Unfair Voting in Indian Idol 2

Hi All,

we have seen 3 episodes of piano round and I think the voting has been pretty unfair.

In my opinion....

In the first round, Ravi didn't deserve to be, rather Shitij should have been in

In the second one, I have no ides how Dilpreet was left out

In the third, they chose Panna...Huh..C'mon man. I think Anuj, Amey and Makkash were the top 3.

See all this, I think the pattern should be changed a bit and voting should be as

Judges - 30% and Janta 70%

What u say....

Cheers

well, yer da in da first 2 episodes of piano round i agree da votin woz unfair.. but cum on panna did sing well n so did anuj.. n y every1 against panna? y is no 1 against sandip.. i dont h8 him but jus sayin!

Well kshitij getting out was bad so was it in Dilpreet's case. Anuj also lost thanks to the public voting. But I think since many of us who live outside India, should also be given the right to vote. Amey surely didn't deserve to come third he performed the best that day if the public continues to vote like this we might lose out on some talented singers.

I THINK THE METHOD OF NACH BALIYE JUDGEMENT SHOULD BE PREFFERED IN II2 OR THE METHOD OF SAREGAMA.COZ JANTA IS TOTALY FALURE.JANTA IS GOOD IN POLITICAL SELECTION BUT NOT IN SUR TAAL.JISKO HERO HEROIN MAFIK LAGTA HEY USEY VOTE DETA HEY..................CHEHRE PE FIDAAAAAAA AUR SUR KO ALVIDAAAAAAA........YEAI KYA BAAT HUIEE.....BAAP RE BAAP.......SALAM INDIA SALAM JANTA..

Originally posted by: Ahmed143

Hi All,

we have seen 3 episodes of piano round and I think the voting has been pretty unfair.

In my opinion....

In the first round, Ravi didn't deserve to be, rather Shitij should have been in

In the second one, I have no ides how Dilpreet was left out

In the third, they chose Panna...Huh..C'mon man. I think Anuj, Amey and Makkash were the top 3.

See all this, I think the pattern should be changed a bit and voting should be as

Judges - 30% and Janta 70%

What u say....

Cheers

Oh i totally agree with you as far as panna is concerened. Nothing personal against him or anything but i am sure even he knows heart to theart that he got votes for his looks not for his voice. (not that i would have voted for him for his looks either)

They should def make an exception and conduct another round for Kshitij, Dilpreet, Anuj and Nakkash. Lets see who the "sensible" audience votes out next week. I am sure there will be atleast one contestant who will be excluded based on looks rather than voice.

I really wish they had allowed voting on the internet as well. We get to see the first round in time to vote as well so why should we be left out? No fair 😕

Ya voting is really unfair in Indian Idol.But it was not this bad in Idol-I.Wat has happ 2 the audience.The voting in Idol is now very much like FG.Thts a real pity coz we want a singer as our Idol and not a showman like Qazi!!!!!

i guess the only X-FACTOR-free singing show is also becoming X-FACTOR centered.... 😕

One could really see and sense the frustration looking at the judges how dissapointed they were with the outcome of the last episode. If you really observe Panna you can tell that he was kind of embarassed to be chosen since all the judges had not predicted him to be part of the final 3. He knew he made it because probably many of the girls fnd him to be very cute. But hobestly he sings strictly OK. As far as singing is concerned i feel Nakkash and Javed sang far far better than him and ofcoure then there is no comparison to Anuj. Poor Poor Anuj 😕 It was heart breaking to see him sob. And he was not doing it because of losing i am sure, he was sobbing because he knew he desreved to be among the 3 winners. 😕 I hope the audience WAKES UP.

Originally posted by: Niceup

I THINK THE METHOD OF NACH BALIYE JUDGEMENT SHOULD BE PREFFERED IN II2 OR THE METHOD OF SAREGAMA.COZ JANTA IS TOTALY FALURE.JANTA IS GOOD IN POLITICAL SELECTION BUT NOT IN SUR TAAL.JISKO HERO HEROIN MAFIK LAGTA HEY USEY VOTE DETA HEY..................CHEHRE PE FIDAAAAAAA AUR SUR KO ALVIDAAAAAAA........YEAI KYA BAAT HUIEE.....BAAP RE BAAP.......SALAM INDIA SALAM JANTA..

Agree with u 100%

I totally agree that the voting system is truly unfair. Judges should have at least some %age of say in this issue. It shouldn't totally be left upto Junta Janardan. And also, how woulda few lac votes be representative of the entire Indian population? We could have few minorities being completely voted out due to personal favouritism. Ad I also agree about the fact that audience votes could be prejudiced based upon a person's looks/personality rather than voice quality.