SIRIUS BLACK...did he have to die

DO u think Sirius really had to die.....? I cant forgive JK Rowling for that.

i was in tears when i read about it......what do you guys think??? 😭

And u know what...i think she may kill Remus Lupin too!!!

And that wud be tooooooooooo much for Harry!!!

I miss Sirius....sob!

yeah , i miss sirius too . by the time , i had finishes reading ootp , i was crying and crying😭

i hope he comes back as a ghost........😭

Originally posted by: misha

yeah , i miss sirius too . by the time , i had finishes reading ootp , i was crying and crying😭

i hope he comes back as a ghost........😭

I agree with every one. I was so SAD when i was read Sirius is killed......it was miserable. This is the only reason why i dont like the 5th book!😡

I was shocked and depressed that Sirius died, but (dont hit me now) IMHO his death was very important and a required part of the story.

Think about it. Harry lost his parents to Voldemort. Then he loses his guardian. Who's responsible? Technically Bellatrix Black, but overall its Voldemort. These deaths are a justification Harry to take the step to destroy Voldemort and the death eaters.

I dont like it when my favourite characters die, but I give props to JKR who has the guts to reveal that life is not a fairy-tale even in a world of fantasy. 👏

Hey Mystica......I do feel like hitting you.....nah just kidding...

but just think, sirius was all that harry had in the world....a friend, brother, father like and everything......he could have stayed on......

poor harry left all alone......come to think of it.......Sirius was an excellent person......sad that he died ....sob!

Its true, Sirius didn't have to die...but he did. Shows how much is beyond our control... 😭 Honey, you are making me depressed all over again, yaar! I miss Sirius too!

But, in a way, Sirius' death will make Harry stronger and prepare him to face the worst in life.

I doubt it that Sirius will come back as a ghost...as Nearly Headless Nick said, he has moved on.