.vineeta. thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Last week till end waited for story usually Gul start it parallel with her ott characters. Girl sweet and sour who is strong with some sad BG and guy pure jerk, but with some conscience. He don't like mango but isn't there better way to say no, and really what's your problem? You have no compassion for your workers or way to motivate them, such self obsessed person.

So far I just saw guy extra jerk with bit softness to mom, but really who loves such guys? We all hate mummas boys and girl, I can't place at all. One day she was crying and angry over factory demolition n when done she had no reaction literally, was it because now she had job? Then giving piece to sister on her speech to show strength in character, then there was crying n too much will miss you scene but very second later she was having fun, she was way over chirpy:( the whole airport scene didn't gel with her character if she is later shown as mature one right now she is behaving like teenager with active harmone.

I am waiting for story, have been disappointed with characterization, and Shivya need to buck up. In this industry looks and talent are needed, she is very ordinary looking so have to sharpen her acting fast to keep viewers with her, today she was disappointment

I love Gul, she has knack on creating love story but her writers need to buck up.

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.8k

Users

11

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

Ecrivain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#2


I guess the show n the characters will take a lil more time to develop 😳
.vineeta. thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: ecrivain




I guess the show n the characters will take a lil more time to develop😳


Maybe expecting too much but really didn't see any emotions in a girl who cares for family and leaving them for the first time and it's not for few days. Lead character should have if nothing but consistency I think
Skankipati thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
I agree with you on every single point. She couldnt express her grief over factory burn down well neither did she handle her emotions during airport departure scene. I am having a tough time seeing a new comer with lot to work on her acting skills after seeing ace of actresses be it in prior Gul stories or other serials. I am sure hoping she picks it up soon. At this point she knows nothing but to give a open grin. Her acting skills are sure killing the character portrayal.
Lets hope that Gul will bring the best out of her soon.

-Su
Nrp77 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: .vineeta.

Last week till end waited for story usually Gul start it parallel with her ott characters. Girl sweet and sour who is strong with some sad BG and guy pure jerk, but with some conscience. He don't like mango but isn't there better way to say no, and really what's your problem? You have no compassion for your workers or way to motivate them, such self obsessed person.

So far I just saw guy extra jerk with bit softness to mom, but really who loves such guys? We all hate mummas boys and girl, I can't place at all. One day she was crying and angry over factory demolition n when done she had no reaction literally, was it because now she had job? Then giving piece to sister on her speech to show strength in character, then there was crying n too much will miss you scene but very second later she was having fun, she was way over chirpy:( the whole airport scene didn't gel with her character if she is later shown as mature one right now she is behaving like teenager with active harmone.

I am waiting for story, have been disappointed with characterization, and Shivya need to buck up. In this industry looks and talent are needed, she is very ordinary looking so have to sharpen her acting fast to keep viewers with her, today she was disappointment


I love Gul, she has knack on creating love story but her writers need to buck up.

So glad someone else felt this way as well! Maybe after watching IPKKNDn having loved Sanaya's acting so much, this actress just falls flat! I'm trying, but I'm just not feelin' her! She doesn't evoke any emotion in me, but annoyance. Feel bad for saying this, but it's the truth! I'm still hoping she grows on me! Also, Allah knows needs to go! 😕

Looks like there is going to be a lot more drama and characters in this one! Only time will tell if this one will be as appealing as Iss Pyar Ko Kya Naam Doon was...
Deshian4lyf thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
This is really sad but really true! But then again lets give her some time guys :D
664269 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
lets cut Shivya some slack plss.. she is a newbie in the platform, and her work is decent, it isnt mediciore from any level. she has debuted in this show unlike sanaya in IPK, or with whomever she is being compared to, because other actresses had a good body of work unlike hers.
Moreover, whoever is frustated that Gul has recycled IPK or QH and made Humsafars, plss stop whining, because there are ppl who are liking the show and most of us have never watched a Gul khan show, so its a first time for us. none of the hindi shows made in today's world are original, most of them are recycled, so there shouldnt be any issue.. if Humsafars is adpated from IPK and QH, then the latter shows were also adapted from geet , its not that now we will watch Humsafars only to dig out what is copied and what is not. its better to ignore if its disappointing.
Edited by harshu.sundas - 11 years ago
VandyP thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
the factory was never aarzoo's dream right???
she was worried abt the factory coz its where her mom worked...its from where they got their bread n butter

and as far as aarzoo handling her emotions r concerned...mumbai is her dream...she is abt to fulfil her biggest dream...plus with an extra responsibility of being the bread winner of the house...u don't really have time to think abt ur emotions


and shivya is a new comer...we need to give her time
Nrp77 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: harshu.sundas

lets cut Shivya some slcak plss.. she is a newbie in the platform, and her work is decent, it isnt mediciore from any level. she has debuted in this show unlike sanaya in IPK, or with whomever she is being compared to, because other actresses had a good body of work unlike hers.

Moreover, whoever is frustated that Gul has recycled IPK or QH and made Humsafars, plss stop whining, because there are ppl who are liking the show and most of us have never watched a Gul khan show, so its a first time for us. none of the hindi shows made in today's world are original, most of them are recycled, so there shouldnt be any issue.. if Humsafars is adpated from IPK and QH, then the latter shows were also adapted from geet , its not that now we will watch Humsafars only to dig out what is copied and what is not. its better to ignore if its disappointing.


I'm almost positive that you posted on the wrong thread b/c I don't see a single person here whining about this show being a recycled version of IPK or QH!
...luci... thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Thanks n well said sundas n vandy no comparison wd any serial or actress

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".