Who could have made a difference?

Hello guys now that Indian idol has ended & the winner picked, i was thinking of those contestants among the top 28 who couldn't make it to the Gala rounds.

As we all know that II has public voting from the piano rounds itself and a genuinely talented singer gets the boot for lack of votes very early without getting the opportunity to showcase his/her vocal skills in the final rounds whereby he/she could have given tough competition to the selected finalists & who knows even be the winner or top 3 competitor.

So which eliminated contestant of the piano rounds do you think could have made a huge difference in the gala rounds and why?

Do you feel any of these(Top 28 excluding the top 13) contestants can go ahead and compete in the next season of II or any other such TV singing competitions and excel?

Here is the list of the best of the rest who were left out at the half way mark.

GIRLS:
Aisha Sayed
Harshida Madhaparia
Pinky Maidasani
Priyanka Mukherjee
Rashmi Vijayan
Shifa Ansari
Vanita
Vartika Shukla


BOYS:
Anish Jain
Bharat Uniyal
Bhavin Dhanak
Padmanav Bordoloi
Rehan Khan
Roshan Singh
Shantanu Sudame
Suhit Gosain

My choices are;
Aisha, Rashmi, Vanita, Bhavin, Bharat, Shantanu & Padmanav
(will come back with the reasons)


PS: If you feel anybody even from the pre-Piano rounds were good enough to be top 5 material please feel free to mention their names with valid reasons.

I was just watching some of the old piano episodes and thinking the same..

Girls:

Aisha
Harshida
Vanita

Boys:

Bhavin
Padmanav
Shantanu

grt post...
was goin thru the piano round vids the other day n believe that the comp wud have reached another level had
bhavin, ayesha, rashmi, vanita, shantanu made it to the galas...along with amit, deepali, emon, puja, smita, chang/abhishek/prashant n jolly (have to put her in..)
they were all gud singers with gud powerful voices...
thou amit wud still have been my fav 😛 ...but these guyz deserved to b in the final 13

i think bhavin, ayesha, shifa, & shantanu deserved to be in top 12.

i didn't watch II from the start but i did watch a few epis.

so according to that i wud say aisha, shifa, bhavin....

I would say Suhit..he will do well in any other talent show and he is I think the only one out of the eliminated piano rounds contestants who is actully doing something big in the music business..His gna be in band..the album is coming out!!😳😃

~ Urrm other then that I like Aisha's voice and Harshita's voice a lot, AAisha would have been tough competition for Deepali and Puja.

xxxxxxxxx

I wud say Aisha Syed ....She defi deserved to be in top 13

I hope she will get chance in her life

I didnt really watch the piano rounds so I dont knwo anything about any of them excpet Suhit. He could havre made a difference in the voting.

I would think Suhit ...he was great