this is not fair...

hey guyz. there is no doubt that indian idol is a great chance for ppl. 2 show their talent but don't u guyz think that sonu, anu malik, and farah are kinda rude and insulting ppl. they r making fun of their singing. i feel soo bad 4 the people who r being insulted😭😭. does anyone agree wid me? plz post ur comments!!

i agree!! they are very rude to a lot of ppl this time! and some of the ppl that
they are rude to are not even that bad!

yea i think they are rude too especially in the mumbai audition the guy who asked for a second chance and then his mom came too was not that bad in my opinion...but we have to understand that the judges have to sit there and listen to about 100,000 ppl audition out of which maybe 100 is good...but still it's rude sometimes

They are just trying to be like the 1st one American Idol so they need to get attitude (Simon) But yes whatever they show on T.V. is usually off them being rude

I agree sometimes they are just obnoxious. With their new and different ways of disagreeing and saying no. I hated it yesterday how they mocked the person who sanfg Aahiq bannaya . It was bad no doubt but to make him sing so they could have a laugh was not required.

Originally posted by: desimundha7

They are just trying to be like the 1st one American Idol so they need to get attitude (Simon) But yes whatever they show on T.V. is usually off them being rude

yup, compare to AMERICAN IDOL our ANU is SIMON COWELL.........................😆

DID U GUYS SEE THAT GUY WHO SANG ASHIQUE BANAYA AAPNE HE WAS FUNNY

yup we at home singing the same way whole day 😆 😆

I think you also need to look at the fact that these judges have to listen to thousands of people in a day. Some of these people were really bad, even while watching some of the performances on TV you can barely stop yourself from laughing. It is hilarious. To laugh is a spontaneous reaction .Yes, I agree that they did mock a few not so bad ones which was uncalled for but that is probably more for the sake of the TV viewers to increase the TRPs( the long red haired guy and Jigar Kapadia and that young kid who sang some old song were not bad). Some of the situations are quite funny to the viewer and if a person is really that bad they shouln't be trying out in the first place. Some of them were not even good enough to be bathroom singers - forget Indian Idol. The first round elimination was pretty easy for the judges.
Why doesn't Sony do a preelimination of the contestants prior to showing on TV ? What is the criteria for being a participant? Anybody can go ? Is there an application fee?

hi tina.i tottaly agree with u.they(judges)really insult the people.by the way that ashiq banaya apna was really very funny. 👏 thx ,by😊