scinerd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
I just want to give a huge round of applause to the top 5! 👏. They all are amazing singers,unique and it will be a huge loss if any of them go. Coming into the top 5 swaroop and bhoomi we're weaker, both amazing at the start but got lost in the middle. But after last weeks stuff and the preveiw of this weeks they are back! Shivam, sreeram and rakesh are great as usual. In the promo of next week all of them sang great. Swaroop, from the preview sang the disco song great! I think it was sulaman that gave him his confidence back.

Indian Idol 5 top 5 you rock! ⭐️

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

412

Users

2

Frequent Posters

mintyblue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
It is not ideal top 5...unlike saregama where usually the best singers come in top 5.I like Sreeram and Swaroop in top 5, both have capacity to do something really good in terms of playback, potential as singers. The other 3 have their share of fans that's why they are here, they all ahve good qualities, they might do well in stage shows but nothing extra-special about them in my humble opinion.
For me top 5 would ahve been Sreeram, Shashi, Swaroop, Vishwas, meghna/ Arpita, but I wish the current top 5 all the best.
scinerd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: mintyblue

It is not ideal top 5...unlike saregama where usually the best singers come in top 5.I like Sreeram and Swaroop in top 5, both have capacity to do something really good in terms of playback, potential as singers. The other 3 have their share of fans that's why they are here, they all ahve good qualities, they might do well in stage shows but nothing extra-special about them in my humble opinion.

For me top 5 would ahve been Sreeram, Shashi, Swaroop, Vishwas, meghna/ Arpita, but I wish the current top 5 all the best.



yah saregamapa does have the best singers and i respect your opinion. but I think this top 5 they all are differnt singers. It's more pleasant to the eat, than having singers that all sing in the same genre.
mintyblue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
^^^Its not about genre. Sreeram, Shashi are very versatile singers who can sing all kinds of songs. I would prefer Shashi in top 2 than Rakesh not only because Shahsi is technically far better than Rakesh but also because he can sing all kinds of songs.
Singing is about techniclaity first. if 2 singers are of the same level techncailly then we can go ahead n have subjectivity like feel, versatility etc. Technically I found 5 singers very good--
1. Sreeram - He is obviously the best
2. Shashi - He could guve good com to Sreeram
3. Vishwaas- From what i heard of him he was a singer in control, he had the range and could sing Sukhwinder's and shaan's song with ease.
4. Naushad / Arpita/ Swaroop/ Meghna- All are technically good, Naushad could not deliver. But all of them had something different about them as well,
I would arther hear a technically good and versatile / non- versatile singer than a technciaslly mediocre one like Bhoomi/ Shivam.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".