Better Judge...Who?

Hey guys.. Who do u think is a better judge in Indian Idol?

sonu and shabana azmi are really gud! both of them give a lot of constructive critisism and encourage the participants to do their best. javed aktar is also excellent but i feel tht he has a teeny weeny itsy bitsy bias towards smita. anu, well, hes very unpredictable. when he praises, he praises so tht the contestants becum very confident (rather overconfident) and when he critisises, its rather demoralising them and crushing their confidence into bits and pieces. n ive realised tht he sumtimes praises very mediocre performances and pulls down sum not-so-bad performers.

farah was gud...but she mostly judges the performance and presentation of the singers. and alisha and udit....well, dunt really think they are a powerful judge! 😕 😳 😃

i wud say shabana but i like javed more than her

Deff. Shabana G. I think she tells
the contestants their mistakes
along with a inspirational comment.
😊

Yes i like Shabana G too 😃