraud. If you can see through the actual wall, then we have a huge problem!

Quote

NoComments

@NoComments

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

#14

Wow - thats a good catch... Surprised that none of judges had a word about it...

Shibani is a very good dancer - but her act yesterday could have been so much better.. She has done so much better before..

About the passage to exchange the characters - I always thought yesterday that the gap existed in the far end of the wall and they always came to the front and danced - so it was OK.. But if the gap was right in the middle, then what was it about the challenge - I so much wonder!

And again - very good to see that supporters can also be so objective and critical - Great!

Quote

Khushi Ghai

@Khushi.

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#15

Firstly , you earned a lot of respect from my side for actually starting a topic questioning an act of the jodi you are favouring this season. It takes alot of guts to do this as here almost everyone forget about right and wrong and just blindly favours there favourites. So Kudos!👏

Secondly, Yes! i feel that the judges should have pointed this out and this whole thing should have been clarified. What is unfair is unfair! I loved there performance alot but it didnt satisy the challenge given to them.

Quote

433796

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#16

Best part is these are the channels(almot all) who supported Anna agitation against corruption but they themselves are corrupt. I dont blame judges, they are being directed. They say show live, but they even edit mistakes of contestants according to their choice. Channel is there to make money, judges are part of it otherwise how will they be paid. If a judge shows honesty, that will be his/her last season on the show. So, jo mil raha dekho, warna switch off kar do. Anyway India is among most corrupt country. And this title a country get after hard work of its citizens.

Quote

JaZzs

@JaZzs

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#17

yeah i noticed it too ... from the expressions of remo i thought he will point it out n say they havent did their challenge perfectly but nothing ...they got accolades and 30 😕

Quote

SudhaSangeet

@SudhaSangeet

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#18

I knew it...

It was obvious when shibani and punit crossed each other from door...

And I dont think anybody must have come in the middle of performance to close the door...😆

Remo should have pointed it out...😕

Quote

BIackSwan

@BIackSwan

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#19

I bunked Saturday's episode but I must say you are one honest and spunky girl. Take a bow my friend!!

Now why do I say that?

You are one of the very few fans who has guts and audacity to point out a mistake or rather a negative point of your fav contestants out in the public. I don't see this more often so I really respect you for that

Darn it... Why couldn't the judges point it out? I have no faith in others but Remo??! I mean seriously?!?!?

Not only this act but with regard to the challenges, I'm miffed with them for giving teen ka tadka and that too with two dancers for Salman & Isha and Savio & Bharti. These two jodis should have been given proper, touch challenges. Teen ka tadka is not a broad challenge compared to what others were given especially Shampa & GC and Darsheel. I'm really disappointed

@Dabulls

Totally agree with you on this 30/30 business. Judges are just giving away marks so easily without judging the act

Quote

246851

Hibernated

Posted: 13 years ago

#20

is it reflected wall or doorway? i think its a doorway. the whole idea of both of them going over to each other's sides looks a bit suspicious. But most of the time they were dancing facing the front, so i donno if shibani could steal a glimpse or not. However the climbing and exchanging sides looked like tricks by punit to make it easier.

Also the dance was just normal hip hop, at the most lyrical hip hop what was the theatrical part of it, didn't get it. and yes perfect score looked a bit too much. 27/28 would have been fine.

Quote

1 2 3 4

Fraud on Jhalak? - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics