Dont be complacent - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

1.1k

Users

11

Frequent Posters

bsb-star thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#11
fair play to u, u got ur reasons- but at the end of the day i still stik wid karu to tick all the points you mentionned above!!
ng4khan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: movieman1111


Frankly yes...If you want one on one comparison see it ..
1) Technical knowledge on singing : Karunya better
2) Voice : Sandeep better (Dont confuse it with singing)
3) Singing: Karunya better
4) Confidence: Sandeep better
5) Ability to improve (assuming Karunya is singing since the age of 4, and i still dont know since when Sandeep is singing, thanks to Sony for hiding that) : Sandeep
6) Stage Performance: Sandeep better
7) Playback singing ability and match : Sandeep better
and mind you i never went for Sandeeps smile or innocent and i dont believe Sandeep or Karunya anyone is innocent.

😊All the seven points mentioned by you Karu has got in abundance and we can add even some more points to that, Like versatality, breathing control, and last but not tha least recognition by very eminent people in the music world. No body can deny their judgement. Gina.

checks thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: movieman1111

Hey Sandeep fans, dont be complacent and please try voting for him to the extent you can, since he has still not won the title and last galas result mean nothing. Remember Vinit in SA re ga ma ..So keep voting for Sandeep and let him stand proudly in front of judges who doesnot want him to win.
And karu fans dont worry, sooner or later u will be Sandeep fans like me still loving Karunya.



Buddy....I really appreciate your love for sandy but please, try to restrain from posting such things that can (and will !!) create unnecessary confusions n debates over insignificant issues....ppl have right to express their views - I agree and I also respect your views as it is...but for the sake of 'peace' in the forum, plz dont say anything that might hurt fans of other contestants...except few handful ppl, karu fans are really nice and I want you to keep only this thing in mind that even sandy and karu's relations beyond II is now in limelight...so dont degrade anyone and dont do anything that might hurt ppl...we all are here to discuss n share ideas...not the grudges!!

hope you got the point same way as I said with all praise to your love for Sandy ...he has to rock on II stage and he did it.....now ppl are voting...dont feel they will stop...

FYI, its time that gets end when sandy fans stop voting....no complacency any time....take it from me....
once more, be a bit polite as your favorite he keeps his cool...even when things weren't meant for him in some of the galas...

and as usual.....

peace

Piscean thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#14
Thanks Checks....really appreciate your timely advice to a fellow Sandeep fan! 👏 And thanks for your compliment as well! We as Karu fans feel the same way about Sandeep fans so I hope we can continue healthy discussions without any personal attacks!
movieman1111 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: bsb-star

fair play to u, u got ur reasons- but at the end of the day i still stik wid karu to tick all the points you mentionned above!!


I know its ur own opinion and its not that i dont like Karunya but just cant digest the fact that he is god of singing (as it sounds from the judges mouth as if he has never gone off sur or sung dull )and also Sandeep being portayed as if he is only a bathroom singer.
Karunya can be classical maestro no doubt like legendary Suresh Wadker, but do you know in the movie fraternity he is beyond others. Thats why i see Sandeep as a better candidate of Indian Idol.
sreejan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: movieman1111


Frankly yes...If you want one on one comparison see it ..
1) Technical knowledge on singing : Karunya better
2) Voice : Sandeep better (Dont confuse it with singing)
3) Singing: Karunya better
4) Confidence: Sandeep better
5) Ability to improve (assuming Karunya is singing since the age of 4, and i still dont know since when Sandeep is singing, thanks to Sony for hiding that) : Sandeep
6) Stage Performance: Sandeep better
7) Playback singing ability and match : Sandeep better
and mind you i never went for Sandeeps smile or innocent and i dont believe Sandeep or Karunya anyone is innocent.



good analysis 👏👏....but i will have to disagree on some points ........

you yourself agree that karunya is better in singing ,technical knowledge......well isnt it the main thing in a singer to sing any kind of song ....don't music directors love to work with people who they dont have to struggle hard ?then i want to point out versatility which is very important for a performer ........and orijinality which makes you unique from others .....i think these things make Karunya very unique .😊

you know i always prefer mukesh saab than rafi ji singing .....many argue with me that rafiji had the best playback singing voice ....but then does it really matter when mukesh ji can create magic with his singing .....then its just the difference of what you like more ........again i am not comparing them to those greats......just trying to explain why people always go with conventinal voice quality ........and sandeep did not show any versatility .......he tries to bring uditji's flavour in every song ......i am sure as long as Udit ji is still there its going to be very tough for him to survive in music industry with just better performance .

then confidence .......i am sure sandeep has a good confidence level in his singing ........i have seen him on stage .......but dear so is Karunya ......i am always surprised by his confidence level .......even choosing difficult song when he can get popular by singing popular beats .....

what is stage performance ?????i am sure Sandeep has his own style of singing and i do like to see him perform ......but so does Karunya ........he impresses me with each performance of his ......like farah ji said i just don't want him to stop there ......its just a treat to to watch him .

thats just my 2 cents 😊😊😊
bsb-star thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: movieman1111


I know its ur own opinion and its not that i dont like Karunya but just cant digest the fact that he is god of singing (as it sounds from the judges mouth as if he has never gone off sur or sung dull )and also Sandeep being portayed as if he is only a bathroom singer.
Karunya can be classical maestro no doubt like legendary Suresh Wadker, but do you know in the movie fraternity he is beyond others. Thats why i see Sandeep as a better candidate of Indian Idol.

i dont think the judges think that karu is the god of singing, but are giving their opinion-sayin that karu deserves to win-they are tryin to do india a favour by givin them da best. they r there to give their opinion-its their job. simon cowell says wat he thinks too. i think he already in class where he compete wid people from the movie fraternity--again onli my opinion!!

checks thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Piscean

Thanks Checks....really appreciate your timely advice to a fellow Sandeep fan! 👏 And thanks for your compliment as well! We as Karu fans feel the same way about Sandeep fans so I hope we can continue healthy discussions without any personal attacks!


Sure, afterall, its not the end of the world for any of them, sandy or karu - as the saying goes, every failure is a learning experience and I hope n believe, they will take it as an experience to do far more better that what they have been doing so far....

and I wish fans on both side or also those who are supporting either sandy or karu will keep their cool for two three more days...once its out, its our Indian idol...be it Karu or Sandy....he may not be the loveliest person on the planet but for the whole year, he will be called as Indian Idol....and I wish them once agian, good luck...
and for fans on either side, plz, plz.....dont degrade others as that wont serve the purpose.....no way!!

peace
movieman1111 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#19
sreejan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: movieman1111


I know its ur own opinion and its not that i dont like Karunya but just cant digest the fact that he is god of singing (as it sounds from the judges mouth as if he has never gone off sur or sung dull )and also Sandeep being portayed as if he is only a bathroom singer.
Karunya can be classical maestro no doubt like legendary Suresh Wadker, but do you know in the movie fraternity he is beyond others. Thats why i see Sandeep as a better candidate of Indian Idol.



no my dear friend ......a person with good head on his shoulders would never call him a bathroom singer ....pls don't take some silly comments by some immature people .......i personally like some of his songs ......i just wish he had chosen diif kind of songs and shown versatility ......and shown his classical background by just choosing one classical song ........that should have done the trick ......see here not sandeep nor karunya is going to give us something back for backing them up ...........sandeep really need to work hard on his sur becasue he easily loses control of the song ........and to a trained ear its a biggest blunder for a singer .........karunya may have slipped once or twice as no one is perfect ......but he has shown more control over his sur and shown good control ........i am sure some young people who still have to learn a lot may make silly comments comparing him to greats or making him look like god .....but people take it to heart booooom they make another thread against him ........its a vicious cycle ........its just battle of ego......its not even about these contestants .😊😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".