snape n lilly

goth princess wrote: welcome, listen to my theory snape loved lily, but hated james. he told voldy about the prophecy but asked him not to kill lily, wen voldy killed lily, he felt guilty and went over to the good side...now he hates harry cos he is james's son, but tries to help him, because lily stuck up for him, wen he needed help (book 5) so he feels he should help harry. if u need it in anymore detail, just ask 😃

i need some detail

i dont no wat ur talkin abt N......

how cud SNAPE LIKE LILLY????

N IF HARRY WAS DA SON OF JAMES N LILLY HE STILL HARRY DA LOOKS OF JAMES I MEAN SHUDNT HE HATE HARRY N NOT HELP HARRY COZ LILLY CHOSE JAMES OVER HIM????

N IS THERE ANY SIGN THT HE LOVED LILLY?????

N IF YES IS JKR GOING 2 TELL US THT IN DA 7TH BOOK W/ OTHER MYSTERIES NEED 2 BE SLOVED OR R WE 2 PREDICTED THT???

HOW CUD IT BE POSSIBLE???

I HV MORE Q? ILL TYPE LATER!!!!

this is going over my head....

OK so Snape loved lily rite thatz what you mean... that why he called her a Filthy Mudblood didn't he?

oh common you trying to find logic in trash.

regards,

tejas

Originally posted by: albusdumbledore

this is going over my head....

OK so Snape loved lily rite thatz what you mean... that why he called her a Filthy Mudblood didn't he?

oh common you trying to find logic in trash.

regards,

tejas

this is exactly..i wanted to say after reading the post.

i didnt understand a thing

yeah same reply from here.......snape called lily as mudblood

snape is a double agent no doubt...n that's y he's helping both sides...i dont think the lily-james-snape luv triangle theory works at all!!

Originally posted by: albusdumbledore

this is going over my head....

OK so Snape loved lily rite thatz what you mean... that why he called her a Filthy Mudblood didn't he?

oh common you trying to find logic in trash.

regards,

tejas

lol...

the logic used here... is the same many use for draco/hermione u kno...

as many pple write draco/hermione fanfics... using the logic that draco loves hermione but calls her names to hide his feelings... tht logic...

but yeah i do agree thts not the thing here.... as v already know the reason y snape hates harry [coz of james(james being one of the marauders is a reason enuff-but well v get a peek on how he treated snape in the fifth book)specially the incident after the OWL exam] and why snape saves harry [coz of james again(this v come to kno by the shriekin shack incident)james had saved snapes life so its like unwillingly snapes feels he owes ALOT to james)

Originally posted by: albusdumbledore

this is going over my head....

OK so Snape loved lily rite thatz what you mean... that why he called her a Filthy Mudblood didn't he?

oh common you trying to find logic in trash.

regards,

tejas

yo dis isnt my theory!!!😳