Nandini Updated: Book Bazaar to Chole Bhature :( - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.6k

Users

11

Likes

30

Frequent Posters

-honeydew- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: skg267

So in yesterday's episode we had to tolerate a lot of Devini, which we did, being the loyal fans that we are, but I just want to say, why does it have to be this bad? I mean I know it is hard to measure up to the characters and chemistry of Maan and Geet but even Dev has a pretty complex character and they could have really done a lot with that. Introducing Nandini as his love interest was not the worst idea from day one, but they have not built up a character and sometimes it feels like she is just a prop on the set.at times i feel they deliberately under play other characters to up Maan and Geet ... and yes when the track was brought in i had many expectations .. right from them bonding over playing cupids to Maan and Geet, to Nandu actually falling for Dev only to realise he cant love her back owing to his past... i somehow have looked at Sameer as someone who can portray many shades of Dev .. and was thoroughly disappointed ... however, Nandini's track started really well, but went on to become the run of the mill trip and fall, look into my eyes, nok-jhok romance ... 😕

Even though in the Amritsar track, the story did not seem to be very well thought out, most of the characters were well-developed and interesting. Even Lucky, who seemed to be there initially just for comedy got great character depth and Ahwaan executed this really well. Now we all like his character because we know him, and we know his story. Nandini, despite having a storyline revolve around her, got nothing. We still know nothing about her as a person, only that Dev is in love with her and now apparently she loves him too.The other day when they even mentioned for a second she wanted to pursue her PHD i was thrilled.. then i laughed .. she calls Geet didi, and Geet is all of 19, yeh ladki itni choti si umar main kounsi PhD karlegi .. however, though my dreams of wanting Geet to continue her studies are long shattered, i would love to see this happen with Dev ...😳 he can educate her and then they call fall in love 😛

Her entry was actually really cute with the rainbow umbrella, the nose buried in her book, and her natural disdain for men. I would love for them to build on her character as a something of a bookworm, which they refer to occasionally with the PhD and her always having to go to the bazaar to get books but I want her not just to say it but for it to be shown in her personality. Also, she was really sassy at first and now she just laughs at everything. To me, she started out with a lot of potential as a character and interesting love-interest for Dev but they have left her so flat as a character which is irritating because Dev's character is so loaded with history. there is no doubt they need to work on her character .. and give her more depth !!! m sure they knew why they got Melanie when they introduced Nandu...she was after a lead on an Imagine show ... i am sure they can still work on it .. they face still resistance from non Dev likers .. which is why this is happening in ll probability ...

I completely understand that the CVs have to have supporting tracks and am completely open to liking Dev and Nandini if only they would give her a character outside of being Dev's love interest. They have plenty of opportunity with her working in the office now so I reaaally hope they do this! Of course we want only Maneet but if they execute other tracks with a little more thought we might not feel that we are missing anything when they are not showing Maan and/or Geet.

Some things they could elaborate on:
What was Nandini studying when she was away from Amritsar? What would she want to do her PhD in?
Why does she doubt men in general? -i was hoping they would explore this .. she has two brothers has always been protected, she could have been a tom boy par she is girlie yet has a mind of her own !! why dont they show her using her mind ..??😲
What books does she keep reading?
Her relationships with characters other than Dev. Maybe she could have a cute friendship with Adi and/or Pinky i hope they build this and show how they become Geets pillar of support and how she helps Geet and learns certain things in the process as well.. also these people can become cupids and try and bring dev and nandu together since both of them cant muster courage to confess their feelings for one another .. ala . mera dil bhi kitna pagal hai yeh pyar toh tumse karta hai .. jab saamne jab tum aate ho.. kuch bhi kehne se darta hai .. oh mere saajan ... i woul love to also see a parallel song sequence between Maaneet and Devini ... do dil mil rahey .. types ...
She could be shown to know a lot of arbitrary facts, illustrating all that reading she seems to always be doing. she could want to be a writer .. Dev could encourage her .. she could read out to him... their thoughts could connect them ...!!! he could become her inspiration, the way he loves his family, the way he cares for his bro, the way he works and the way he treats Nandu .. can all be instrumental.. then imagine one fine morning she realises, he has hidden such a huge thing from her .. how would she cope with it then?will she still love him the same way? or would she fight it?

Like I said, I see so much potential!!! Do you agree with me? Can Dev-Nandini become more interesting?

they can !! for sure, only if the audience give them a chance .. and dont close their eyes and shut their ears at the mention of Devini ...

thanks for writing this... i always enjoy replying to you !!
Disclaimer: Not bashing, constructive criticism. 😊

Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#12
Thanks for your lovely responses which are always a pleasure to read! And sorry for the late reply...but just a few things

QUOTE=-honeydew-]

Originally posted by: skg267



at times i feel they deliberately under play other characters to up Maan and Geet ... and yes when the track was brought in i had many expectations .. right from them bonding over playing cupids to Maan and Geet, to Nandu actually falling for Dev only to realise he cant love her back owing to his past... i somehow have looked at Sameer as someone who can portray many shades of Dev .. and was thoroughly disappointed ... however, Nandini's track started really well, but went on to become the run of the mill trip and fall, look into my eyes, nok-jhok romance ... 😕
Believe it or not, I actually imagined the same situation with her falling for him first and him being reluctant due to his checkered past but alas, instead we got an ultra-lame version of Maan and Geet (snobby rich boy falls for educated, but traditional girl). I actually liked Nandini when she was a meddlesome, sassy overconfident baby sister of two macho older brothers but they flattened her out after the first mahaepisode 😒

.
The other day when they even mentioned for a second she wanted to pursue her PHD i was thrilled.. then i laughed .. she calls Geet didi, and Geet is all of 19, yeh ladki itni choti si umar main kounsi PhD karlegi .. however, though my dreams of wanting Geet to continue her studies are long shattered, i would love to see this happen with Dev ...😳 he can educate her and then they call fall in love 😛
Argh! This is so frustrating! I wanted this too but yesterday they even took the little bit of character she had away...from book bazaar to chole bhature, lame. Them going to the book bazaar could have revealed something about her character, but no
instead we get the same, tired concept of Dev eating channa bhatura and"learning to live life" the desi way, balle ba-*YAWN*. She doesn't even seem to be going to the office now so she is only ever going to talk to Dev? Ick.

there is no doubt they need to work on her character .. and give her more depth !!! m sure they knew why they got Melanie when they introduced Nandu...she was after a lead on an Imagine show ... i am sure they can still work on it .. they face still resistance from non Dev likers .. which is why this is happening in ll probability ... The thing is, though that if she had a character of her own, people would like HER, with or without Dev in the picture. Meera was in love with Dev but that didn't stop us liking her, even though Dev was even more unlikable back then. I feel that that is because she had a character, we knew her career, her history with Dev, she was on good terms with Maan, had philosophical chats with Geet. Her interactions weren't limited to Dev and her character wasn't limited to Dev. Also, it helped that she knew his past. Go to the book bazaar, Nano and tell us what you are reading!


Some things they could elaborate on:
What was Nandini studying when she was away from Amritsar? What would she want to do her PhD in?
Why does she doubt men in general? -i was hoping they would explore this .. she has two brothers has always been protected, she could have been a tom boy par she is girlie yet has a mind of her own !! why dont they show her using her mind ..??😲
👍🏼
I totally got this impression when they first introduced her and that is what led to her overconfidence in judging Dev, meddling in Geet's business (telling everyone that Dev was Maan). I KNOW, they really don't show her thinking at all! That is why I feel like sometimes she is an inanimate prop on the sets.
I

YI
What books does she keep reading?
Her relationships with characters other than Dev. Maybe she could have a cute friendship with Adi and/or Pinky i hope they build this and show how they become Geets pillar of support and how she helps Geet and learns certain things in the process as well.. also these people can become cupids and try and bring dev and nandu together since both of them cant muster courage to confess their feelings for one another .. ala . mera dil bhi kitna pagal hai yeh pyar toh tumse karta hai .. jab saamne jab tum aate ho.. kuch bhi kehne se darta hai .. oh mere saajan ... i woul love to also see a parallel song sequence between Maaneet and Devini ... do dil mil rahey .. types ...
I love your hypothetical situations! Yes, this could be very cute and maybe making their relationship more related to other characters. Right now it is so disjointed from the rest of the story. WHY is Nandini touring Delhi, of all things, at time like this?

. she could want to be a writer .. Dev could encourage her .. she could read out to him... their thoughts could connect them ...!!! he could become her inspiration, the way he loves his family, the way he cares for his bro, the way he works and the way he treats Nandu .. can all be instrumental.. then imagine one fine morning she realises, he has hidden such a huge thing from her .. how would she cope with it then?will she still love him the same way? or would she fight it?
CUTE, CUTE, CUTE! And interesting. Maybe they are saving his past to create drama later?


thanks for writing this... i always enjoy replying to you !!
Likewise! and thank you for your reply!

Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#13
First fab topic.. n hats off to u to have the courage to talk on a character thats looked down upon with disdain among the fans.. thanks to Dev..!!
I agree.. her character was introed wit a lot of chutzpah.. but suddenly it all went amiss when her engagement track began..! CVs are showing MSK having ML.. i believe they are having ML... for totally forgetting n shunning Devs murky past...!!
I feel bad for the actress playing Nandini coz honestly she is 1000% times better then Nikunj ... yet Nikunjs character was getting more focus.. back then.. ! Hope the CVs can utilise her character better then just making it look like a add on.. or a prop as u put it..!!
BeastInCarnage thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#14
Past two weeks ? I came after a month in this forum.
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

First fab topic.. n hats off to u to have the courage to talk on a character thats looked down upon with disdain among the fans.. thanks to Dev..!!

I agree.. her character was introed wit a lot of chutzpah.. but suddenly it all went amiss when her engagement track began..! CVs are showing MSK having ML.. i believe they are having ML... for totally forgetting n shunning Devs murky past...!!
I feel bad for the actress playing Nandini coz honestly she is 1000% times better then Nikunj ... yet Nikunjs character was getting more focus.. back then.. ! Hope the CVs can utilise her character better then just making it look like a add on.. or a prop as u put it..!!



Thank you! I have to admit, I was pretty worried that this would become one of those posts that disappeared into oblivion with no likes or responses but with the flurry of rumours dying down and the general excitement about the new track I feel like the forum is once again open to small doses of constructive criticism, without it being immediately dismissed as bashing. So thank you for replying!

Yup, the flair and personality of Nandini died for me in the first mahaepisode, funnily enough right about the time she stopped hating Dev. And her attitude towards Daman was frankly quite jellyfish-like. I expected her to be more audacious, as she was when they first introduced her. She is the baby sister of two very macho brothers and the daughter of the woman who seems to run the village so why on earth would she turn so docile and shy all of a sudden? I actually hope the ML serves to recall Dev's story so she can hear it, maybe after they have already confessed their mutual feelings so there is an additional element of drama!

I honestly think they are shortchanging Melanie Pais, as well. Anvesha had such a more interesting character and got to be seen as a career-woman who was good at what she did, owned a business and worked hard for it. I am even more disappointed about Nandini after yesterday but hopefully the CVs will have an epiphany soon and give us some more personality and non-Dev-related Nandini moments!

Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Assassinator

Past two weeks ? I came after a month in this forum.



Oh that explains a lot although I am still not sure why you chose to bring this up in this topic. Geet fell to no. 2 two weeks ago and hasn't been updated since. It has been pretty frustrating for all of us.
eminent thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#17

What a great post! You know what I was too busy hating the fact that Dev will have a love interest soon in the show- that I didn't pay much attention to Nandini's entry. But you're right her entry was quite cute! It kind of reminded me of Belle's entry from Beauty and the Beast...how ironic! 😆

True that they can't come close to Maaneet's chemistry, but you're right their love angle can be presented differently, & as you said - in small doses! (Even though I preferred Meera with Dev-But that's over and done with! )...

& You're right- Dev's character is definitely complex, in fact I think it's more complex than any other character in this show. He's gone from being Good, to [naively] evil, & to good again. He's picked up variant shades from different parts of his life. Having said that, if they're going to continue with Devini track, than I think Nandini's characterization should be sober-to balance perhaps?... But yes, there should be more depth to her character, or else she'll just start looking like a doll in the corner.

I really like your ideas, hope CVs implement them into the story line!

~Emi




eminent thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#18
Addition:
Oh- sober not just for balance purpose, but I don't want it to overshadow Geet's character!
😃
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: eminent


What a great post! You know what I was too busy hating the fact that Dev will have a love interest soon in the show- that I didn't pay much attention to Nandini's entry. But you're right her entry was quite cute! It kind of reminded me of Belle's entry from Beauty and the Beast...how ironic! 😆

True that they can't come close to Maaneet's chemistry, but you're right their love angle can be presented differently, & as you said - in small doses! (Even though I preferred Meera with Dev-But that's over and done with! )...

& You're right- Dev's character is definitely complex, in fact I think it's more complex than any other character in this show. He's gone from being Good, to [naively] evil, & to good again. He's picked up variant shades from different parts of his life. Having said that, if they're going to continue with Devini track, than I think Nandini's characterization should be sober-to balance perhaps?... But yes, there should be more depth to her character, or else she'll just start looking like a doll in the corner.

I really like your ideas, hope CVs implement them into the story line!

~Emi






It was like Belle (my favorite Disney girl) and strangely enough reminded me of...me! I am always wandering about with my nose buried in a book and their are piles of books everywhere I go (yes, even in the bathroom). Also, I love rainbows and happen to own and love that very same umbrella that she was carrying. As soon as she entered, I felt wow, I am going to love this character and then I didn't because really, what's there to love?

Of course I would never want anybody to overshadow the leads! If I could have it my way, the entire 20 minutes would be just them but since it can't I thought I would raise the topic of how the CVs can make the side tracks more bearable so we don't feel the difference so much. Part of the problem with Dev/Nandini is that both of them are so disjointed from what is going on with everyone else. WHY isn't she at the office like she was supposed to be?? And why isn't DEV at the office helping his infirm brother?? GOD! I loved Dev and Meera too. She was a good balance to his character, unshakably loyal and secure but alas, it wasn't to be!

I agree that as a romantic interest for Dev, Nandini should be shown as somebody sensible and with a head on her shoulders. Dev is very much a follower and not a leader and he needs a strong person to keep steering him in the right direction. I am really hoping for some insight into Nandini because I want to like her but don't know what to like.

Thanks so much for your reply and your great ideas!

Edited by skg267 - 14 years ago
leverne thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#20
i wrote a lot but power got cut and i lost ma entire post but i'l summarize it as i loved the topic...
@ TM...its very interesting to talk abt the way the character of nandini has been developed...i agree with many of you but the fact remains that she is one person whom cvs look upon as a backup to make up for the absence of the leads and its sad to see that...devil should not sit and think of ways to ask her out instead they should work in office and let poor MSK who has just been through an accident rest...plus nandini instead of supporting her sister and feeling bad or worried for her wants to go out on Delhi tour makes no sense at all...i dont like devini torture at all and frankly i can never accept the fact that devil is repenting for his sins even if nandini accepts him knowing his past...to me devil has not repented fully for his sins...or may be the character was not given more attention...rather used to fill up for leads ka absence...the devil would have been accepted more if there was any depth to his repentance...which i believe ought to have been a gradual process rather than an overnight one...lovely debatable topic i must say...

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Gurti_Maaneet

1 years ago

FATE 3 Updated P 46 on Pg 76 / 7-9-2025

Introduction Small os or ss not decided yet... might be dependent on the response 🤔 I am not sure.

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Queen0fDarkness

2 years ago

Tera Hone Laga Hoon #2 Chapter 74 pg 46 Updated 28/07 Tera Hone Laga Hoon #2 Chapter 74 pg 46 Updated 28/07

Chapter 52 Sameera watched as Maan arrived at her house. He hadn’t visited for a couple of days and Aavya had started asking when her new friend...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Dragon-Heart

2 years ago

Kismat Connection 4 Updated Part 25 on PG 47 / 14-7-2025

INTRODUCTION A new season of this fiction. It's not an FF it's an ss

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Gurti_Maaneet

2 years ago

BROKEN HEARTS 2 Updated P 41 on Pg 86 / 24-8-2025

INTRODUCTION NEW SS FOR MY READERS. FIRST SEASON WAS ORIGINALLY WRITTEN ON MY PAGE. BUT THIS ONE I STARTS HERE. LET'S SEE HOW MUCH YOU...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Dragon-Heart

2 years ago

The Lost Prince MG FF Updated P 37 on Pg 62 / 21-8-2025

Introduction As I already told you that I am going to write period fiction... So here is it... Let's see how is the response. That will decide...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".