Feeling shattered by the negative comments! - Page 3

wow you have a big heart😆

Dear Biancaraj,

🥱

better way stop watching IPKKND...

Originally posted by: Erika1

What do you mean by "Illiterate kids", are you talking about yourself?
You are such a lovely inspiring individual, who lack the depth to understand the simple diction of the IF members who were kind enough to reply to your post, giving you their honest opinion, whether negative or positive, you should therefore extend due respect and courtesy to their views.
What makes you better than another individual on this earth or in this forum, do you think by using a few big words that makes someone intelligent and literate?
ONLY GOD is above everyone else.
Its a pity that the same kids you think are illiterate, could one day surpass your superior intelligence, oh immortal one.

Very well said

TM, this is exactly what I meant - ur comment calling us illiterate kids...will fetch u more negativity...it has become a vicious cycle...plz stop being so rude to ur fans...you are even losing support of the moderate well speaking members of the forum...

Dear Binacaaj...first of all I commend you for having the courage to put your point forward...Athough, you could have done without the illiterate kids reference...

You are right that IPKKND forum members have not given serious consideration to the fact that the title of the show meant all types of love not only romantic love...In fact I noticed that too and made a post a few days back exactly abou the same point saying IPKKND is about all kinds of love..

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3175564

.

But while you have a story with a nice philosophical theme...your characterization of the various characters on the show is highly inconsistent and completely devoid of common sense more often than not...While it is true that each character is driven by certain experiences...your characters jump from one to the other without having any bridge or continuity at times ...and a complete lack of amnesia of what they were thinking before...To you sir, I recommend...brushing up the characterization skills by either watching or better still reading Romeo and Julliet, pride and Prejudice or any number of classic...or even modern literary works ...

Secondly, if you are serious about showing a story of a woman who has been scarred by her past and gone through such a big trauma...can you please convince her to dress for the part...and not lose he baby bump in one day? Now about maintaining some continuity in her physical state that she was just wounded and couldn't walk with lacerations on her feet?


The direction on this show is lacking in a major way...to convey a complex story like different facets of love...you need direction caliber that can deal with complexity...instead eveytime a complicated situation comes...your characters (except Arnav...who is also butchered at times but not always) can't think beyond one thought at a time...why not pay more attention to your women characters...Why do they often come across as dumb to many women waching the show...? Why cant they be emotional but not have amnesia...why do they appear incoherent about their thought process ...just like Khushi did when she ran away from RM...fussing about a birthday gift?


At the end of the day sir...you are the one selling a story...and if the audience is not buying it...the literature you have read has not helped you enough to be successful...

.

I am not a kid. That's why I think showing a woman making kissy face with a husband who has been maligned the way Shyam has been is unrealistic. Showing a woman as pious as anjali WAS lying, manipulating, sneaking around and emotionally blackmailing is not realistic. I also think showing a woman go through a stillbirth, not miscarriage, and then pine away for kissy time with herr husband is incredulous and unrealistic. I also think building up one LOVE story as the central theme of your show for 13 months and pulling a switcheroo is disingenuous to the audience who were prepared for the culmination of the center plot.

So you see, its not that people ddont understand what we are seeing in the show, we don't like the insensitivity and total lack of emotional integrity with which it is being executed. The script and screenplay don't connect with audience. That is the bottom line.