'HD':in the making of 'Kabhi Alvida Na Kahana'

Earnshaw09 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
"Hitler Didi" seems to be in the making of the movie,"Kabhi Alvida Naa Kahana",where two married people fall in love and go against everyone to choose the path of their hearts.What doesn't make sense is:why is Illa Bedi every time picking the plots of her story from one or the other movie?As I see it,it is absolutely unnecessary to go in the process of complicating the story so much.Although illogical,that the protagonist is shown dead at one point of the story,and coming back with a new identity at another;this crisis can be solved with simply unfolding the mystery,whether Zara is Indira.The script-writer has absolutely lost track of the story,making it confusing for the audience.If Zara is Indira,which we'll are sure she is,than why drag this suspense so long?

As we'll have seen from the beginning,both Indira and Rishi are strong characters,who are not only loyal to one another,but also to all other relations they have.Rishi,who has been a one-woman-man,loving Indira with all his heart,is suddenly shown to flirt with a married woman.If he believes that Zara is none other than Indira,than the first thing that calls our attention to the story is that,he should dig deeper into Zara's past;the co-incidence that eight years back when he had lost Indira,Zara also met an accident and lost her memory.And Zara on the other hand,should also question her strange connection with Indu and Rishi that she feels.I bet we'll want Indira,alias Zara and Rishi to be together,but not this way,making a wrong image of relationships.Besides,Zara and Shweta fighting over Indu would look more logical and right only when the mystery is unmasked,that Zara is Indira.Otherwise the story of "HD" seems to be heading towards the genre of domestic drama,with two married people practicing adultery,and two women having cat-fight.Seriously,never thought such a simple and good story would go this way.Its disappointing.

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

655

Users

5

Likes

17

Frequent Posters

rajh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Earnshaw

"Hitler Didi" seems to be in the making of the movie,"Kabhi Alvida Naa Kahana",where two married people fall in love and go against everyone to choose the path of their hearts.What doesn't make sense is:why is Illa Bedi every time picking the plots of her story from one or the other movie?As I see it,it is absolutely unnecessary to go in the process of complicating the story so much.Although illogical,that the protagonist is shown dead at one point of the story,and coming back with a new identity at another;this crisis can be solved with simply unfolding the mystery,whether Zara is Indira.The script-writer has absolutely lost track of the story,making it confusing for the audience.If Zara is Indira,which we'll are sure she is,than why drag this suspense so long?

As we'll have seen from the beginning,both Indira and Rishi are strong characters,who are not only loyal to one another,but also to all other relations they have.Rishi,who has been a one-woman-man,loving Indira with all his heart,is suddenly shown to flirt with a married woman.If he believes that Zara is none other than Indira,than the first thing that calls our attention to the story is that,he should dig deeper into Zara's past;the co-incidence that eight years back when he had lost Indira,Zara also met an accident and lost her memory.And Zara on the other hand,should also question her strange connection with Indu and Rishi that she feels.I bet we'll want Indira,alias Zara and Rishi to be together,but not this way,making a wrong image of relationships.Besides,Zara and Shweta fighting over Indu would look more logical and right only when the mystery is unmasked,that Zara is Indira.Otherwise the story of "HD" seems to be heading towards the genre of domestic drama,with two married people practicing adultery,and two women having cat-fight.Seriously,never thought such a simple and good story would go this way.Its disappointing.




mostly cvs will tell in the end that zara is not indira.
and most probably we need to accept zara and rishi as pair.

well i dont have any problem with this story if cvs move fast and start divorce of zara [or malik killed in encounter] and rishi divorcing swetha immediately.
Edited by 100raj - 12 years ago
PD_forums thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
agree with you HD is promoting adultery

Rishi and Zara are behaving like teenagers but not as matured people..

i think leap kaa baad CVs brain took backward leap so they are behaving in this vulgar way🤢

who will give respect to such leads 😡
Edited by preethimadhavg - 12 years ago
iSakshi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
🤢

Originally posted by: preethimadhavg

agree with you HD is promoting adultery


Rishi and Zara are behaving like teenagers but not as matured people..

i think leap kaa baad CVs brain took backward leap so they are behaving in this vulgar way🤢

who will give respect to such leads 😡


I would never support this kinda🤢 eek!!! whats wrong with these CV's

their so "called" love just makes me wanna🤢
Edited by xXHoNeYb3aRrXx - 12 years ago
-Paulomi- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: xXHoNeYb3aRrXx

🤢


I would never support this kinda🤢 eek!!! whats wrong with these CV's

their so "called" love just makes me wanna🤢


Exactly,if u had to bring Indira/Zara back,then why did u kill her?

The biggest blunder done by the cvs is to bring that DNA report thing so early

They are now leaving every fact in a half way.They are not completing any track.

Eg 1)terrorism track for which zara came
2)what happened with Zara 8 yrs ago and what about her ML

I dont know whether u people will agree with me or not,but the story was far far far better before the leap at least there was a beautiful friendship between Rishi and Shweta.Just to bring a crap leap,they have destroyed a friendship.

If cvs have decided to make Shweta negative then I just hope they don't make any blunder which they made with Sameer

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".