Judai story line is coming out slowly - Page 2

Originally posted by: goldstar678

I dont think Suhani is Neira kid and i really hope she is not.I want her to be Rupalis kid only and i really hope they copy the film story.I hope Neil adopted her after her mothers death as he feel responsible for her mothers death.Ragini is very possesive about Neil and as its already revealed that he and Rupali were dating before the entry of Ragini in Neils life.I dont want Pam lying to Neil thing at all.

And answer to the question that when Pam dont care about Nishi and Aarav,why will she show so much love for Suhani if she is not Neil kid,its very simple.Pam never liked the fact that Neil married Ragini for x y z reasons.She always wanted Rupali and Neil to get married as im sure Rupali was Pam best friend(my assumption), rich,and all as Pam always talks about status and all.So my POV is as she is her best friends daughter and was responsible for the separation of Neira which she was waiting since their marriage.

Woman like Pam cant love anyone,i am sure she wont hesitate to use Suhani even now,if she sees that Neira are coming close together once again.when Pam wil be exposed she will give the same explanation to Neil that as she loves her brother a lot,she did all this for him,which actually is not true.

Why Neil is hiding about Suhaani to Nivedita is becoz he loves Suhaani the mos among the 3 Kids who are with him and he dont want Suhani to know that she is not his own kid and Ranbir and Agam are not her real brothers.

I will be really happy if they show this because already they are showing Neil standing at the wrong side by supporting Ranbir and not even intrested to know the truth from Karan (which actually is so dumb),so i really hope they will show this other side of Neil.If they show this,Ragini also will realise that she totally misunderstood her NACHIKET.

Last but not the least,its high time all Cvs should and must wake up from their sleep,sit together and discuss and creative head showing some intrest in the show rather than taking Selfies.

Originally posted by: loveanime

Even in the film rekha didn't know the patient was that sick so sick they would die it was an honest mistake. I can't imagine Ragini preventing Neil deliberately to reach a patient out of jealousy, even if she believed he was having an affair with that woman she would never risk another life out of spite she is too principled. Neil must have hid something about Rupali to Ragini, maybe Rupali being his x girlfriend Neil must have been afraid Ragini would over react. The way I see Neil act now I just don't think he is the honest kind of man he seems more like I will do what is best for my family type of person which led to their marriage break down. Rupali maybe had some personal problems issues with her own husband and family and she was trying to reach out to Neil as a friend. Neil must have not explained the situation properly to Ragini so she must have thought they were fooling around. God I miss Rudra and Paro they were the best communicators, these two are the worst they think something say something else feel different and do another thing.

Originally posted by: poetic

Again, what you say makes complete sense.

If we go back to the scene where Nachiket tells Ragini that should I remind you of the reason for our separation, it's almost as if the sky falls on Ragini.

Could it be that Suhaani is actually Ragini and Nachiket's kid? Maybe Ragini came to know about her pregnancy when they were on the verge of separation. She might be tried to connect with Nachiket, who might have distanced himself from her by then, both mentally and physically. Pam is the intermediary who doesn't tell Nachiket the truth. Ragini is made to believe that their daughter was still born; while actually Pam took the child and gave it to her brother, saying that Ragini didn't want it and was happy that the child was still born.

Nope, not making any sense. It would make Nachiket hate her for eternity.

Originally posted by: loveanime

I think the story could swing either ways. I don't think even the writers have decided what they want. What they will do whatever has the most complication, most pain, and confuses and irritates audience the most. If Suhaani is Neil and Ragini daughter then it is very complicated to explain why and how Suhani was stolen from Ragini and I think personally there is less drama with this version.

But if Suhani is not their daughter then it would be a real testament to Ragini character to love a child that she assumes is her husband love child. Imagine the shock on Ragini face when Suhani turns up and calls out mommy. Obviously Nishi and Arav no nothing of Suhani existence they would assume their mother hid they had another sibling from them because she didn't matter but seeing Suhani sweetness Ragini will never have the heart to tell her the truth, she will bitterly accept that Suhani thinks she is her mother. Neil's hatred for Ragini stems from the fact that he believe she is heartless and judgemental. When the truth gets revealed to Suhani that her whole existence was a lie she would hate everyone and maybe Ragini too if she believe Ragini had a hand in her mother Roopali death. They could show Nive gave up Suhani willingly because she was too young and had no real means to take care of a baby herself. And when Suhani returns Nive would want to bond with her but Suhani will want Ragini. Neil would fall in love with Ragini all over again seeing her strength in character considering he would know she is not Suhani mother but protects Suhani regardless from the bitter truth. But Ragini would hate Neil even more playing a sick game with her, telling their children he is Suhani mother so as to keep his own image up otherwise he would have to confess he cheated on their mother. So my vote goes for Suhani being not the biological sister, this version has far more drama, angst, and hatred involved.

From what I can guess on Neil and Ragini interactions so far, Neil doesn't hate Ragini he doesn't she is a bad person he knows her as stubborn, heartless and judgemental, but he knows that she is very principled. Ragini definitely seems to hate Neil she doesn't think Neil has any good values.

Originally posted by: poetic

Well, the storyline could swing either ways, as of now. And both will have enough drama. Though I agree that the one where Suhani is not NeiRa's daughter will have more drama.

The MU is great between the two, so much so that it has led to their divorce and separation. While Nachiket's heart is convinced that Ragini is not totally at fault; Ragini's head tells her that it's Nachiket's fault. And that's where the conflict lies. Even if they are away from each other, they still have feelings which itself in the form of extreme hatred, disbelief and MUs all over again.

While Nachiket's feelings are more or less visible - aww, he wears his heart on his sleeves; Ragini is far more controlled. But that doesn't mean that it's non existent. We are just not shown that part of her character, that yearning, that longingthat probably lies hidden within her.

Originally posted by: san2471

I do not think Rupali meant hell of a lot to Neil. He never takes her name and always says "Ek aurat ki jaan chali gayi"... Neil has definitely not cheated on Ragini. Even if Suhani is Rupali's child, it must be from someone else.

However, her resemblance to Ragini in her young days, being very simple and wanting simple things in life makes me feel that Suhani is NeiRa daughter !! She is too sweet to be a part of nagin family