Richa's future being spoilt

I sincerely believe that Richa's career is being spoilt by their parents and by judges as well. After so many years of training if she is so bad like this ( problem is that she just sings from mouth), i dont think she can be any better in the future. She should choose another career.

I think tht she's an excellent singer, but its just tht she not much of a performer and her voice sounds as if shes a kid. She needs grow up in the content of singing .. but yes she is an amazing classical singer!

Originally posted by: prettyasjen

but yes she is an amazing classical singer!

Are we talking about Jhumri Talaiyyan Classical Music. Because one day by chance in search of Bhelpuri I landed up in a classical music concert where the cacophony was so awful, I havent found Richa to be of that horrible calibre..

U cannot make tht judgement...hw do u know hw her voice will mature ...have u heard songs by lataji and ashaji in their teens..i have....somewhr...they also sound a bit childish and nasal...but their voices matured and they trained their voices sooo well...tht later their voices ruled the music industry for decades in India....so give her time..i agree she has joined II a couple of yrs sooner than she shld have though....but at such a young age if she can sing such tough songs..i wonder hw she'll sound later in life... 😃

If all children with nasal childish voices having spent a year or 2 in classical music classes mature and become Asha and Lata, the Indian Government will have a hard time setting up factories to make Padma Bhushan and Padma Vibhushan and Padma Shri stattuettes to honor them. Personally I rather desist from giving them so much trouble. 😕 😕 😕

she is just 16, she has a bright future ahead

Originally posted by: bigyo_bancharam

If all children with nasal childish voices having spent a year or 2 in classical music classes mature and become Asha and Lata, the Indian Government will have a hard time setting up factories to make Padma Bhushan and Padma Vibhushan and Padma Shri stattuettes to honor them. Personally I rather desist from giving them so much trouble. 😕 😕 😕

No yaaarr...i'm not saying ki...she or anyother girl who sings in a childish voice like her..is gonna becum the next asha or lata...try to see the underlying message here...if she can take such alaaps and harkatein at her age...she can definately improve wit time....why just go and crucify her onli becoz her voice sounds childish....on the show..she wasn't the onli one who sounds childish...shifa and puja too have childish voices....but let's give them time....personally i wud have preferred if they wud have waited a yr or two b4 joining the competition...i mean...they r young..wht's the rush..but i still cannot deny tht all of these girls have talent....let's not be sooo blinded by hate tht we cannot appreciate even wht's good...😕

She's too immature and childish. she deserves to be out next episode.

Leave the singing to the "talents" not the "payyans."

Originally posted by: kothra

she is just 16, she has a bright future ahead

I would say so, but not in musical career for sure. There are far better singers than her, even at her age. She cannot bring life into her song. That is her major disadvantage and that is very hardly going to change with age.

i think she is a good singer...however annoying she may be....but if she lets her voice mature first and maybe mature herself too...then i think she has a very good chance at being a playback singer!!! like javed saab said, her voice is kiddish!!!