singers grading!!!!!

I have graded the singers: Based on singing talent and 'performance'. I am 95% sure that one from grade A will win.

my favorites are in grade C!!!

A: deepali, emon, abhisekh, amit

B: puja, ankita, parleen

C: prashant, chang, charu

if u oppose this (i mean blatantly)..i will know that you havent follwed II1 and II2; and have never seen other similar contests!😆 sorry to say this , most ppl in this forum speak from heart and not brain!!

and yes I watch each and every episodes of II, VOI and saregamapa.

I like II, saregamapa and VOI: in that order (till now and this may change!!)

And i feel ashamed when i see my favorites/participants in II nowhere close to the singing talents of other shows. but still II and their participants are emotionally attached to me and will be close to my heart until the end of the show.

I will feel most saddened when prashant, deepali and chang are ousted. and little for pooja. in a way, girls would make me cry..universal truth...

I would be v v happy to be proved wrong..u should know why by now!!

If u have any questions, i will defend them to the best of my knowledge.

I disgaree with you putting Puja in the same category as Parleen and Ankita. Puja has all the qualities to become a playback singer like Udit Narayan said. She has sung difficult songs with ease which I don't think Ankita or Parleen could do without losing sur.

ok i am happy you put deepali n amit in grade A....bbut can you plz elaborate how did you make those grades n on what basis....

r_tvfan

As i said its the combination of singing talent and performance...and (the realistic) chance that they reach the top...performace as well as public sympathy matters a lot in addition to the real singing...

roadies_4 fan

what i did was simply
i combined
1. pure singing talent (based on my knowledge and judges comments)
2. performance or desire to win ppls heart
3. public votes/sympathy/popularity

giving more weigth to 1,2,3 respectively.

I think you should give Ankita grade A.. She is the most consistent singer so far. If u dont believe go and watch last 5 or 6 II3 shows.

i guess she is the only one who has been continuously getting positive comments from all the judges

Originally posted by: indnep

roadies_4 fan

what i did was simply
i combined
1. pure singing talent (based on my knowledge and judges comments)
2. performance or desire to win ppls heart
3. public votes/sympathy/popularity

giving more weigth to 1,2,3 respectively.

ok so well ....so accordin to you the ppl in grade A have the highest chance of winning?

i agree with u for the most part...switch abhishek and puja and i'll agree 100%..after a while, these shows become soo predictable

Originally posted by: f_javaid

I think you should give Ankita grade A.. She is the most consistent singer so far. If u dont believe go and watch last 5 or 6 II3 shows.

i guess she is the only one who has been continuously getting positive comments from all the judges

yea totally agree wit u..but dont worry as long as she gets A grade frm judges den im happy nd they hv more sense of muzic.. nd so far she hasnt gone danger zone👏it show now she has lot of supporters out of IF who belives dt she deserves A grade👏

Originally posted by: madhy

yea totally agree wit u..but dont worry as long as she gets A grade frm judges den im happy nd they hv more sense of muzic.. nd so far she hasnt gone danger zone👏

If you read update of Gala 4 then u will find that she will rock again 😃 and this time Govinda (celeb judge) will come to the stage to dance with her

guys guys ...
u shouldnt always go with the judges...history shows it doesnt work..fullstop...public is public...its as simple as that...

ankita is good performer..but shes not II material..
u need much more range, versatality, personality for that!! also everyone everyone will rock at some point of time!

i stand by what i wrote at the beginning..not a voice of heart!