Ishana scenes caused drop in trp - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

157

Views

11.8k

Users

49

Likes

717

Frequent Posters

VIMAL.SM thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Aahana-


Whatever you have written makes complete sense but I can't overlook the fact that they composed a SEVEN minute beautiful song which is longer than Shivika's O Jaana and I'm sure it must have cost them some big bucks with the singers and musicians involved plus the obvious length as well. When they have everything in place, have spent so much (Ishana's costumes are better than Anika's)why not spend some of their brains as well and come up with a storyline that would impress everyone? How difficult is it for them to do it if the writers of this forum can do it?

No doubt It was always Shivika that had all the prominence in the show but I never thought they would sideline other tracks in this manner. Omkara had a proper individual story but they have abandoned that as well. Its a rare show wherein the elders also have their own interesting story lines yet these people are hell bent on ruining all of it. So much potential is being wasted!



@Bold - Completely agree.Vrushy in a seg said the bangles attached with earrings .Specially done for her.Also the earrings.When they can put the thought process n research in these things.Why can't they do it on most imp thing.That's writing a proper track for Ishana.
Edited by VIMAL.M - 9 years ago
--Anushka-- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
😆
Gul rants about feminism, supporting women power blah blah blah and has no regrets in blaming Vrushika for dip in TRP, when vrushika hardly had any screen time more than 10-15 mins in the show. Madam Gul where did your justice go? Only on papers I suppose 😆. This lady seems to be more immature than fans. Grow up Gul.

I haven't been regular viewer though as a vrushika fan I did try giving this show a chance, but ishana's character wasn't that appealing. It was all over the place. But yeah the confrontation was pretty good and I give all credit to the actors. Dialogues could have been better but yeah only sensible scene of ishkara was that. Apart from that nothing great I found in this show. It's one among the Gul's clich! Same old angry young man, down trodden girl fall in love and story goes on.

All that Gul does is copy paste! And I read few comments that she copies from her own creations. I strongly disagree! All her creations are copied as well, KMH, KTH, KHNK all these K-shows had same kind of stories, Rich guy falling for poor one and our Gul flicked the idea and came around saying she has bade biggest shows blah blah. In reality she cannot write a character different from clichd ones.

I saw a comment about cinevistas. To be honest,in my opinion cinevistas had a very good team. Palki definitely is one of the best creators coz she can think out of the box, be it DMG or D3. Apart from her beyond dreams are any day a better production house too, they have a unique story everytime. I hope vrushika bags some other PH role. It'll be a good learning fir her. 4lions are not the ideal one to start off career on a GEC. Again its my opinion.

Good luck Vrushika!
VIMAL.SM thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: AlwyzT.

I disagree with this post. Sorry, guys. You can't just blame our Gul ma'am. She has but spoken all the truth.

The viewers have the ability to predict when Ishana's sixty seconds (gasp! so long) scene is to come and they immediately change the channel due to which the trp has dropped down way too much.

And Bala-Mala plot is actually mine. I own it. There's a cactus in my garden and it does wonders! You put a blank piece of paper beside it and close your eyes for one minute two seconds (the time equivalent to Ishana's presence on TV) and you now pick it up and there is something written on it. I did this and Bela-Mala story you saw on IB was written on the paper which I threatened the CVs to show. They aren't at fault.

And about screenspace, why Ishana got so less is because Gul ma'am is trying to merge Qubool Hain season 4 with Ishqbaaz to finally produce Comedy Nights with Oberois. And so to build up the 'aura' for it- Ishana was shown less. There is no logic behind this. But who cares.

But you Ishana fans, you ignorant fools, why did you bash our ma'am? She is doing a social service to us with her amazing shows.

Please fon't bash ma'am. I'll cry.



👏.I love it.

@Bold - 😆😆 Epic.Nice name Comedy Nights With Oberois.

After reading ur post.My eyes r opened.Sorry I MU'ed our innocent Gul mam.Now onwards I will praise her for the social service she do.

Sorry I will not bash Gul mam pls don't cry.


Edited by VIMAL.M - 9 years ago
VIMAL.SM thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: --Anushka--

😆

Gul rants about feminism, supporting women power blah blah blah and has no regrets in blaming Vrushika for dip in TRP, when vrushika hardly had any screen time more than 10-15 mins in the show. Madam Gul where did your justice go? Only on papers I suppose 😆. This lady seems to be more immature than fans. Grow up Gul.

I haven't been regular viewer though as a vrushika fan I did try giving this show a chance, but ishana's character wasn't that appealing. It was all over the place. But yeah the confrontation was pretty good and I give all credit to the actors. Dialogues could have been better but yeah only sensible scene of ishkara was that. Apart from that nothing great I found in this show. It's one among the Gul's clich! Same old angry young man, down trodden girl fall in love and story goes on.

All that Gul does is copy paste! And I read few comments that she copies from her own creations. I strongly disagree! All her creations are copied as well, KMH, KTH, KHNK all these K-shows had same kind of stories, Rich guy falling for poor one and our Gul flicked the idea and came around saying she has bade biggest shows blah blah. In reality she cannot write a character different from clichd ones.

I saw a comment about cinevistas. To be honest,in my opinion cinevistas had a very good team. Palki definitely is one of the best creators coz she can think out of the box, be it DMG or D3. Apart from her beyond dreams are any day a better production house too, they have a unique story everytime. I hope vrushika bags some other PH role. It'll be a good learning fir her. 4lions are not the ideal one to start off career on a GEC. Again its my opinion.

Good luck Vrushika!



I wish Vrushy bag Inspire Films show[It's unit of Beyond Dreams] or Bodhi Tree Multimedia Pvt Ltd show.
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Aahana-


Whatever you have written makes complete sense but I can't overlook the fact that they composed a SEVEN minute beautiful song which is longer than Shivika's O Jaana and I'm sure it must have cost them some big bucks with the singers and musicians involved plus the obvious length as well. When they have everything in place, have spent so much (Ishana's costumes are better than Anika's)why not spend some of their brains as well and come up with a storyline that would impress everyone? How difficult is it for them to do it if the writers of this forum can do it?

No doubt It was always Shivika that had all the prominence in the show but I never thought they would sideline other tracks in this manner. Omkara had a proper individual story but they have abandoned that as well. Its a rare show wherein the elders also have their own interesting story lines yet these people are hell bent on ruining all of it. So much potential is being wasted!


The soundtrack is also because fans pushed for it.I could be wrong though but why don't Rudra and Saumya have a soundtrack?

Because they are not that popular and fans are not that pushy for them.But in case of Om and Ishaana since they were popular and fans were pushy we got a song.I could be wrong though but this is my theory.

But fans wanted more they wanted a story with equal screen space as that of Shivika or as strong writing but that was never Gul's plan.

Since you area Klaroline fan you will understand what i am saying .See even Klaroline's popularity was unexpected.None of them were leads but all of a sudden one scene and they becmae popular.How much we wanted Klarolien to have more scenes but they never did but the difference here was that TVD writer's themselves were so good that even the small scenes of Karoline had a lot of power and chemistry.But in case of Om and Ishaana not only did they not get the screen space fans wanted but even the writing was bad.If atleast one thing was good like it was in case of Klaroline fans would have been satisfied.But that wasn't the case hence complaints kept on increasing which was unexpected for Gul.
Edited by Sabhayata - 9 years ago
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: AlwyzT.

I disagree with this post. Sorry, guys. You can't just blame our Gul ma'am. She has but spoken all the truth.

The viewers have the ability to predict when Ishana's sixty seconds (gasp! so long) scene is to come and they immediately change the channel due to which the trp has dropped down way too much.

And Bala-Mala plot is actually mine. I own it. There's a cactus in my garden and it does wonders! You put a blank piece of paper beside it and close your eyes for one minute two seconds (the time equivalent to Ishana's presence on TV) and you now pick it up and there is something written on it. I did this and Bela-Mala story you saw on IB was written on the paper which I threatened the CVs to show. They aren't at fault.

And about screenspace, why Ishana got so less is because Gul ma'am is trying to merge Qubool Hain season 4 with Ishqbaaz to finally produce Comedy Nights with Oberois. And so to build up the 'aura' for it- Ishana was shown less. There is no logic behind this. But who cares.

But you Ishana fans, you ignorant fools, why did you bash our ma'am? She is doing a social service to us with her amazing shows.

Please fon't bash ma'am. I'll cry.



You have great sense of humour😆
Sutapasima thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
I did not like the way the creatives had portrayed her .. They need to pul up their socks before blaming any one else.
TRP aunties are the ones who give you TRPs not online fandom
misspinkun thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
trp vrushy ke wajah se nahi balki dekhna issh hafte Surbhi Jyoti ke wajah se down hogi dekh lena...😡👎🏼💔
Flame. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Sabhayata


The soundtrack is also because fans pushed for it.I could be wrong though but why don't Rudra and Saumya have a soundtrack?

Because they are not that popular and fans are not that pushy for them.But in case of Om and Ishaana since they were popular and fans were pushy we got a song.I could be wrong though but this is my theory.

But fans wanted more they wanted a story with equal screen space as that of Shivika or as strong writing but that was never Gul's plan.

Since you area Klaroline fan you will understand what i am saying .See even Klaroline's popularity was unexpected.None of them were leads but all of a sudden one scene and they becmae popular.How much we wanted Klarolien to have more scenes but they never did but the difference here was that TVD writer's themselves were so good that even the small scenes of Karoline had a lot of power and chemistry.But in case of Om and Ishaana not only did they not get the screen space fans wanted but even the writing was bad.If atleast one thing was good like it was in case of Klaroline fans would have been satisfied.But that wasn't the case hence complaints kept on increasing which was unexpected for Gul.


Umm i don't think so. I think the Ishkara song came out when nobody expected it and they even answered in positive when asked if there's a female version of it plus if it was only because of fan demand then they could have given any 3-4 minute song but this is seven minutes. And as far as I have read Rumya do have a song that's not yet released.
I get what you're saying especially after the Klaroline example. No one thought they could become so huge after one or two scenes and yes, the makers gave us brilliant scenes till the very end.
These makers are also capable of doing it but I don't know why they are making it an issue. Its not as difficult as they make it seem. Now for example if you have seen modern family then you must have noticed how sometimes there are multiple story lines taking place simultaneously which they merge in the end in a twenty minute episode. I know the genre is different but its still possible but seems like Gul and her team are just not interested.
sneharay thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
Bang on post...totally agree 👍🏼

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".