No offense but...how is Prashant still in - Page 7

Originally posted by: orchid10

What is talent and how does one measure it? Is there an instrument called talentometer or something that your hang over somebody's head or strap to their wrist to get the exact measurement to the second decimal point, of how much talented a singer is? No right? It's subjective! Just because you or I feel somebody is not talented does not mean our neighbours or friends would feel the same. If everybody started beleiving their subjective view is universal truth and the views that don't comply with our own is 'silly' 'stupid' and 'ridiculous' then we all know which way the world would go.

did i say anywhere in my post that my opinion was the universal truth? it is just my opinion...i feel some are more talented than others so i made that statement...now before u go on rambling some theory, read what i wrote...

no offense but wht kind of topic is this...

ek kaam karta hoon poch ke aata hoon why prashant is still in

Originally posted by: shabzalicious

I really agree with this.. no offense to prashant fans.. wen i saw prashant try out i liked his voice.. but then again an again hes been gettin bashed by judges.. i mean in the last gala yeah anu malik said he is awesome but the rest said he wasnt as good.. even sonu nigam who is an extraordinary singer... i mean yeah i liiiiiiiiike chang but i like amit too an i dont see why puja had to leave wen prashants singing wasnt all that great.. an ur rite hes never been in the danger zone wen all of em have... even chang now... an amit had been kicked out so i mean prashant hasnt had anythin bad happen to him even after constant bad comments from judges... i used to think indian idol was all abt singing.. but its not.. its abt bringn money in for sony... i watch saregama an thats wat i call talent.. i eman indian idol is all abt the money... like take sandeep... sorry to say but that guy sucked.. indian idol is findin a performer as well as a singer.. sandeep sounded juss like uditji.. we dont want another uditji.. an loko at karunya.. has his own album out an sang for a cuple of movies.. as well as abhijeet.. where is sandeep now? na naam na nishaan.. kuch bhi pata nahi hai uska... nowhere to be heard or anytying.. i think amey is doin sumtings.. i mean either india *no offense to any of u*.. doenst know how to vote or its all a set up.. cuz u cant kick a good singer like deepali out an keep a not so good singer ankita jisme sur itna nahi hai an prashant in... i probably have said more than ims uppsd to be but i guess im voicing my opinion cuz i was very upset to hear that after 4 constant good singers were given goood comments i mean oustanding comments an they were kicked out... wen they were more derserveing then others... :-)

Totally agree with you!!!! I mean prashant is good but not that deserving to be in the Top 6.... Much better singers like Deepali and now Puja have left....And Ankita is still in*no offence to her and his fans though* But Ankita is giving much more attention to her performance rather then her singing...which is causing her to lose the spotlight...but still she is in...I mean how come? Its supposed to be the Top 6 and only 3 are good...emon,chang, and amit...

~Mona😛

Originally posted by: *payal*

did i say anywhere in my post that my opinion was the universal truth? it is just my opinion...i feel some are more talented than others so i made that statement...now before u go on rambling some theory, read what i wrote...

Eh? So what were you implying when you said 'at this rate the better question to be asking is how are amit and emon still here'? Wasn't that an expression of your frustration at why those who vote for Ankita, Prashant and Chang vote for them rather than Emon and Amit? Which again implies that your opinion/belief should be shared by all! Otherwise there was no need to ask that question, because the answer is self explanatory, these 3 haven't been ousted yet because people voted for them more than the ousted contestants.

Ofcourse you have every right to determine who you feel is more talented like everybody else, since talent assessment is subjective, but so does everybody else.

Oh, and ' talent is subjective' is not a theory, it's a fact.

Originally posted by: orchid10

Eh? So what were you implying when you said 'at this rate the better question to be asking is how are amit and emon still here'? Wasn't that an expression of your frustration at why those who vote for Ankita, Prashant and Chang vote for them rather than Emon and Amit? Which again implies that your opinion/belief should be shared by all! Otherwise there was no need to ask that question, because the answer is self explanatory, these 3 haven't been ousted yet because people voted for them more than the ousted contestants.

Ofcourse you have every right to determine who you feel is more talented like everybody else, since talent assessment is subjective, but so does everybody else.

Oh, and ' talent is subjective' is not a theory, it's a fact.

hmm i think i would know what i was talking about more than u since its my opinion...and i used the phrase at this rate to express my opinion not a fact....hope that cleared my meaning to u...u can interpret it whatever way u want...but only i know what i meant and i am saying it now to u...

Originally posted by: Naina007

Compared to others he doesnt seemsucha outstanding singer ... yet good singers are leaving and hes still in...i dont know how no offense to any of his fans

Plz do a research work / or thesis or whatever on how this is happening. I think u'll definitely get the necessary funds from the "Prashant bashers" on this forum 😆 😆 😆 U can enlighten us all about your research results 😆 😆 😆 And some esteemed educational institution may award u a doctoral degree for all ur efforts 😆 😆 😆

All the best 😃

no offense but i think prashant is one of the best and he's like the third best in the show, so thats why he shouldn't be out at all!!!!!!! 😆 😳 😊

Originally posted by: Naina007

Compared to others he doesnt seem such a outstanding singer ... yet good singers are leaving and hes still in...i dont know how no offense to any of his fans

i don't remember he ever came in bottom4or3...i don't find anything interesting in his singing..i think he is getting vote from NEPAL ALSO...EVEN UDIT NARAYAN(NEPALI) on his weak performace, pass some positive comments...and for others contestant's excellent performance he aprreciate but don't use good words.

Originally posted by: MONICA0819

i don't remember he ever came in bottom4or3...i don't find anything interesting in his singing..i think he is getting vote from NEPAL ALSO...EVEN UDIT NARAYAN(NEPALI) on his weak performace, pass some positive comments...and for others contestant's excellent performance he aprreciate but don't use good words.

haha, thats retarded. First thing, I have not seen Udit Comment good on Prashant. Its always ANU of Javed Akthar giving him good inputs. I have never actually ( rarely) heard alisha praising him, same with Udit.

Secondly, Nepalis in Nepal cannot Vote for him.

P.S. Even if all the nepalis voted form. India is like 20 times bigger than nepal plus all NRIs in UK, UAE.. can also vote. So, I dont think thats the case.

The man can Sing. sad but true

Originally posted by: lisa_ray

Yuno instead of Deepali and Abishek...Ankita and Prashnat shudve been out...i mean Prashant have the votes from all the Police and other gov people...why is he still there...he does not desrve to be in there

so true totally agree even charu and parleen were better than prashant and charu much better than prashant cz she was better singer and good looks
Parleen was singing ok but better looks so they shuld have gone after prashant