Siddh - can we have one more petition - Page 8

we are calling siddh and he no where around

or he is busy in making the petition

Originally posted by: priyankumupal

i would support this petition too but i have one small question?
when alisha said to ankita we are not looking for a performer but a singer in indian idol and you are not what we are looking for, where was all this sympathy? i mean didn't ankita feel like crying then? isn't she also a kid who has dreams? when it was said to ankita no one wanted to petition against it, but when it's said to emon that he can't make it big we get hurt. it seems a bit wrong of us.

After having said that i believe Javed ji should say sorry to emon, cos no one has a right to break someone's spirit no matter how old and respected they are.

No Alisha i have heard even in the last round praised Ankita. She must have said so in a gala where she must have not sung well. So she gave her judgement that II is for singer and not performer. THAT IS TRUE AND NOT WRONG. and she has a way of telling without hurting.

But here EMON sang very well all throughout flawless. IN FACT HE SINGS THE BEST IN THE LOT. AMIT HAS A HEAVY DEPTH VOICE BUT HE WAS OUT AND CAME IN TRHOUGH WILD CARD AND IS IMPROVING BUT STILL HE NEVER SANG FLAWLESS EXCEPT THAT HIS VOICE COVERED UP HIS MISTAKES. I AM AMIT FAN TOO. BUT THAT IS THE FACT. Only they are feeling Emon's voice is like Sonu. That is ok THOUGH IT IS NOT AS SONU HIMSELF TOLD.

BUT HERE JAVEDJI WAS VERY RUDE AND JUST PREDICTED HIS FUTER AND WROTE HIM OFF EVEN BEFORE HE IS ELIMINATED .

PRASHANT WILL WIN. NEITHER EMON OR AMIT. THE Q HERE IS HOW CAN YOU WRITE OFF A SINGER WHEN THE MUSICIAN HIMSELF EMBRACED HIM AND CALLED HIM A VERSATILE SINGER.

EMON IS 18 AND HIS VOICE WILL CHANGE AND CAN BE MODULATED AND NOW A DAYS SO MUCH OF TECHNIQUES IT CAN BE SOUNDED BETTER WHEN RECORDING.

JAVEDJI HAS NO RIGHT TO HUMILIATE HIM AND DEMORALISE HIM THIS WAY A YOUNG BOY TRYING HIS HEARD TO BE A GOOD SINGER. EMON WAS ALWAYS HUMBLE.

Originally posted by: srk_lover

hes sleeping....loll

oh oops

ok soja raj kumar soja

sukh sapno mein khoja

aur subah udkar petition bana

Originally posted by: ManaliS

tell me priyan...what did alisha say...? yeah she said u r not the best singer...more of a performer..did she declare that Ankita tum kuch nahi ban paogi? did she? NO!therez a huge difference b/w criticizing a performnce n saying things like that u have no future...naa tum singer ban paoge naa performer.. javed jee shudnt have said that...i am neither an ankita fan nor emon..heck i dont even care abt amit n prashant..but wrong is wrong..

Right i just posted a reply on Alisha's judgement. Yes i just wrote the same in my post

" NO!therez a huge difference b/w criticizing a performnce n saying things like that u have no future...naa tum singer ban paoge naa performer.. javed jee shudnt have said that...i am neither an ankita fan nor emon..heck i dont even care abt amit n prashant..but wrong is wrong."

anjali...please dont rite in caps...itz shouting on the forum 😳

Originally posted by: soulfry

alisha never said that. she said out of emon, deepali and ankita she would prefer ankita to be eliminated and she didnt sound harsh at all. she said ankita is a very good performer but she sings flat at this point she felt deepali and emon are better singers and it will be a death of a singer if one of them leaves.....who were in bottom 3 along with ankita that day

Right she gave her judgement on comparison as singers. BUT NEVER WROTE OFF ANKITA and said you have no future etc.

Originally posted by: srk_lover

anjali...please dont rite in caps...itz shouting on the forum 😳

OK OK sorry . I find it easy to type keeping caps as i type very very fast. Anyway then i will not use caps at all at the beginning of sentence at all.

loads of wls support the petition..he must say sorry...who is he to say whether emon wld be a playback singer or not...he is horrible 😡 😡 😡

Ya I also agree that JA is wayyy out of line but I thought he aditted his mistakes and misunderstandings in the coming gala 😕 😕 ....in fact I supported JA in the gala update thread when I learnt that he praised Emon a lot admitting his mistakes !!!!!!!!

I don't know whether he apologised or not !!!!!

U guys r right ..I have never seen a judge to right off a singer like that saying tum kuchh ban nahi paoge ...u will never be a play back singer ...like what the heckkkk !!!! 😡