did shamit really do politics? - Page 3

well I think this is past.but I strongly believe shamit didn't play any "dirty politics".He was being fair,
But everything is over and we should move on

I think this topic is too exhausted by now..I thot ppl were already convinced tht shamit is not a politician...
But if u want a reply .. then here u go!I wont hesitate to clear shamu's name...

Okay now First of all I fail to understand y javedji continuously stresses on the fact tht shamit alone did it .. shamit alone is bad etc.
At tht point in time others had also voted out kirti..shamit cud no way have done it all by himself..cos its clearly not possible cos he like everyone else only has one vote...Now y the others r not being blamed...I dunno and at this point in time we r alreday hinted abt javed akhtar's unreasonable personal malice against shamit...Y so?... he alone noes...Secondly, if ppl say tht shamit managed to influence arijit it wud also be wrong.. cos they clearly mentioned tht shamit n arijit were togther and all shamit had sed was tht he wud vote 4 gurpreet.Now wud u call this influencing.Shamit cant help it if arijit is so awed by him... and wants to take the same decision as him...Arijit shud have taken a decision 4 himself..He shud have decided wat he wanted...Granted he comes frm a small town and all... but this much sense of discretion.. I think he has..And u neva noe perhaps after hearing shamit say tht he wud vote 4 gurpreet, arijit thot of the idea and after sum pondering decided tht yes it was a good one... so he decided to vote 4 gurpreet..It was not necessarily a case of "shamitbhaiya jiske liye vote karenge main bhi usi ke liye vote karoonga"..All tht hints towards the fact tht shamit did influence arijit was tht shamit did have a 'alibi' so to speak at tht time..But this too i think is a very baseless judgement....

Moving on, Now I believe tht if he did have any intention of playing politics..shudnt his frens have known the characteristics of his personality... during the 2 mths spent with him.. at least one of them shud have guessed at least..but no they all denied and supported shamit..

Next, Is it so hard to comprehend wat shamit had in mind wen he was voting 4 gurpreet?..I dont think so.
Just sympathy and wanting to keep up her morale.. thts all... he proabably thot tht nobody wud vote 4 gurpreet so he decided on humanitarian grounds he shud give his vote 4 gurpreet.. just to boost her morale and keep up her self confidence..How du u think a person wud feel if outta 9 (dunno if the figure is correct)votes he/she got none at all...he/she wud probably feel very dejected...And let me add tht the rest of them also voted 4 gurpreet on the same grounds.. again i fail to understand .. y only shamit was blamed../cos in the end all their so called 'sympathy' votes just caused a bad coincidence and kirti got voted out..sometimes one trieds to ensure tht sumthing good happens but unfortunately they fail miserably!

Continuing, We are already hinted abt javedji's malice against shamit...we can see more in the episode wen he tokes abt shamit's mom saying tht he wants to take advantage of the softer side in everyone so tht they will vote 4 him...Granted the next day he does apologise.. but wat was tht?.. remorse for saying sumthing wrong on tv ..something which was hurtful...The first comment he made was instantaneous...telling us wat javedji has in mind..Moreover, we can confirm the fact tht javedji was highly against shamit by taking the eg of his oust.. wen supposedly shamit voted out kirti.. there was so much of a hue and cry frm his side.. however wen arijit voted out shamit.. tht too this time it was clear arijit had the power to actually choose btween shamit n monica as to who he wud get in..so yes wen arijit voted out shamit ..he merely argued tht " Is stage mein this is ok.. its not right to nip it in the bud".. wat nonsense!!..He just changed his principles in accordance to the person in question...tht is hypocrisy!!!..I think this is enough to tell us abt javedji's persoanl malice against shamit!..Now who stressed on the topic of shamit playing games.. who reprimanded him and insisted tht he was guilty?..javedji...so now a person so well known throughout india can exhibit his malice against an amatuer singer tht too on tv...and he can change his principles in seconds..How much credibility do u think this persons words hold..inspite of him being a public figure..A person who can say sumthing so disgusting in respect to shamit asking 4 sympathy by taking his moms name? Very little i wud say....

Now, i have noticed a few ppl saying tht shamit is a politician cos he speaks well and is able to manipulate ppl..let me add tht it is quality which grew with time ...as u guys noe he gone thru much in life and has had to do odd jobs.. tht automatically makes a person mature..and maturity obviously reflects in ones speech...so r u gonna pin him down for being mature?..Also I wud like to add tht shamit used to in a call centre.. where he gives advice to customers abt the products they bought..A job in which the primary necessity is to have good communication skills..Speaking well is part of his job .... Dont u think he will have good communication skills which have grown with experience in the job?

Also, I wud like put in tht... we can probably use guesswork to tell tht showing shamit as a politician cud have been a marketing gimmick by sony...A very good one in fact.. TRP ratings of FG were very low ... also in comparison to indian idol they were pathetic.. I noe this issue attracted a lot of viewers..But who d blame them...It s human nature to gossip n expect dramaIn fact i m guilty as well..I started watching FG wen i saw all this drama..

Now moving on to dus ke dus...I thot he was very sweet there.. and yes he was showered with votes ... sumthing which he wasnt able to secure much in FG...This i belive is enough to tell us tht ppl have realised tht he is indeed very nice.. just misunderstood to a greta extent in FG..kehte hai naa.. bharatiya janta sab janti hai (anu mallik sed so)...speaking along those lines..I think it is evident tht no shamit dint play politics.. cos public memory is not all tht short..and yes if the public can be convinced... then the verdict is given ...

I hereby conclude tht shamit is not a politician..he was just misunderstood to a great extent!

Bravo!!!!! 👏 ipsitabasu
Hats off to u!!! 👏

mene already apna ans de diya he 😃

Originally posted by: sosweet

very well said sweetz...i agree that sony tv shudnt have showed this inside story of gurukul..
but after watching,we cantstop ourseleves drawing cobnclusions about the contestants....

Shamit is there to sing.....and he should realise that. After all they ALL know they are under a camera watch the entire time and that the whole world is watching them.....Shamit's unnecessary explanations and trying to prove he is good made him villain in people's eyes.


shamit was talkig about Xfactors and all by pointing qazi...and i know shamits politics are exaggerated


qazi who knows that no onelikes him but still how he manages to live with them. hat's off to qazi for his sporting spirit

so we are not left with any other alternative than forming an opinion about these contestants..........

we are forced to form opinions if we stick to the smaller picture, but if we look at an overall picture... every1 was equally evil and nice there... we know that.. because we are so quick to find faults in other pplz favs and defend ours... therefore every1 has their reasons.. the inside story was shown as a purpose of entetainment and an increase in the voting by the public.. so sony can make $$... no1 should be judged based on that... its a television show afterall

IpsitaBasu,Great job.Your answer is so clear

ok lo0ks lik som ppl..are really gettin annoyed wit this question..mumu and othrs lik diksha..sry if our question bothred u..im so sorry...this is jus the question of the week...if u guyz want 2 attack the person who waz responsible 4 this thn thn attack zaara...hehe..kiddin..sry 1 again..

oh sry 2 zaara 2

No he didnt do politics what i think is that arijit the tharki was flipped over gurpreet and he asked shamit to vote for gurpreet so as to spend more time with her... as shown in the secret talk they were once having caught under the camera...
as for Kirti he was not thr friend and they had no emotional attachment with him nor did they like him as he was a bit chipko so got rid of him hahahahaah 😉