Is acting not required to be in Indian Soaps?Mod note pg4,8&12 - Page 6

Originally posted by: msd21

I have seen all episodes. She has acted in soap before so one would assume that she is a better actor. But her expressions and smiles are fake. The only person so far who is good is the person playing dadi.

This is an open forum and not ravi-nia? not sure what you are trying to get at.

Originally posted by: SunshineTears

Oh not at all 😲 I see all these great actors/actresses from Tellywood going to Bollywood and ruining their careers. Such examples are Rejeev Khandelwal, Aamna Shariff, Eijaz Khan, Anita Hassanandani, Prachi Desai, Shilpa Anand etc. They were far more famous in Tellywood. Bollywood doesn't automatically mean "great acting", it means whoever has the most contacts and whoever can do the most item songs That's why all the actors/actresses in Bollywood now are children of famous actors/actresses. 🤢 This is the first time I heard something like Bollywood is a proof of acting skills 🥱 It's actually Nia's intelligent decision if she stays away from Bollywood!

OK, let us be realistic. All those names you mentioned wished to be in Bollywood. Most actors go to Tellywood first so that they can prove their talent. Once they have shown their talent, they go to bollywood because of larger audiences. Somtimes movies do not do well not because of actors but there is no story. I hope Nia does well in the coming episodes and I wish her well!

Originally posted by: crazyvirmanians

Lets take an example...

For example u r from an xyz country n a driver.. so wont u feeel offended by someone saying that "u cant drive at all n is driving not required in ur xyz country" Just a fair opinion?

Its ok if u would have used the words that she is not good as Roshni, or u r not liking her acting.. but saying "she cant act" is something offending for us as fansss

Not sure I understand the analogy. All I said was she does not appear to have acting skills - which is the same thing as "she is not good as Roshni" because if she did, she would be a good actor. I do not her personally - she may be an excellent person. BTW, fans do not have to follow someone blindly - they have to accept postive and negative criticism.

Cheers!

Originally posted by: msd21

You need to see some movies with great actresses, go beg some money from your mom😆

Originally posted by: crazyvirmanians

I agree its ur choice to like someone's acting or not, but making a post in forum which belongs to Nia n Ravi n then saying the girl playing Roshni doesnt knoe acting n at the end only we fans getting warning is something making us insecure..

Ok abusing or personal attack on topic maker maker is wrong but seriously no warning to topic maker..

Ps.. this happenned in past too.. n the topic of that post was, "Nia looks bad" n at that time even we were warned more than topic maker.. so maybe I m feeling more insecure

N I highly agreeed that abusing n calling names to topic maker or any other actor is wrong..

I'm not saying that the topic maker shouldn't be warned if they have made a bashing post but this topic maker hasn't made any bashing post. I have seen a lot of bashing posts and there has been strict action taken against them. One thing I can assure you of is that the dev team is definitely not biased and this is a promise. The topic maker here has just made constructive criticism here just pointing out on the acting nothing else as Jyoti already pointed out that it is not against the forum rules & if it was then the thread would have been closed instantly.

And one more thing; I disagree that this forum is just Nia-Ravi. This is an open forum for anyone who watches the show. There might be people around who watch the show for the story. I myself know a lot of people who are not fans of Nia or Ravi but they love te story hence the watch the show. So in my opinion; every member on IF who watches the show has a right to post and put forward their opinion without the fear of being bashed. Many members on this forum cannot take healthy and constructive criticism in a healthy manner hence the post gets negative and is forced I be closed. But there is a handful of people who can take criticism lightly as they don't blindly follow any actor so applause for them.

Again; this is NOT an invite for arguments nor is it meant to hurt anyone's feelings.

Originally posted by: jyoti06

The warning applies for both sides when I spoke about personal attack whether its the topic maker or the members commenting ... Personal attacks wont b allowed from either .,.,

@msd21 : Avoid quoting all the past posts where u felt attacked as a note for it is already given .. Counter attacking members with personal attack is against IF rules too ... U can keep your point on the topic related to the actor but without getting personal with any member ..

If the personal attacks still continue after this last note then I m afraid I will hv to finally close the topic then ,., But that does not give everyone the licence to go around personally attacking each other just to get a topic close because menbers involved in personal attacks anymore will also face a WL rise now ,...


JR Dev team

I already took the comment back! see my other post.

Originally posted by: msd21

I already took the comment back! see my other post.

I respect your opinion but even after she bashing the members and getting bashed this topic should have been closed

Originally posted by: .vineeta.

she turned me off completely after first week. She overact I feel

Let stop arguing wid dis people... Roshani is a far different character from Maanvi if u'll compare b'ween den u r seriously mindless..
Get some life people who r saying dat dey were fan of maanvi bt disappointed by Rosh...den its ur problem cz u cant understand difference b'ween characters...
Watever man if u like do watch dont den keep increasing our forum activity by ur insecurity... :p