Emon vs Amanat Ali - Page 4

Originally posted by: dell123

why are you comparing AManat with Emon. Amanat, Raja, Aneek are the best singers there..even if the wrost singers from Saregamapa come in Indian Idol they will def make it to top 5 or top 3. if one of these three come they will def be idol for singing. 😊

u know wot...u can xpress ur opinion...but u hv no right to insult anyone...perticularly" Indian Idol" contestants...all of us r watching the show n can make out who's gun n who's bad...we also understand music...plus we also hv fully functional pair of ears....plsss stop behaving as if its only u who can understand music...sur n taal...got that...

EEks...."saregamapa"...it's suchha big turnoff...everybody on the show overreacts...the show as well as the contestants r grossely overrated....

INDIAN IDOL CONTESTANTS R WAY BETTER THAN ANY saregamapa CONTESTANTS ANY GIVEN DAY....

@cancer__gal...: okay okay.. take it easy... you think II3 is better than SRGMP.. okay fine... dont take it toooo seriously 😃

but others may not agree with you same as you are not agreeing with few of our frendz 😳

i think they both did well b/c amanat sang more like

shafqat amanat, who is the actuall singer of mitwa. but

emon sang it in his own kind of voice which was also

good, so u cant compare the 2 of them. they both were

100% in sur, i am sure.! 👏

Amanat sung it really nice, but Emon is very good too. I am a big fan of both and like both of them . 😃

Amanat was better as he brought out the songs emotions more and sung it like how it was...a soulful song...not a party song 😊

our emon was better👏

though Amanat is also veri good 😛

I would say that we shouldn't be comparing Amanat with Emon as both the voices are so different. The better comparision would be to compare Amanat with Amit i would say.

Personally I feel that both are very good singers but Emon can sing all types of songs. By that I mean that he is bound to a specific type of song, he is so versatile and I can't think of any songs which will not suit his voice.

Amanat on the other hand is a very good singer too and can also sing all type of songs but I would prefer him to sing only certain types of songs.

Originally posted by: spsharmila

Emon sang the song as a filmy song (which it is !!)
Amanat sang it as if he is singing in a clasical concert....with additional alaaps and murkis. Also he was singing in lower scale than emon.Thats why it feels that amanat sang much better than emon.Actually singing wise I don't think emon was less than amanat. One more difference I have noticed is that in II3 the participants get only 2 minutes to finish the song, now-a-days mostly all songs are longer in length so they are not able to give justice to the song....it sounds unfinished 😕 On the other hand in SAREGAMPA the contestents are given more time to perform on the song.

i totally agree wid u😃