Why

Lubabah Rahman

@ChurriBurri

Rocker

25

Posted: 9 years ago

#1

First of all...what da hell is wrong with Shabnam?? She seriously burns SidNi's pictures. Poor Roshni!! I mean those pictures were all she really had of Sid. And here there is Raghu...looks like Sid, yet says he is not Sid. Her mom is in jail for a crime she did not commit, her Nani is paralyzed and her sasural is no where to be found. Shabnam knows Sid is out there, she really thinks that she will get away with all the harm she is doing?? Sid is alive. Not sure if he had ML or is faking it.

That is so confusing to me still...I think I have to either re watch the episode or wait for more episodes. But at one point in the dance he did do a small salute, which Sid does. What did you guys think from today's episode?? And why??

Help me figure out...

8

Reply

Quote

Ridhi20

@Ridhi20

Inactive

22

Posted: 9 years ago

#2

I think he is suffering memory loss only ! D way he is behaving doesn't look like a plan !

1

Reply

Quote

afghangirl

@afghangirl

Rocker

25

Posted: 9 years ago

#3

I still dont believe in ML. The story wont move. Raghu has blue eyes, Sid hasnt. I think he is faking his memory loss and the story reminds me of SRKs movie Baaziger. if Sid has ML, why on earth would he wear lenses?

1

Reply

Quote

Lubabah Rahman

@ChurriBurri

Rocker

25

Posted: 9 years ago

#4

I too want to believe that he is faking it all...I'm dying to find out. I'm sure if he is faking his ML then he will come to a breaking point. Roshni will try to keep meeting him, a point might come where he misbehaves with her, to keep her away. Which would leave her crying...he might after wards cry as well...we all know Sid does not like seeing tears in Roshni's eyes...he even did the salute during his performance...

1

Reply

Quote

afghangirl

@afghangirl

Rocker

25

Posted: 9 years ago

#5

Originally posted by: Churri
I too want to believe that he is faking it all...I'm dying to find out. I'm sure if he is faking his ML then he will come to a breaking point. Roshni will try to keep meeting him, a point might come where he misbehaves with her, to keep her away. Which would leave her crying...he might after wards cry as well...we all know Sid does not like seeing tears in Roshni's eyes...he even did the salute during his performance...

Agree.if he has ML why would he change himself so much?

I just remembered an old serial which had a similiar track.the lead fake to be someone else as he was framed for a murder he didn't commit.He found about the real killer and his name was cleared.

For me JR without Sid is not possible.If CVS planned something like that I 'll quit watching cause story with new character even if its the same actor spoils the whole story. Happened to many sucessful serials.

1

Reply

Quote

Stephanie

@stephie34

Rocker

25

Posted: 9 years ago

#6

I believe it's a memory loss ...it doesn't make any sense what so ever for him to stay away for Six month when he know he was the only one to get DD out of jail and he could have won over Shabnam now that everyone knew the truth so I.don't see any need for a plan for him to fake his idnetity

Reply

Quote

afghangirl

@afghangirl

Rocker

25

Posted: 9 years ago

#7

Originally posted by: stephie34
I believe it's a memory loss ...it doesn't make any sense what so ever for him to stay away for Six month when he know he was the only one to get DD out of jail and he could have won over Shabnam now that everyone knew the truth so I.don't see any need for a plan for him to fake his idnetity

I get your point.even I am confused. But I don't understand if he got conscious and suffered memory loss,how can change so much?Sid was fair and he didn't have blue eyes plus he turned mechanic from a business man.My point is Raghu is a complete other character than Sid.Only his affection for Roshni is the same.

Somehow and somewhere he should resemble Sid.I don't know about people who suffer memory loss are changing completly. Here it looks in some scenes as he is indeed Sids look alike.

Edited by afghangirl - 9 years ago

1

Reply

Quote

Gingerly

@Gingerly

Dazzler

23

Posted: 9 years ago

#8

I don't think he has memory loss. Sid had told Roshni that it's going to be a long fight and then something about even if he has to loose himself, can't remember the entire conversation. Granted it has been 6 months that he has stayed away from his family but I think it was necessary for him to do it. He couldn't have come back as Sid because in the eyes of the public and media he's guilty of something he didn't do. So he stayed away to work on a new strategy, which involves him loosing himself as Sid, letting his identity as Sid die and forming an entirely new identity for himself only for the sole purpose of clearing Sid's name and defeating Shabby. He couldn't have fought Shabby as Sid because she is to slithery like a snake and cunning as a fox but he'll fight her as Raghu and she will be the none wiser, just my opinion.

Edited by Gingerly - 9 years ago

2

Reply

Quote

Lubabah Rahman

@ChurriBurri

Rocker

25

Posted: 9 years ago

#9

My brain will explode yaar!! Need more spoilers and segments...though Ravi keeps saying it's nt Sid. Grrr!!

Reply